Skip to comments.US military chaplains concerned about freedom of religion
Posted on 06/30/2013 7:17:48 PM PDT by markomalley
Christian religious leaders balefully greeted the Supreme Court decision on June 26 to strike down key provisions of the Defense of Marriage Act, signed in 1996 by President Bill Clinton. In an op-ed, Catholic Archbishop P. Timothy Broglio, who serves as chief chaplain to Catholics in US military service, said that Catholic bishops and the Archdiocese of the Military Services remain "resolved in the belief that no Catholic priest will ever be compelled to condone even silently same-sex marriages.
In a 5-4 decision, the Supreme Court ruled that DOMA treated same-sex marriages as less respected than others, thus violating the Constitutions guarantees of equal protection under federal law. As a result, there is no longer one single definition of marriage for the purposes of the federal government. Individuals states may thus continue to define marriage as they wish, while the federal government must accept the marriages acknowledged by each state. At the present time, only 12 states and the District of Columbia have redefined marriage to include same-sex couples, but efforts are underway to push for a redefinition in other states throughout the country as well.
Archbishop Broglio noted that the Constitution guarantees that no endorsed minister will ever be compelled to perform a religious ceremony contrary to the dictates of his/her faith nor will todays decision have any effect on the role and teaching ability of a priest or deacon in the pulpit, the classroom, the barracks or in the office.
Questions have been raised the the ruling over potential threats to religious freedom. Some religious groups and individuals have come under pressure already to affirm same-sex relationships as marriages, even if doing so violates their religious principles and identity. In states that have legalized same-sex unions, Catholic adoption agencies have opted to close because they would only place children in homes with a married mother and father. Persons who because of their religious convictions recognize only the traditional understanding of marriage as being between only one man and one woman have faced lawsuits, fines and even threatened jail time.
Archbishop William E. Lori of Baltimore, who leads the Catholic bishops' committee on religious freedom committee, said the Supreme Courts ruling poses a serious threat to religious liberty and conscience rights for countless people of faith.
Of particular concern is that the guarantee of religious freedom in the military may be in jeopardy. Military chaplains have already reported harassment and threats of punishment for promoting and defending Church teaching on marriage. Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel said in a statement that the Department of Defense welcomes the Supreme Court's decision today on the Defense of Marriage Act.
Department of Defense intends to make the same benefits available to all military spouses regardless of sexual orientation as soon as possible. That is now the law, and it is the right thing to do.
Chaplains and clergy within the armed services are members of the military and therefore federal employees. It is unknown how the Supreme Courts ruling will apply to military chaplains. When asked in a June 26 press conference how changes will be implemented, Joint Chiefs of Staff chairman General Martin Dempsey said that DoD will assess what that means.
Archbishop Broglio voiced hope in the Constitutions protections of free exercise of religion which ensure that no restrictions or limitations on the teaching of the Catholic faith will be placed on any Catholic priest or deacon in the armed forces. Furthermore, he remains confident that people of this great country, no matter the consequences, will continue to promote and defend the good and the truth of marriage as the union of one man and one woman as husband and wife for life.
Marriage remains what it has always been, regardless of what any government might say, he stressed.
Scouts Out! Cavalry Ho!
The Gay Military. They can “handle” anything.
I have hear Broglio speak. He made a lot of sense then and he does here too.
God bless our military troops who adhere to God’s rules.
Medal of Honor for US Army chaplain Father Kapaun
Army chaplain to get Medal of Honor posthumously (Fr Kapaun)
Chaplain Fr. Emil Kapaun: The Good Thief
Chaplain gets Medal of Honor 62 years after death (Outstanding story)
New: "The Miracle of Father Kapaun: Priest, Soldier and Korean War Hero"
Students Try to Banish Catholic Chaplain >From Campus for Anti-Gay Stance
Archbishop Broglio Delivers Homily of Thanksgiving for Service and Dedication of Pope Benedict XVI
Father Emil Kapaun to be Awarded Medal of Honor
New auxiliary bishop for military archdiocese, Bishop-designate Robert J. Coyle
February 3rd - Four Chaplain's Day
We Have to Go Where The Suffering and Dying Are [Military Chaplains]
We See the Lord in Combat - Remembering Servant of God Father Vincent Capodanno
Lawmakers Claim Air Force Culture Becoming 'Hostile Towards Religion'
Get in Line or Resign Admiral Tells Military Chaplain
A Halo and a Medal for Emil Kapaun?
