Skip to comments.Student's tall tale revealed. Confesses fabricating US surveillance story [Mao's "Little Red Book"]
Posted on 12/24/2005 10:13:27 AM PST by John Jorsett
It rocketed across the Internet a week ago, a startling newspaper report that agents from the US Department of Homeland Security had visited a student at the University of Massachusetts at Dartmouth at his New Bedford home simply because he had tried to borrow Mao Tse-Tung's ''Little Red Book" for a history seminar on totalitarian goverments.
The story, first reported in last Saturday's New Bedford Standard-Times, was picked up by other news organizations, prompted diatribes on left-wing and right-wing blogs, and even turned up in an op-ed piece written by Senator Edward M. Kennedy in the Globe.
But yesterday, the student confessed that he had made it up after being confronted by the professor who had repeated the story to a Standard-Times reporter.
The professor, Brian Glyn Williams, said he went to his former student's house and asked about inconsistencies in his story. The 22-year-old student admitted it was a hoax, Williams said.
''I made it up," the professor recalled him saying. ''I'm sorry. . . . I'm so relieved that it's over."
The student was not identified in any reports. The Globe interviewed him Thursday but decided not to write a story about his assertion, because of doubts about its veracity. The student could not be reached yesterday.
(Excerpt) Read more at boston.com ...
People are idiots to think they can get away with making this sort of thing up in the age of New Media. People were dissecting this story before it was 2 minutes old.
Knew it was fishy from the start. The jerk should be hauled into the dean's office and kicked out of college.
Um, you were lied to moron!
So when does Senator Kennedy issue his apology???
Even if it was a lie, its the seriousness of the charges!! I am speechless, just like some senators should be!
Fake but accurate? Do they still think they can get away with that?
Are you kidding? It's probably on their business cards :-).
Dang, ya beat me.
This student is simply preparing for a long career as lying journalist with the NY Slimes.
In my view this could be construed as a form of treason. This 'student' should face some serious prison time...
Mao's first rule.
If you lie big enough, everyone will believe you.
This kid has a journalist job waiting for him at the Old York Times!
Merry Christ's Night
Well I guess I'm going to have to retract my story about Ted Kennedy being a child molester and a heroin addict. But dammit, even though I was totally wrong to spread those false allegations, none of this should detract from my broader point that Ted Kennedy abuses kids and takes way too much heroin.
Hope you're not holding you breath. I think you may be turning quite blue if you're waiting for this.
I think this student now needs a visit from the FBI and reported for making false claims against the government.
It's just another example of why it's better to tell the truth: it's easier to keep your story straight!
Oh that Kennedy?!
Merry Christ's Night
He was just being a good little Marxist-Leninist.
Lying is one of the mildest of sins advocated in the unholy cause of advancing communism.
We have an entire MSM built on this premise.
His real "sin" was not doing a better job of lying, and then admitting his lie.
Even Dan Rather would not commit that "sin."
He may be a liar, but the professors and the media were willing dupes..and just in time to affect the Patriot Act renewal..Isn't that a coincidence?
Wonder how much he got paid for his lie so that Teddy could get published under any-including false-pretenses.
If Teddy Kennedy got suckered and punked on this one, well, it's all good.
Doing this to fat old drunken stupid Ted is rather like poking sticks at a toothless old lion. Fun to watch and not much danger involved.
Posted on 12/24/2005 11:50:46 AM CST by smoothsailing
If Kennedy were a man, he would publicly apologize to President Bush for repeating a vicious lie about him and giving it credence. But of course, if Kennedy were a man, Mary Joe Kopechne would be alive.
Delusional persecuted liberal syndrome strikes again!
This is nothing more than S.O.P. for the dims.
Don't they know that the majority of Americans no longer take them seriously?
Lie; get caught at it; "could happen" when the lie is unearthed; just doesn't sell any more.
Merry Christmas and happy whatever holiday you celebrate.
Obviously Carl Rove got to him. Was he water boarded? Forced to wear women's underway on his head? Inquiring minds want to know.
