Skip to comments.Israel Needs A Non-Jewish Prime Minister
Posted on 01/05/2006 6:55:45 PM PST by SJackson
While serving as rabbi at Oxford University, I befriended a young African-American Rhodes scholar by the name of Cory Booker who became like a brother to me. Because of Corys immense popularity within our student organization, the Oxford LChaim Society, he was voted in as co-president 1992, serving as leader of an organization of more than 4,000 student members.
Many in the Anglo-Jewish community were puzzled at a non-Jew serving at the head of a Jewish organization, especially when pictures of Cory, with a yarmulke on his head introducing our speaker Mikhail Gorbachev, appeared throughout the UK press. But to my mind that was never a contradiction. Cory was simply the best man for the job.
A deeply spiritual man of impeccable character, Cory, a Baptist, was the living personification of Jewish values. He had a deep love and reverence for God, humanity, and the Jewish people, and he possessed a charismatic ability to inspire goodness in others. Indeed, Corys presidency was long remembered as a golden era for Jewish life at Oxford, and today Cory, who is now running to be mayor of Newark, New Jersey, is not only one of Americas most influential young politicians, but is adored by the American Jewish community.
I thought of Cory as I watched Israel descending into the morass of another bitterly-contested election. We who have prayed for a strong Israeli leader firm in his or her conviction that the real road to peace in the Middle East rests not with Israeli concessions but with Arab political reform and democratization are now handed a roster of the usual suspects. For the most part, the prime ministerial candidates are men who have already succumbed in the past to international pressure to cede territory in return for what was supposed to be peace but was always increased Arab hostility toward the Jewish state.
Indeed, I have begun to despair of any Jewish prime minister of Israel being able to withstand the pressure for further concessions. Menachem Begin was the most nationalistic of all Israels prime ministers and one of the proudest Jews of modern times. But he handed over to Egypt land equivalent to three times Israels size and received an ice-cold peace in return. Ariel Sharon, the man many once viewed as the unshakable rock of Israels security, abandoned Gaza and its brave Jewish residents and in return received a wave of Hamas-launched rockets so incessant that his government is now threatening ground operations in Gaza, which obviates the entire reason for leaving in the first place.
Ehud Barak, once Israels most decorated soldier, was ready, at Camp David, to give to Yasir Arafat Judaisms most sacred sites, and even Bibi Netanyahu, long Israels most eloquent defender, gave up control of Hebron, Israels first capitol and the city of the patriarchs, and signed the Wye River agreements under pressure from Bill Clinton.
Given this kind of history, does it really matter who is elected Israels next prime minister? The outcome is already a foregone conclusion. Whoever is prime minister will come under horrendous pressure to cede huge tracts of Judea and Samaria to the Palestinians, and if history is a guide, they will buckle to that pressure.
I believe that, as strange as it may sound, it is time for Israelis to begin to look seriously at having a non-Jewish prime minister. One of the reasons Cory Booker was such an effective president for us at Oxford was that he did not have so many of the hang-ups that we Jews sometimes possess: problems affirming our identity in a non-Jewish environment, feelings that we are outsiders (which in turn leads to a desperate longing for mainstream acceptance), and a feeling of queasiness at how disliked Israel is by the rest of the world.
Whereas many of our committed Jewish students were reluctant to invite their more secular Jewish friends to attend Friday night Shabbat dinner for fear of being stigmatized as parochial and missionary, Cory served as one of our greatest sources of recruitment and many Jewish Rhodes Scholars became regulars at our events due entirely to Corys inspiration.
Israel needs that kind of leader: a man or woman who is unafraid to assert that Israel is a moral and democratic country that has little for which to apologize. Israel needs a leader who couldnt care less about fitting in and for whom invitations to the White House and Downing Street are meaningless.
A non-Jewish prime minister, who is already an insider, would save us from the many Jewish prime ministers who traded in their ideology to gain mainstream acceptance. Indeed, perhaps it is only a non-Jewish man or woman who could go to the United Nations and have the credibility to speak the truth about the shocking prejudice against the Jewish state in that increasingly immoral international body.
Perhaps it is only a non-Jewish prime minister who could speak with credibility about the right of the Jews to their ancient, biblical homeland. Indeed, would the Balfour Declaration of 1917, promulgated by a non-Jewish lover of the Jewish people, have had the same credibility had it been the Rabinowitz Declaration?
The story of the modern State of Israel is one of constant tragedy, interspersed with remarkable triumphs. But the most remarkable thing of all is how so many of those tragedies were self-inflicted. The Oslo agreements, in which Israel brought back to its territory and armed tens of thousands of men committed to its destruction, will no doubt be forever regarded as one of the greatest self-inflicted catastrophes by any nation in the history of the world.
Of all the people who are puzzled at Israels mysterious penchant for self-destruction, it is evangelical Christians who are most puzzled of all. Evangelicals were the most vocal opponents to the withdrawal from Gaza, wondering why Israel would voluntarily allow the creation of a Hamas terrorist launching pad on its borders. Indeed, Christian evangelicals take seriously not only the Jewish biblical claim to the Land of Israel, but the idea of Jewish chosenness as well, a concept that makes modern Jews incredibly queasy.
So why not have an evangelical prime minister who actually believes in and will authoritatively speak to the world of the Jewish peoples three-thousand-year-old claim to their homeland? I, for one, would welcome any Israeli leader, of whatever birth, who is wholly immune to any sycophantic desire for international acceptance.
