Skip to comments.A little help needed here for a school project
Posted on 11/14/2005 4:38:45 PM PST by roostercogburn
My 14 year old son has been given a project to design a memorial to the fallen soldiers of the Iraq war. It must be designed as though it will be built on the Mall in Washington D.C. which means it must follow the same design restrictions that applied to the Vietnam Memorial. It must Honor the memory of those who served and those who gave their lives. Be harmonious with the Mall and its surroundings. Somehow fit into the "historic continuity" of American art. Be durable, buildable and not hard to maintain. Please , any ideas would be appreciated.
Your son should thoroughly research the reasons leading up to the war and the justification for the war so that he can defend any decisions he makes. When he understands WHY we needed to go to war with Hussein, he will be able to design a thoughtful and meaningful ( at least to him ) monument
IMO these teachers are instigators. They come back to the schools from the universities carrying a bunch of baggage, then try to get the kids to carry it for them.
It should also show that they are freeing millions of people. Good luck.
A soldier with his rifle on guard, while another behind him holds a small Iraqi girl(or hands something to a child).
The best way to achieve peace is by vanquishing your enemy on the battle field.
How about the feet of the Saddam statue that were left standing when they pulled the rest of the thing down?
I refer you to my idea. ;)
Typical liberal. Cant put aside politics about the war to honor those who are brave enough to defend our freedom. While im sure those who have fought wouldn't think this, i dont think she deserves to be called an American along with our brave soldiers.
I'd suggest avoiding crescents as part of the design...
That would be very nice.
Suggestion: Let your son do his own assignment.
Wanna really make trouble? Have two soldiers, one black and one white, comforting an Iraqi boy and girl. Behind the soldiers, an angel. the inscription on the base of the monument reads, "Free at Last".
The Russians build awesome war memorials. Probably too awesome for public school.
Maybe handing a book to a child.
"War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse. The person who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature and has no chance of being free unless made and kept so by the exertions of better men than himself".-- John Stuart Mill
That should be the words below the monument. My favorite quote. But I want my son to come to that conclusion on his own. By being an educated student who knows that life is not in the gray areas. It is black and white. Right or wrong.
A "Wall of Pictures" Pictures of the soldiers playing soccer with the Iraqi kids etc...The Purple finger...
ROTFL. I like you.
"A soldier with his rifle on guard, "
Nope. The kid would be expelled for a facimile of a gun.
Alternatively, a soldier with his rifle slung on his back walking, hand in hand, with a small child. Should be designed on an east/west basis, so that depending on the time of day, the sun is either directly behind or in front of the statue.
This is the letter I wrote to his teacher.......
I am Stephan Caricchio's father. I would like to know what designing a monument has to do with Language Arts? It seems a bit outside of the realm of reading. This is not graphic design or art class.
I hope that there are no political motivations here. To allow an option to students to basically make protest art is poor judgement in my opinion. These kids are not mature enough to weigh out all of the reasons and whys sacrifices are made. All they have are images of the dead. No logical discussion of terrorism. Why we want to fight terrorists over there instead of here, that there are groups of radical muslim fanatics that have no other goal than to kill Americans. At 14 kids are either to sensitive and think killing is never right, or overzealous and think killing is never wrong. There isn't that area of thought in between that allows them to weigh issues and options. I truly believe that this is not appropriate for my son to be involved in. If it were just monuments to the sacrifice of our soldiers, fine. But I will not allow my child's immature thought process be weighted in a way that I do not choose. And I do not choose to have him be influenced by your possible underlying political motivations.
This will turn into a discussion of politics in a classroom where you are the final arbiter. Where your views can be accepted as fact and the truth can be tilted to meet your opinions.
Please do not take this in a bad way. Nothing personal, just the way I feel. I look forward to a response from you. Please contact me at your convenience.
How about a statue of our troops passing the Iraqi flag back to an Iraqi with a purple finger?
Show the soldiers and the kids, the purple V's, the women and girls in schools.
Then show the soldiers day in and day out, especially the one with the "thousand yard stare" that wowed women everywhere.
Then show the solemn graves and the tears of the comerades for the fallen. And the President when he comforted the war widow.
Make sure you get all 4 branches of the Military.
Under the whole thing, post:
"We will not tire, we will not falter, and we will not fail."
-President George W. Bush, October 7, 2001
That should piss his teacher off completely and send them into a real rage.
Give him a flag instead then. Times are bad, but they still can't openly hate the flag.
Just make a bronze statue of that.
How about a picture of a 7 foot American GI stomping on cowering likenesses of Hitler, Stalin, and some bald little fat guy with an NEA pin.
That one is great!
How do they get the gun to stay like that?
A hand prying/lifting up another hand while freed peoples walk out from under the first hand. The theme being, the Hand of Democracy frees all from the hand of oppression. Peace doesn't free people, War does.
a wall of urinals with pictures of ted, nancy, harry, john, et al, placed in said urinals. it'll be an interactive display.
Hey, the positive side is that the title of the assignment ISN'T:
"Show Why These Soldiers are Baby Killers sent by the Monster Hitler Bush so he could get more Oil for his Halliburton Firends".
That's progress if this is a public school.
I wouldn't seek to compose it for you, since that's your child's job. But here are some elements I would include:
1. A dozen Iraqi children reaching out to a smiling US soldier; 2. Several adults holding up purple fingers with a ballot box nearby; 3. A copy of the Iraqi constitution; 4. A mosque, to remind people we stand for freedom of religion (unlike our enemies); 5. Date palms which stand for life; 6. The confluence of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers; and 6. Somewhere noticeable but more subtle, the face of President George W. Bush. All in bronze of course.
C'mon Coop. He is 14. I am all about him doing things on his own, but this assignment is a tough one. He needed help. And I am as close to an artist as I am to Pluto.
Ug. Firends -> Friends
How about something that depicts the Iraqi's toppling the statue of Saddam?
How about a large bronze dog standing next to a large bronze pig, both of them peeing on the ka'aba
I was going to say the Saddam statue too with a tank hooked to it pulling it down.
Aren't all his classmates about the same age? Is getting adult help for the child fair to all the kids who just do their own work? What are you teaching your child about individual responsibility? In the long run, you are also being unfair to your kid. You won't be able to help him when he takes the SATs, when he goes to college, when he takes his final exams.
Uh, all of these kids will be getting help from parents. That is part of being a parent. I do not mind helping. We are discussing all of the ideas right now for the monument. We are also discussing the reasons for war as well. Why sacrifice is sometimes required. But I have my childs best interest at heart, and I will help him any way I see fit. And he will learn to think on his own in the process. Nd he is laughing heartily and some of the funnier ideas you guys here have posted. The kid beating saddams head with a shoe is his favorite.
Have the woman with the purple fingers, forming a peace sign, sticking them into Saddam's eye sockets.
heh that would be cool too :)
I was going to ask what class produced this assignment. Perhaps the best "Memorial" in the circumstances would be an elegantly-reasoned term paper on the causes and effects of our intervention in Iraq.