LOL -yup, the moonbat telegraph system consisting of moonbat websites and MSM hubs... Otherwise known as WMN, the Whining Moonbat Network
Here are the pertinent points IMO
The professor, Brian Glyn Williams
praised the student as hard-working and likeable, said he was shaken by the deception.
''I feel as if I was lied to, and I have no idea why," said Williams, an associate ("professor of Islamic history"). He said the possibility the government was scrutinizing books borrowed by his students ''disturbed me tremendously." ....Shocked I tell you, shocked!.... ;)
a history seminar on totalitarianism and fascism taught by a colleague of Williams, Robert Pontbriand. .... Sounds French.....
a Standard-Times reporter called Williams, who has traveled to Afghanistan for research....yeah, just "research"... uhuh
UMass-Dartmouth, said the university did not expect to take any action against the student. ''This was a conversation that took place between a student and his faculty members," .... Never mind that the proffessor went to the Standard News.....
After that story, a Standard-Times reporter called Williams, who has traveled to Afghanistan for research, to ask whether he was concerned about government surveillance, Williams said. .... my, my...out of the blue after the NYT story on NSA, this reporter just happens to phone "The Proffesor, William" ..... wink wink ;)
As an afterthought, (But just as an "afterthought"...but of course!) Williams said, he told the reporter about the alleged visit by the Homeland Security agents, and that became the lead of the Dec. 17 Standard-Times story.
Pontbriand was appalled. ''A university is a place for the open inquiry for the truth," he said. ..... Don't you mean for knowledge Ponti baby? This guy wouldn't know truth if it hit him upside the head!
This story is all about the enemy within. And it would behoove our intellegence to look in to those little trips to Afghanistan and both these proffessors.
Sorry if this was hard to read in the beggining, I could have done better if I knew how to bold and use italics in this type of forum, but hopefully you understood where my own remarks were. :(
How much would I bet that this student was merely spewing back to his professor of "Islamic studies" exactly what he thought his prof would love to hear???? I would bet major $$$ that this prof spewed hate-America bile for a whole semester, and the student thought it would be a nice way to suck up to such an America-basher by retailing this preposterous story. The professor's extreme bias can easily be seen in the fact that the idiot relayed the tall tale to the media without first being sufficiently skeptical about such a ludicrous tale. The media bias can be seen in the fact that such tripe made it quickly into the mediastream without any adequate investigation.
I'm waiting for a Liberal commentator to say something like: 'If someone was sufficiently concerned about anti-terrorism laws that they IMAGINED this happening, then it might as well have REALLY happened.' To them, laws that have a "chilling effect" is sufficient to claim that they are being oppressed. Same thing as the Patriot Act, where people feel that their civil liberties are being violated, but no one can provide anything other than hypothetical cases to show that their civil liberties really were violated. To the Left, it's all about what they feel should be--reality makes no difference.
Interesting that the professor taught Islamic history. Wonder if the student was a Muslim trying to discredit our government.
The whole thing doesn't pass the laugh test, does it?
Fake, but accurate.
This law is so good it makes its victims deny their rights have been violated.
Rush Limbaugh's quotation of another idiot member of Congress: "Admiral Boorda..." comes to mind.
See HTML Sandbox.
After how many apologies, firings and retractions did it finally take for the Globe to show a bit of responsibility? Now if only some of this could rub off on the NYT, Wa.Post and CBS.
If the liar is 22 years old, why is his identity being protected? I could understand it if he were a minor child, but he's an adult and should be responsible for his actions. He made public statements and has caused a great many adults to run around after his story; he should be held to account for the problems he has caused.
Exactly. And, as I posted on the other thread, I want to know who the 78 callers were on the kid's cell phone???
"This 'student' should face some serious prison time..."
He sounds as whacked out as the runaway bride...wonder if he's related to her?
Was there anyone on FR who believed this story? Even a little?
If he's related to her then prison time might well should be "loony bin" time....
Searching around on the Internet a bit, I see that Laura Capps is also mentioned as "former Clinton speechwriter" and "Director of Government Relations" at Berkeley. What a surprise.