Posted on 05/25/2005 9:04:12 PM PDT by ambrose
Officers raid wrong house - Resident says family traumatized
By: WILLIAM FINN BENNETT - Staff Writer
MURRIETA ---- When Mapleton resident Rodolfo Celis heard a knock on his door last Saturday night, he said he never suspected anything was amiss.
That is, until he opened the door and looked down the barrel of a rifle.
Several Murrieta police officers then entered his home in the 33500 block of Eugenia Lane, he said. They herded the 54-year-old father and five of his family members, including two young children, into the living room and sat them on a couch at gunpoint, he added.
"They didn't even show me a warrant or ask permission, they just pointed rifles," Celis said, adding that the officers then proceeded to search the house and garage for a suspect and automatic weapons.
The six officers believed a parolee armed with automatic weapons was inside the home and that was the reason they entered the house without a warrant, Murrieta police Lt. Bob Davenport said Friday.
"He was considered armed and dangerous," Davenport said. And in cases of that type, a search warrant is not necessary, the lieutenant said, adding that "at some point," Celis gave them permission to search the remainder of the house.
There was just one problem. They had the wrong house.
The Celis home is next door to the house officers intended to search, Davenport said.
The events leading up to officers arriving at Celis' home began earlier Saturday. Murrieta officers received word that a black sport utility vehicle ---- with automatic weapons and other guns inside ---- was parked in front of a Temecula home. The report from their Temecula counterparts indicated that officers believed the vehicle belonged to an at-large parolee, who was listed as living at the house next door to the Celises in Murrieta.
When officers arrived on Eugenia around 9 p.m. Saturday, they thought that the man they were looking for was armed and dangerous. They counted the houses from the corner of Mapleton Street and Eugenia Lane and believed that the numbering sequence of the houses on the street indicated that Celis' house was the right address, although the darkness may have made it difficult to check the exact number on the house, Davenport said.
"They couldn't light it up with a flashlight to verify the numbers, because that would put them at a tactical disadvantage," he said.
As they walked toward what they thought was the right home, they saw a black sports utility vehicle parked in the driveway.
Asked whether the officers had checked to see if the license plate matched the one at the Temecula address, Davenport said he was not sure whether Murrieta officers had a license plate number for the SUV seen in Temecula.
The lieutenant said there was also some uncertainty as to whether the license plate number that was reported in fact belonged to the SUV or another vehicle that had been towed away from the same address about 30 days before. But the SUV did match the description of the one seen at the Temecula address, he said.
"All the SUV does is verify in their minds that they are at the right house," Davenport said. "It was just a piece, but not a critical part of the puzzle."
Officers also were suspicious when they heard people talking in the Celis' garage, he added.
"They assumed they had the right location," he said.
He confirmed that Celis told the officers that the man they were looking for, Johnny Lopez, 25, had never lived at his house. Celis told the officers that a man matching Lopez's description had lived next door.
"Not until they left the house did they realize that the address didn't match," Davenport said.
Celis said his family is still traumatized by what happened. The memory of having guns pointed at his entire family won't fade easily, he added.
His 15-year-old son was terrified, Celis said. Seeing the boy's fear that night, Celis said he felt powerless and mortified that he could do nothing to protect him.
"When I saw my son's face, I felt ashamed because I wasn't doing what a dad is supposed to do," Celis, 54, said. "I felt like I should have protected my kids."
Celis' son Rudy said that on the night of the raid, he came into the living room to see what the commotion was and, "they told me to put my hands up; they searched me and were asking, 'Where is Johnny Lopez?'"
Rudy's sister-in-law, Jennifer Celis, said she couldn't believe that the family was treated like common criminals.
"They were pointing rifles at us," she said.
When Jennifer asked the officers why they had come to their house, that night, "they kept telling us to shut up, shut up and wouldn't tell us what they were looking for."
Now, Celis is thinking about hiring an attorney to look into the matter, he said.
"I am not looking for any money, but I would like to at least alert the community so they know we're not criminals," Celis said. "I would like the Police Department, before they do something like that again, to make sure they are going to the right house."
He said he can't help but wonder whether the officers came to his home because his family is the only Latino family living on the street. A group of Latino people lived in the house where the officers were supposed to go Saturday night, Celis said. But he added that those people moved out of the neighborhood a few months ago.
"I think they saw my family coming in and out of the house and because we are the only Latino family on the block, they thought this was the place," he said.
Davenport denied that race played any role in what happened.
He said that when the officers approached the home, they had no idea that a Latino family was living there.
"Of course it was a mistake, but they were under the assumption that they were at the right house and were within their legal bounds," he said. "That's a mistake we will explain (to Celis) and apologize for; we are all human and are going to err on occasion."
