I'm not going to quote any Bible verses for you but I am curious. If you believe in God, that He is a loving God, and everything you believe about God, did you not learn that from the Bible? If you believe that part of the Bible, why would you reject other parts of it?
Not all sons and daughters of Adam will have eternal life. Some fraction will face the death that atheists see for themselves - oblivion. It will be to we who are saved as if they had never existed.
This is what the Bible teaches. This is consistent with the loving God of Justice that the Bible teaches us.
This vision of eternal agony is not Biblical. This is Satan lying to us about the character of God.
Its a common fallacy out of the arrogance of men and more than a few cults that God should behave as we expect him.
Its a way that seems right to our limited understanding, but as Jesus recounted the story, we have Moses and the prophets and now with the Gospels we have even more than Lazarus and the rich man had, we are all without excuse,
When Jesus returns its with “the day of vengeance of our God” and the Jubilee, the Beast and False prophet are thrown alive into the lake of fire, Satan only catches up with them 1000 years later,
“And, behold, they cried out, saying, What have we to do with thee, Jesus, thou Son of God? art thou come hither to torment us before the time?” Matthew 8:28