Skip to comments.Why is Philomena No Longer Considered a Saint?
Posted on 09/12/2013 7:30:16 AM PDT by Weiss White
Q: How is it that the martyr Philomena used to be a saint, but isnt any more? I dont understand how the Church can canonize a saint and then change its mind Mary
A: Philomena is not, and has never been a saint.
Many Catholics erroneously believe that Philomena used to be a saint, and was somehow decanonized by Pope John XXIII in 1961. In fact, the action taken that year by the Congregation of Riteswhich back then had jurisdiction over matters pertaining to the canonization of saintsactually clarified and made more consistent the canonical status of the person commonly known as Saint Philomena, which up to that point had been quite confused. But the surprising refusal of some lay-Catholics to accept the Vaticans pronouncement has subsequently caused the confusion surrounding Philomena to be greater than ever!
(Excerpt) Read more at canonlawmadeeasy.com ...
Then explain the current pope's determination to declare John XXIII a saint.
St. Philolena, pray for the wayward modernist church.
Contrary to popular belief we are not directly affiliated with the Catholic Church, or any diocese or parish. We are however associated with the Catholic Church through our faith lives. The Catholic Company provides us the means to provide for our families and our parish communities. Our staff and their families belong to over 10 parishes in Charlotte, NC and the surrounding area. We also support with our time, talent, and treasure important Catholic organizations throughout our area, including: Belmont Abbey College, Room at the Inn (a home for pregnant single women), and the Knights of Columbus.
They haven't gotten the memo yet ..
"Saint Philomena is the patron of babies, orphans, test takers, youth, and impossible causes. Very little is known about her life as she was martyred in the early years of the Church at the age of fourteen. Saint Philomena's shrine in Mugnano has had numerous cures attributed to it since 1805. She is the only person to be recognized as a Saint solely on the basis of miraculous intercession. St. Philomena's feast day is August 11th.."
post to the “Questions no one is asking” thread pls
There is a St. Philomena parish in Torrance, CA. They wouldn’t have a parish named after her if she weren’t a saint.
What evidence do you have against Pope John XXIII that would thwart his canonization?
Got to remember that Blessed John XXIII is going to be declared a saint on the same day, next Divine Mercy Sunday as Blessed John Paul II. Blessed John XXIII going for the ride in other words, while the bigger focus will be on Blessed John Paul II being declared a saint. Blessed JP II will be famous for making popular the divine mercy devotion.
I belong to a parish, St. Christopher’s in which at one time declared not a saint.
What’s up with St. Christopher? Has he been reinstated as a Saint? My brother Chris was pretty disappointed when it was decided that there was not enough evidence that St. Christopher really lived and had done what was attributed to him.
I have no evidence to thwart canonization. We don't have a "devil's advocate" any more so as far as I know no one has evidence to thwart canonization.
But the burden of proof is on those advocating canonization. Ordinarily, two verified miracles due to the candidate's intervention are required for canonization. Pope Francis has waived this requirement for John XXIII.
John Paul II however does have two verified miracles.
I believe he was by Pope John Paul II.
Ordinarily, two verified miracles due to the candidate’s intervention are required for canonization. Pope Francis has waived this requirement for John XXIII.
He only waived the need for the second verified miracle didn’t he?
My mother’s real name was Filomina and nobody named kids after people who weren’t saints.
She is still a saint. She may not be in the new Roman Missal, but she is still a saint.
St. Christopher is still a saint too.
St. Christopher here>
St. Philomena here
So much for the bogus Roman Catholic unity, eh???
I thought all this talk of “decanonizing” saints is really just a pragmatic matter of not enough days in the year for feast days for all of them.
Just because the Missal doesn’t list St. Christopher or any other saint that got bumped doesn’t reflect some kind of reversal of their status.
My wife is the Confirmation Director there. Very active Christ centered Parish. There are 450 teens in Confirmation year 1 and 2 classes. Maybe that’s a miracle whether Philomena is a Saint or not!
What are the popular confirmation names this year?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.