Skip to comments.Research Shows Dogs Can Comprehend Words
Posted on 06/10/2004 10:41:32 AM PDT by KentTrappedInLiberalSeattle
WASHINGTON (AP) -- As many a dog owner will attest, our furry friends are listening. Now, for the doubters, there is scientific proof they understand much of what they hear.
German researchers have found a border collie named Rico who understands more than 200 words and can learn new ones as quickly as many children.
Patti Strand, an American Kennel Club board member, called the report "good news for those of us who talk to our dogs."
"Like parents of toddlers, we learned long ago the importance of spelling key words like bath, pill or vet when speaking in front of our dogs," Strand said. "Thanks to the researchers who've proven that people who talk to their dogs are cutting-edge communicators, not just a bunch of eccentrics."
The researchers found that Rico knows the names of dozens of play toys and can find the one called for by his owner. That is a vocabulary size about the same as apes, dolphins and parrots trained to understand words, the researchers say.
Rico can even take the next step, figuring out what a new word means.
The researchers put several known toys in a room along with one that Rico had not seen before. From a different room, Rico's owner asked him to fetch a toy, using a name for the toy the dog had never heard.
The border collie, a breed known primarily for its herding ability, was able to go to the room with the toys and, seven times out of 10, bring back the one he had not seen before. The dog seemingly understood that because he knew the names of all the other toys, the new one must be the one with the unfamiliar name.
"Apparently he was able to link the novel word to the novel item based on exclusion learning, either because he knew that the familiar items already had names or because they were not novel," said the researchers, led by Julia Fischer of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig.
A month later, he still remembered the name of that new toy three out of six times, even without having seen it since that first test. That is a rate the scientists said was equivalent to that of a 3-year-old.
Rico's learning ability may indicate that some parts of speech comprehension developed separately from human speech, the scientists said.
"You don't have to be able to talk to understand a lot," Fischer said. The team noted that dogs have evolved with humans and have been selected for their ability to respond to the communications of people.
Katrina Kelner, Science's deputy editor for life sciences, said "such fast, one-trial learning in dogs is remarkable. This ability suggests that the brain structures that support this kind of learning are not unique to humans and may have formed the evolutionary basis of some of the advanced language abilities of humans."
Perhaps, although Paul Bloom of Yale University urges caution.
"Children can understand words used in a range of contexts. Rico's understanding is manifested in his fetching behavior," Bloom writes in a commentary, also in Science.
Bloom calls for further experiments to answer several questions: Can Rico learn a word for something other than a small object to be fetched? Can he display knowledge of a word in some way other than fetching? Can he follow an instruction not to fetch something?
Fischer and her colleagues are still working with Rico to see if he can understand requests to put toys in boxes or to bring them to certain people. Rico was born in December 1994 and lives with his owners. He was tested at home.
Funding for this research was provided in part by the German Research Foundation.
Any others...? :)
Dogs know dup threads when they see them
Border Collies are quite smart, that's part of the reason they excel at Training/Agility Competitions.
My Golden, on the other hand is about as smart as a Box of Rocks, but lovable nonetheless.
[::shrugs::] "Ees not my chob, man." :)
Couldn't spell 'walk' in front of our last dog, she knew what it meant and would get excited enough to start knocking things over in her rush toget out.
er ... huh?
The key to the experiment was that the dog was a Border Collie.
We had a Border Collie, Barney, (who died of cancer). He was smarter than us, and had more stamina than any two dogs combined that we have owned in the past.
I can recall that while he was still a pup, he would come into the house and my wife would say "dirty feet"!, and he would run to the bathroom and jump into the tub.
Okay, no more puppy stories! (I can here the "aww how sweet" reactions from here! LOL
xs2pup most certainly can comprehend my words!
But is there research to show that Democrats can comprehend economics? ^
Put Gloria Feldt in there, the head of PParenthood, who came up with the "Choice on Earth" abortion Christmas card...
Research shows that this article has been previously posted!
Cats can too...they just don't care about anything you say.
1.) I'll be a "professional" searcher the day you (or someone else) offers to pay me for performing said task, thanks.
2.) Deeeeeep, regular breaths. You get yourself bent all out of shape over piddly stuff like this: you ain't never gonna survive the rigors of Election Night, this year. :)
Perhaps you misunderestimate your Golden's intelligence. S/he is smart enough to get out of a heck of a lot of work assignments you've tried giving him/her. That's pretty smart, IMO.
"Fetch? You talkin' ta me? I ain't got a clue, honey. Pass me another one a' those buscuits, wouldja?"
They're not nearly as perceptive as reptiles, who are smart enough to stay out of your damn way and not shed like a banshee whenever they traipse around your furniture.
