Posted on 11/07/2001 3:49:17 PM PST by jocon307
Jersey Lessons What Schundler did wrong.
By Rick Shaftan, president, Neighborhood Research/Mountaintop Media November 7, 2001 9:50 a.m.
Compassionate Conservatism” bombs again in New Jersey.
With a message designed to "reach out to minorities in the inner cities," Bret Schundler joined a legion of other Republicans who failed at trying to reinvent the wheel. Schundler got exactly the same 42 percent vote G. W. Bush received last year — almost exactly district by district — and proved once again that Republican efforts to attract urban black votes are counterproductive.
Schundler's message of "empowerment" didn't attract black votes and turned off the white, Catholic, suburban men. And without the energized white, Catholic, suburban male vote, you cannot win as a conservative in a state like New Jersey. That's why as many as a third of conservatives pulled the Democratic lever yesterday and many, particularly in the northwest counties, stayed home.
After running an excellent primary election, Schundler made a number of mistakes:
1) Pandering to the Franks voters. All the Tom Keans, Bob Franks, Don DiFrancescos, Christie Whitmans, and other liberal Republicans added up to only 130,000 votes — 20,000 fewer votes than third-party candidates Murray Sabrin and Rich Pezzullo won in 1997. Once the Franks party machine was defeated they had proven to the world their powerlessness. But the Schundler campaign didn't get the message, spending half their effort trying to win just five percent of the electorate. This might explain why exit polls were showing 30 percent of conservatives voting for McGreevey.
2) Not helping Bill Schluter, the independent running for governor, get matching funds. With two liberal candidates in the debates, McGreevey would have had to watch his left flank for defections to Schluter, making it easier for Schundler to define McGreevey as a liberal. Early polling indicated that Schluter's votes would have come overwhelmingly from McGreevey.
3) Mishandling the gun issue. Pennsylvania and Connecticut have the same "right to carry" laws that Schundler first said he supported, then said he didn't. Changing his position was bad enough, but the obsession with being defensive on guns and repeating it in virtually every ad, debate, and campaign appearance had to keep 10,000-20,000 gun owners home — or maybe even voting for McGreevey — especially those gun owners who are also union members.
4) Being afraid of the right-to-life issue. Exit polls show that voters who voted on the abortion issue supported Schundler by more than 10 points, yet the Schundler campaign refused to attack McGreevey on his radical abortion stance, a move that might have helped boost numbers in solidly pro-life areas.
5) Letting McGreevey define himself as a moderate. Schundler's passive press office did nothing while newspaper articles repeatedly referred to McGreevey as a "moderate" or "centrist" Democrat. One survey showed that only 23 percent of voters thought McGreevey was a liberal while 42 percent said he was "moderate." Amazingly (or maybe not), 13 percent said that Schundler was a liberal. McGreevey won 5-1 among those voters who thought him a moderate and 4-1 among those who thought him a conservative (8 percent). There's nothing wrong with being a right-wing extremist as long as the other guy is a left-wing extremist. You cannot win as a conservative if you do not define your opponent as a liberal. And you cannot define your opponent as a liberal unless you are a conservative to begin with.
6) Panic and react. More gripes about the press office. No one really paid much attention to the Saturday article in September where Schundler criticized DiFrancesco's handling of the September 11th attack until the Schundler campaign verbally attacked the reporter who wrote it, calling attention to a gaffe that no one would have noticed. Another time, Schundler said he would sign a law — that has 80 percent support — ending government-funded abortions. The panicky reactive press office immediately put out a statement saying it wasn't true, which not only became a news story in itself, but a bad one.
7) The obsession with the black vote. Bret Schundler went to the left of McGreevey on the racial profiling and attacked him for "not hiring enough minorities in Woodbridge" (on the Bob Grant show of all places.) For this, Schundler won 12 percent of the black vote. This proves once more that Bush won in spite of "compassionate conservatism" not because of it.
8) Failure to target men. Men are the Republican base and Schundler's obsession with "gender gap" issues like gun control showed why men weren't energized enough to try to convince their wives to vote for Schundler.
9) Mail and phones instead of TV and radio.Whoever came up with this strategy was really responsible for the debacle. And what few TV ads were run were weak and pathetic. The mail was awful, wordy, and ridiculous.
10) Closing "on a positive note."Schundler ended with a wimpy ad featuring an endorsement from someone from out of state (Giuliani); fitting for a campaign that held most of its big fundraisers out of state.
11) Taking the summer off.McGreevey hustled all summer and showed that he wanted to win more. By early October, instead of being a pro-abortion liberal, McGreevey was a moderate-to-conservative Democrat.
12) Pathetic fundraising.All last night I heard people whining that, "we didn't have the money." There's no excuse for an arm breaker like Bret Schundler, who could raise millions as mayor and various pet projects, to not raise tens of millions or more as the Republican nominee. The fundraising should have started primary night when he had a captive audience fueled with adrenaline and alcohol, ready to break out checks and credit cards. There was no reason why the Schundler campaign shouldn't have raised the maximum in two weeks.
13) The debates.After scoring a near knockout in the first debate, Schundler got progressively worse until he completely bombed in the only primetime debate. And who could blow the "ask your opponent a question" question? I've never seen a candidate lead with his opponent's main issue and manage to offend both sides of the issue — and do it again and again. Guns. Guns. Guns.
14) Mishandling the education issue. To Schundler, "education" meant urban education and school choice. This does not appeal to either the suburban parent who lives 30 miles from Jersey City or the Jersey City parent who doesn't want Our Lady of Victories opened up to everyone from Ward F who walks in with a voucher. There's a reason why immigrants from all over the world send their kids to Jersey City Catholic schools and it doesn't have to do with the religious training. Completely unaddressed was Christie Whitman's troublesome "core curriculum." On hot-button issues, Schundler was silent.
The lesson? Republicans should secure the base first. Energize them and they will come out on Election Day. Reinventing the wheel isn't worth the time or effort.
Apparently, the Schundler camp knew that the rumors that McGreevey is a closeted homosexual were true. They chose not to use this. IMHO, this was a mistake. New Jersey is heavily catholic. While pro-choice is something that catholics tend to split over, they do not split very often over the issue of homosexuality. It is a sin and most catholics still believe this. The fact that it was also a secret also brings up the issue of lying to the voters.
They could have and should have used this.
I myself believe that
9) Mail and phones instead of TV and radio.Whoever came up with this strategy was really responsible for the debacle
hits the nail best.
New Jersey was INUNDATED with McGreevey ads, bang-banging constantly and shrieking that "Schundler wants to put assault weapons back on the street!" - while Schundler had few radio and TV spots, and what he had was very low key.
I'm afraid it's true about advertising, that lots of noise and constant repetition wins the day.
McGreevey did make a public statement today that he's going to work harder than he ever has not to raise taxes, but he may not be able to hold the line. Now, who does THAT sound like. He didn't waste any time either. Bend over New Jersey. The Dems never learn. Neither do the voters.
The Democrats learned LONG AGO that Southern Democrats were entirely different than the NE Liberal and CA wierd Democrats. Republicans tend to want all Republicans to be alike. Jesse Helms could not have been elected from NY, , VT, etc. In fact, Jesse Helms might not be electable if he was starting NOW given the current situation in North Carolina.
BTW, I agree with you about Schundler. For such a good-looking, well-educated obviously intelligent man, he did a miserable job in the debates. I think the RNC needs to set up a Debating department, because frankly it is not a strong point of the party. I suggested that perhaps GWB could give Schundler an appointment somewhere and give him some broad exposure.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.