Prison Mates Promote Cause of Heroic Korean War Priest
Recognition Finally for a Warrior Priest's Heroics
ACTION ITEM ALERT! Pres. Obama, through a minion, attacks Catholic chaplains once again
Airborne Forces Priests Will Make Parachute Jumps During Their Training [Russia]
Religious Speech in the Military: Freedoms and Limitations
Soldier, Chaplain, Shepherd (Auxiliary Bishop Rick Spencer of the U.S. Archdiocese for Military)
Catholics Seek to Boost Number of Priests Serving as Chaplains
Catholic Chaplain Finds UK Troops in Afghanistan Hungering For Religion
U.S. troops in Afghanistan
Cross removed at base in Afghanistan
Mass During Wartime
The Traditional Latin Mass -- in Afghanistan
Uncle Sam attracts more (Catholic) military chaplains
Evangelical Chaplains Refuse to Marry Gay Couples on Military Bases
Over 2,000 Evangelical, Orthodox Chaplains Join Catholics in Opposing Pentagon on Same-Sex Marriage
2,000 Evangelical, Orthodox Chaplains Join Catholics in Opposing Pentagon Directive on SSM
No Same-Sex Weddings at West Point's Catholic Chapel, Says Military Archdiocese
Conflict between Pentagon and Catholic military chaplains brews over dont ask, dont tell
The (Catholic) Church's Noblest at Ground Zero
More men asking about becoming military chaplains
Catholic Caucus: Fr. Emil Kapaun: The Good Thief
Catholic Military Chaplains: America's Forgotten Heroes (Ecumenical)
Fr. Emil Kapaun Beatification Cause Heads to Rome [US Army Chaplain]
Two US Soldier Priests
Chaplain Groups Ask Military to Create Religious Liberty Protections
Australian Padre helps deployed soldiers tackle life challenges (Former SAS soldier turns chaplain)
Army says chaplain is first killed in action since 1970
Army Chaplain Dies in Afghanastan
With God in Iraq: A Day in the Life of a Military Chaplain
Soldier's Death Led Catholic Priest to Become Chaplain
Mass at National Shrine to honor Servant of God and heroic Navy chaplain
Prison chaplain remembers ("Behind the Walls with the Man Behind the Stole")
"Thanks God... and Thanks Mom" (Senate chaplain recalls his mom's amazing last day on earth)
Priest a wartime legend (Most decorated chaplain in Canadian army history dies at 106)
Catholic Navy chaplain shares story of Iraqi conversion (from 12/04/07)
I am ignorant of what Catholic chaplains do in the military now. Do they only minister to Catholics (ie. hold mass, listen to confessions)? Also, do they now celebrate the Sacrament of Matrimony in the military for Catholics?
Yes to all of your questions. They also administer support to non-Catholics who need guidance on whatever problems they have. They obviously can’t provide any confession or give communion to non-Catholics, but they can provide any kinds of psychological needs.
Thanks..one more question. Are they the only religious present? Or are there other Christian ministers there?
Good question. They normally have four chaplains. A Catholic, Protestant (sometimes 2), sometimes a Rabi, and now a days a Muslim.
Again, thanks so much. I needed the answers to those questions to formulate my overall response to this article.
I would *hope* that, in the event, 2 gay Catholics want to get married that they would be required to go to one of the other ministers (who are not against gay marriage).
I would also *hope* that the Catholic chaplain can also advise them of the state of their souls if they do so (ie. the mortal sin they are committing); however, I have to wonder just how many Catholic chaplains actually currently express the need to be a Catholic in good standing though...or if they tend to lean towards the wishy washiness I see more and more of these days.
T have a relative who is the only Chaplin of any kind at the Navy Base in Puerto Rico. He is a Baptist.
xzins is a chaplain. Pinged him to the discussion.
My fear is that the military will deal with any conflict by simply ending the chaplaincy. There is no requirement to have it. That said, it will be clearly unconstitutional to force a minister to function in a government approved manner in the conduct of religious ministry. Most denominations view marriage as religious., so there will be no required weddings. However, I can envision required counseling which is not necessarily viewed as religions in nature.
The catholic chaplains I ever worked with were very faithful to instruct in Catholic doctrine. They all bravely and short handed tried to both run a Catholic parish and cover a military unit.