I am already annoyed with preparations for recounts and court action this fall. But the consolation is that if Bush steals this election, too, then he will be able to run again in '12 and '16.
Your village is calling. They've lost their idiot.
I have a cat that molts when you look at him..
My dog was rather good at not shedding all over the furniture.
However, when she was covered in mud, wetfrom rain, or blanketed with burrs she'd rub against the couch.
My sis in law has a golden, they are lovey puppies! However, we nicknamed him baby hugie because he doesn't realize how big and powerful he is and will knock you down when trying to greet you!
I'll stick with collies, and agree they are really smart...
Research shows my dog understands the word, 'DUH', too.
The dog I had growing up, a mutt, was the exact same way. You couldn't spell the word 'walk' without him going nuts. He was the same way with the word Moped. I would take him for rides on my Spree (what a site to see!) and I couldn't say or spell the word without him heading to the actual moped to get ready. Riding on the moped was his favorite thing in the world...
The big shepard across the street was trained to never go beyond the periphery of his yard and I NEVER saw him elsewhere until I heard my runaway puppy crying at my door. When I opened the door, there was my puppy laying on his back, frozen in fear. The wonderful shepard was standing over him. Puppy never ran away again!!
Hey now, dogs are usually cute. ;)
Does the salted gas grenade show any signs of this?
I had a neighbor with a standard poodle. Smartest dog I ever saw. I could tell it to go get a hat and it would look all over the house until it found a hat and brought it back to me. Same thing with slippers, socks, balls, bones, dollys, etc. It make it more amazing, it could distinguish between slippers and shoes or you could say caps or hats and the dog knew you meant the same thing. Also if you asked for a slipper or a hat it would bring you one, but if you asked for slippers or hats, it would bring you two. To make it all the more interesting, a complete stranger could tell this to the dog and the dog would understand the words, so it was not the tone or inflection of the words spoken by the dog's owner. It seemed to me the dog actually understood the meaning of the word itself.
Aside from some crippling allergies, among other things, she doesn't seem to have much of a problem dealing with him. Though it is stressing her out a little bit.
Personally, I like her hamster a lot more.
My friend's dog, named "Stupid", just took a whirlwind ride through a 48" culvert. Yup, came out breech. That's STUPID!
I can't use the word swim without my golden freaking out. If I happen to open a car door with him outside, he's in the car giving me the "look".
Dog stories on FR. Has it gotten kinder and gentler here? I didn't think so.
My dog is a genius
I could tell you stories but I don't want to make other dog owners feel bad :>)
Border Collie bump!
Omigawd... they're freaking ADORABLE -- ! :)
We're pretty sure he knows what "Dear God almighty, what's that smell?" means.
The dog I own now is so sagacious that he can actually unwind himself from a post, patiently going around and around until he's free. I've never seen a dog that could do that kind of thing. It's amazing, because in order to get what he wants he actually has to move away from the the object he's seeking. That, to my mind, requires some kind of foresight.
I'll bet. He probably hears that at least twice a day!
LOL!! Too right! We had a golden who somehow couldn't hear us calling her to come in from the yard, but she'd hear a pop-top from a mile away on a hot summer day...she loved to drink a little beer off the patio stones!
I suspect our current two are just as smart, and "willful"...hehe!
Other words one couldn't spell or say in the dog's prescence: out, food, play.
Spelling them backwards provided some slight relief from being trampled upon or drooled on, but that didn't last long.
Dog riding on a moped?
Wish I could've seen that.
(Got to see my uncle drive his 'girlfriend' who was "A real dog" in his orange Nova affectionately called the Orange Peel. He was cleaning the car and the dog hopped in and wouldn't get out until he drove around the block.)
The Molting One is my wife's cat.
He suffers from nervous delusions I think.
He does the nervous shedding thing, and runs from his own tail when he sees it move.
When we had the dog, he seemed to think she was okay, if a bit on the drooly side.
(Even if he did leave his molted fur on her nose thus making the dog sneeze uncontrollably.)
Cat that's that old?
It's the most remarkable thing you'll ever see.
It's kind of like that dog on
I think its name was "Rags", though I'm not positive.
Some of my friends have dogs, including my friend Pepper, who has a little pug.
I'm not sure how his girlfriend feels about that, but I guess she's put up with it to this point in time.
Currently I don't have a dog.
Not sure when and if I'll ever have another one.
I have a 24 pound cat, and that precludes owning anything smaller than a Corgi.
The cat would eat anything smaller or similar to her size/mass.
That leaves me looking for a dog in a husky/hound size class.
It's always good to keep those "replacement" dogs in stock; just in case an unforeseen accident occurs.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.