Asked if the mistake will generate any policy or procedural changes within the department, Davenport said: "We are going to review what happened and make a decision on what to do in the future."
On Friday afternoon a police sergeant who participated in the search called Celis to apologize for the mistake.
"I accepted his apologies, but I keep thinking what would have happened if one of my kids had gotten scared and tried to run ---- somebody could have been shot," Celis said.
Contact staff writer William Finn Bennett at (951) 676-4315, Ext. 2624, or wbennett@californian.com.
Years ago, we had enough sense to contact the mail man to point out the right house. It worked in white neighborhoods as well as non-white locales.
Yeah, their disadvantage weighed against the LETHAL DANGER they put an innocent family in. Maybe someone should inform the cops that taking risks in defense of innocent citizens is all part of their job.
Let's just hope no officers were traumatized in this incident.
I know you're being sarcastic.. but every once in a while, a cop does get busted for abusing his authority... so guess what the cop does then? He goes on permanent disability for "stress" !!!!
Don't you fell safe from terrorists, knowing that your local police dept has some shiny new APCs?
Nail every one of the cops who organized and led this raid to a wall. Bursting into the wrong house is like operating on the wrong patient. I have no sympathy nor any patience with such ineptitude and one mistake like this is enough, in my view, to disqualify these cops from ever serving in law enforcement.
Late night freeping
Breaking and entering, false imprisonment, and using a fire arm in the commission of a felony.
You lock up a few "wrong house" jackboot LEO's with their badge in hand, this crap will come to a screaching halt.
The standard MO for this BS =
A few broken doors and maybe a few windows, a few dead pets, a completely botched attempt at apprehending a bad guy and volumns of trampled constitutional rights, terrified citizens with mental scars worth years of therapy and when lucky you get to live, with an apology and a warning not to disguise your house again to look just like your neighbors in moon light.
Welcome to Germany 1941.
Chalk up the increasing errors to hiring diversity.
Quotas.
"I don't know what a distict attorney would do to the poor bastard who unwittingly kills a cop under such circumstances, but I certainly have my suspicions."
The lefties would have a field day, claiming this to be a perfect example of why citizens should not bear arms.
My mapping program is better than the cops on the ground.
Why recon when you can rambo it?
This is indeed a terrible situation and the police should take steps to see this does not happen again. However, as an earlier poster mentioned, the police did knock first and it appears they were polite. The police heard voices in the garage which is highly suspicious. Also, the homeowner was able to identify the crook, so maybe they were buddies and who knows what kind of things they did together. Finally, the house appears to be in a ghetto area which probably has a lot of shootings and crime, so how traumatized could the family be? What the police did was wrong, but the homeowner has to take his share of responsibility as well.
Being the patient person that I am, I'm wondering what the exigent circumstances here were. If they were acting on a belief instead of factors requiring immediate action, ie: they saw the guy through the window or he ran into the house when police arrived, then they should of had a warrant developed though other sources of info. There may be some missing details here on that issue. So I'd say they screwed up in others ways too besides freaking out the Celis family. Thanks for the ping.
...and those requirements would have been for the correct house.
Ah, everyone knows what happens when you assume.
"Thinking isn't knowing"
"All the SUV does is verify in their minds that they are at the right house,"
a black sport utility vehicle ---- with automatic weapons and other guns inside ---
Ah, the evil SUV effect. A black SUV, the most evil sort of SUV, plotting, lurking, corrupting, foulest of all SUVs
52 Krankor wrote "Also, the homeowner was able to identify the crook, so maybe they were buddies and who knows what kind of things they did together"
--- However, Celos didn't know or identify Lopez -- 'He (the victim)said he can't help but wonder whether the officers came to his home because his family is the only Latino family living on the street. A group of Latino people lived in the house where the officers were supposed to go Saturday night, Celis said. But he added that those people moved out of the neighborhood a few months ago ... Celis told the officers that the man they were looking for, Johnny Lopez, 25, had never lived at his house. Celis told the officers that a man matching Lopez's description had lived next door. "
IMHO matching a description means nothing until we know what the description was. Was the description "male, average height, slender build, dark hair" or was it "male, 6 ft tall, 140 - 160 pounds, brown hair normally cut short parted on left side, appears to be of latin ancestry, inked on upper left arm with serpent". Both hypotheticals could be word pictures of the same person.
Krankor also paraphrased from the article that 'The police heard voices in the garage which is highly suspicious.'
--- I'll be sure never to talk in my garage again
Krnako "What the police did was wrong, but the homeowner has to take his share of responsibility as well"
--- Which was what, not being the perp that the cops were looking for? Being Latino outside of the barrio?
If you do nothing wrong, you have nothing to fear.
Why should this be assumed to be bungling? Maybe the house was under a Double Secret Subpoena.
That's the best analogy I've seen in years.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.