Posted on 12/30/2004 3:29:06 PM PST by Alex Marko
Jacob, philosophically in general and specifically for this situation I do believe that decentralization works best. The formerly communist countries are used to a very centralized and nationally controlled system in almost every facet of life. The inherent inefficiencies & unresponsive nature of that system were exacerbated in Yugoslavia by widespread mistrust in its impartiality and fairness when Milosevic took over on the strength of Serbian nationalism. As one result, every consitituent part that could split did so: Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia, Macedonia, and Kosovo; and now Montenegro is making noise about doing the same. They all just wanted to manage their own affairs and that's what Kosovo wants as well.
Our state & local governments raise taxes, pay for, and control their own schools, colleges, libraries, museums, police, fire departments, parks, public buildings, elections, road building & maintenance, court systems, etc; establish & enforce most criminal, minor offense & traffic laws, set & enforce health ordinances & zoning. What's wrong with letting the Kosovars do that? And then privatize the state controlled businesses so the government cannot a la Milosevic hire & fire based on ethnicity & party affiliation. Giving Kosovo Province a free enterprise system and the equivalent authority we give our states & local governments would solve most of the complaints that led to their declaration of independence in 1992. (BTW, none of their complaints or current plans have anything to do with Islam; contrary to the silliness spouted by Serbs & their apologists seeking ex post facto exculpation for the atrocities they committed under Slobo.)
"Our state & local governments raise taxes, pay for, and control their own schools, colleges, libraries, museums, police, fire departments, parks, public buildings, elections, road building & maintenance, court systems, etc; establish & enforce most criminal, minor offense & traffic laws, set & enforce health ordinances & zoning. What's wrong with letting the Kosovars do that?"
Not a thing.
"And then privatize the state controlled businesses so the government cannot a la Milosevic hire & fire based on ethnicity & party affiliation."
Local Serbs and other ethnic minorities will probably like the idea for the reason you gave above.
"Giving Kosovo Province a free enterprise system and the equivalent authority we give our states & local governments would solve most of the complaints that led to their declaration of independence in 1992."
Maybe, but some of the problems are no doubt rooted in militant ethnic nationalism. THough Milosevic's actions definetely didn't help one bit and only made things worse. Now that more moderate people like Kostunica are in power, the Kosovor Albanians might be more willing to settle for a sort of compromise.
No doubt the Yugoslav security forces in Kosovo would be recruited entirely from local people.
The Serbian government may be more fully responsible for the administration of ethnic Serb majority areas, like Leposavic or maybe Stripce. Also for the sites of historic and religious significance...such as the various monastaries.
True. And that's why I think former KLA leaders Haradinaj & Thaci are better suited to make peace than Rugova. The militants are more likely to listen to them.
Now that more moderate people like Kostunica are in power, the Kosovor Albanians might be more willing to settle for a sort of compromise.
I think so, except that Kostunica has his own domestic political problems on Kosovo. He is in power based on a coalition with the Serb Radical Party. They are hard-liners on Kosovo and would not likely support a compromise.
No doubt the Yugoslav security forces in Kosovo would be recruited entirely from local people.
Again, the U.S. with our National Guard in each state provides a pretty good model. It is trained & equipped by the federal government, but commanded by each state's governor and the state has complete control to use its guard for disaster relief, riot control, etc.
The Serbian government may be more fully responsible for the administration of ethnic Serb majority areas, like Leposavic or maybe Stripce. Also for the sites of historic and religious significance...such as the various monastaries.
They'll have to hammer that stuff out--I'm a big believer in mixed security forces, in this case meaning Albs & Serbs. Helps some to build personal relationships, but even more they keep each other honest & acting professionaly.
I'm sorry, but when did Kosovo become independent? I must have missed that one. Oh, this is the neocon Economist. Yup, Kosovo, another neocon victory.
Dioxine poisoned?
Mark,your logic is based on flawed information and does not work in former Yugoslavia:
In 1948, Yugoslavia got out of Soviet orbit. That was 56 years ago.
In 1956 citizens were encouraged to spend their disposable income
In 1963, 1963 constitution dismantled command ecconomy and introduced federalism. That was 41 years ago.
In 1974 (1974 constitution) dismantled federalism and introduced regionalism.
Simply put, ALMOST NO ONE OF WORKING AGE on the territory of former Yugoslavia remembers firsthand "very centralized and nationally controlled system in almost every facet of life. For many, it existed before they were born. Like segregation in U.S.A.
If you are so interested in the Balkans, perhaps you should read some reputable history books and leave Cold war drill manuals and Albanian propaganda aside.
The fact is that Albanians have ABUSED Regionalism given to Kosovo by 1974 Constitution. Kosovo authonomy was not taken away because Albanians were harrasing and ethically cleansing Serbs but because IMF figured out Kosovo under Albanians will not be able to
1. pay off loans Albanian communists splurged instead of invested
2. control fiscal spending and swelled employment without ecconomic results.
Milosevich the banker merely acted as an agent of IMF. This fact is hidden behinde the barrage of "authonomy stripped from Albanians".
Parasitic culture has taken roots in Kosovo for decades under communism and continued to the present day. Business 'practicess" of graft, sabotage and outright theft are as common as line of credit in the west. Even Westerners who come to Kosovo become part of it.
Out of 100,000+ who were so far in Kosovo, did anyone bothered to ask what happened with the property of 300 000+ citizens who were chased away when NATO entered province? How many refused to rent stolen property?
Because of all this, it is not surprising that after tens of billions of foreign aid spent on 2 MILLION PEOPLE after 1999, there is no 24/7 water and electricity supply in Kosovo. Kosovo would look the same even with Emirates budget.
Kosovo, is not independent. Its a UN protectorate state. In order for it to become independent, it has to have a new UN sec. counsil resolution adopted w/o a veto from Russia or china. Do the words...."yah right" sound appropriate? This is what happens when you have ex-nightclub bouncers(Haradinaj) as influencial leaders negotiating with professional politicians...you get hoodwinked.
He got his training thanks to x42 who spent a few billion aiding and abeting the KLA terrorists..............once GWB got elected, the KLA criminals started getting thrown behind bars.........somehow this killer escaped Kfor's net.
nope - under the MTA and UNSCR 1244 it is part of Serbia
You're right, legally it is serbias under 1244. But, it is run by the UN, Serbia has no say so in affairs as of now.
strictly speaking UNSCR 1244 means that the UN has to enforce Serbian law there
"somehow this killer escaped Kfor's net."
Kofi Annan probably hid him in the basement of the UN building until the coast was clear.
More likely it was Democrats in the US Congress who took 'campaign contributions' from DioGuardia's PAC who intervened
So this Islamic murderer wears a business suit and the EUro liberals are impressed. Is he eating the UN lobster, caviar and champaign yet?
Never bet on black and never bet on Islam
nice nick name...reminicent of uncle enver?
for Kosovo to get independence, a new UN mandate has to pass the security council with russia and china holding veto power. Not likely when you look at chechnya and Taiwan.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.