Indeed, the Talmud relates that one of the most successful kings of Second-Temple era Israel was the non-Jewish Agrippa, who was so beloved by the people that when he once cried in public, after reading Deuteronomy 17:15, the commandment that "You shall not have a foreigner over you," the people cried out to him, "Fear not Agrippa. You are our brother. You are our brother" (Sotah 41a).
Indeed, I have begun to despair of any Jewish prime minister of Israel being able to withstand the pressure for further concessions....Israel needs that kind of leader: a man or woman who is unafraid to assert that Israel is a moral and democratic country that has little for which to apologize. Israel needs a leader who couldnt care less about fitting in and for whom invitations to the White House and Downing Street are meaningless.
Sure, and we need an Austrian President of the US.
Absolutely correct. I am also of the firm belief that I need a well-tuned accordion for my next hunting exploits.
Has Israel ever had an AUTHENTICALLY Jewish PM?
And Iran needs a Jewish President.
Schmuley's probably available.
Will you settle for a Governor.
IMO, all of them.
And Israel will get a non-Jewish Prime Minister about the same time as Iran gets a Jewish President.
I always wanted to see Jim Hightower be the president of Iran and let Kinky Freidman be the president of Bahrain.
An Irish Catholic would take better care of the place.
Hey, I hear Kofi Annan might be looking for a job soon. Just goes to show, there is no IQ test for being a rabbi.
What about Meir Kahane's "They Must Go?"
Are non-Jews reproducing in Israel faster than Jews are?
(voting rights may be another story)
I don't think that non-Muslims are reproducing in Iran faster than Muslims are.
Schmuley may have an idea here - any Druze a**kickers with a yen for the PM-ship available?
--IMO, all of them.
Absolutely correct. Those who see only haredim or datim as Jewish are taking a very narrow view. Lets put it this way: on Rosh Hashanah 86% of Israeli Jews were at services. That obviously includes the vast majority of the 70% who are labeled as chilonim.
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree. IMO, an AUTHENTICALLY Jewish PM would not "make peace" with murderers or their supporters.
Schmuley's a schmuck.
A discussion for another time.
Yes, but he's entertaining. And there's frequently an element of truth in what he writes. Israel does need a Prime Minister willing to stand up to pressure to compromise Israel's security. But he doesn't make his point very well.
I would make a good President of France.
Observance of mitzvot are important, but they are the result of being AUTHENTICALLY Jewish. There's an old yiddish expression which, roughly translated, states, "first of all, be a human being." The yiddish word for human being is "mensch" with all its connotations of substance over form. When an Arab murders four young girls and then shoots their pregnant mother in the belly, the AUTHENTIC Jews cries out in pain, and demands justice. Those who are merely born to Jewish parents react by giving up land to murderers.
I pick John Bolton!
I agree. A Druze military man would be perfect.
Teenage Immigrant Welfare Mothers on Drugs!
Begin the most,also Shamir, Eshkol, maybe Bibi.
"Indeed, the Talmud relates that one of the most successful kings of Second-Temple era Israel was the non-Jewish Agrippa, who was so beloved by the people that when he once cried in public, after reading Deuteronomy 17:15, the commandment that "You shall not have a foreigner over you," the people cried out to him, "Fear not Agrippa. You are our brother. You are our brother"
While this is a famous passage,I always thought that Agrippa was Hashmonean from his mothers side and hence Jewish. Anyone know the real facts?
Speaking for myself, justice would be dropping a kosher, 50 megaton, bagel-shaped bomb on Mecca.
interesting. I nominate Bill Clinton. After all, he was the 'first' black president.
So sez Michael Jackson's pal.
....About as much as the U.S. needs a Muslim President.
Schmuley needs to lay off the Manischewitz.
I hear Hillary has been playing with dradles while wearing that Yankees cap.
Oddly, Schmuley is a Persian Jew.
If by that you mean haredi, then no. Israel is after all a mainly secular state. Has the US ever had an authentically Christian president? I don't think anyone would say that Pres Bush is christian equivalent of an orthodox jew.
It reminds me of the Curb Your Enthisiasm episode where the guy accuses Larry of not being a real jew because he was humming Wagner and Larry offers to take it out to prove his jewishness.
Ya, maybe the Pope could administer Israel from afar.....
Who writes these things?
"Oddly, Schmuley is a Persian Jew."
Boteach is aa Eastern European Lubavitcher.
I'll never understand why no Israeli Prime Minister has ever stood up before the world and said "Either the Arabs recognize our right to exist as a homeland of the Jews, or they don't. If they do, then there's room for disagreements and diplomacy, if they don't, then there is nothing to talk about and we will be in a perpetual state of war with them indefinitely, and don't expect us to make any concessions or give them the benefit of the doubt".
Hey! My last name is Baldwin!
Hey! Were some of those Kings, relatives?
. . . hey . . . I wouldn't mind, uh, volunteering for the job . . . you know, I could be really mean to those Muslims . . . check my file . . . Should I check in with the Raabei ? I think I would make a great Prime Minister of Israel. No kidding. It's, well, perhaps "in my blood"?
"Israel Needs A Non-Jewish Prime Minister"
Excellent piece and I agree.
And the defense minister and formy army chief of staff is also iranian, as are a bunch of others. israel and iran actually had quite a close relationship before the revolution. Sharon was good friends with the Shah and the military there. One of his best friends was ambassador and another was the chief mossad man in Tehran and defense attache.
I would expand on that description exponentially..
Israel is the home of the Jews. Got a problem with that?
Now this is an interesting twist - ping!
So is Shaul Mofaz.