Skip to comments.CIA dissenters aided secret prisons report ("helped a European probe")
Posted on 07/17/2007 8:57:58 PM PDT by SeafoodGumbo
BRUSSELS (Reuters) - Dissident U.S. intelligence officers angry at former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld helped a European probe uncover details of secret CIA prisons in Europe, the top investigator said on Tuesday.
Swiss Senator Dick Marty, author of a Council of Europe report on the jails, said senior CIA officials disapproved of Rumsfeld's methods in hunting down terrorist suspects, and had agreed to talk to him on condition of anonymity.
"There were huge conflicts between the CIA and Rumsfeld. Many leading figures in the CIA did not accept these methods at all," Marty told European Parliament committees, defending his work against complaints it was based on unnamed sources.
The report issued last month said the Central Intelligence Agency ran secret jails in Poland and Romania, with the complicity of those governments, and transported terrorist suspects across Europe in secret flights.
Poland and Romania have repeatedly denied hosting CIA prisons on their soil.
"People in the CIA felt these things were not consonant with the sort of intelligence work they normally do," Marty said.
He said he had based his findings largely on conversations with "high officials of the CIA (and) highly placed European office-holders, who for different reasons, often honorable reasons, were ready to explain what had happened."
Since he had no power to summon witnesses, subpoena documents or search buildings, he was forced to rely on such evidence, Marty said.
"The Americans themselves admitted there were secret prisons, that they abducted people from the streets, that people were handed over to countries like Syria, Yemen, Egypt where they were tortured," he said.
U.S. President George W. Bush acknowledged last year that the CIA had held top al Qaeda suspects in secret overseas detention centers but did not say in which countries.
"The president of United States made a very important statement..., I think we can all expect ... in the near future further admissions," said Marty.
He also said he would not remove name of former Polish and Romanian government officials from the report, although they threatened on Tuesday to take legal action against the senator.
The report said former Polish national security adviser Marek Siwiec and former Romanian Defense Minister Ioan Pascu knew their countries had hosted secret CIA detention centers.
"I have no reason to withdraw his name. I would certainly not be prepared to apologies. He knew exactly what was happening as did his president," Marty told a news conference, referring to Siwiec and former Polish President Aleksander Kwasniewski.
"I am not shaking in my shoes," he said of the libel suit that Siwiec vowed to launch in a Polish court unless Marty removed his name from the report within seven days.
Pascu challenged Marty in the hearing to substantiate his allegations or withdraw them, but the Swiss legislator did not respond directly.
This is huge. Drastic reform is need at the CIA — immediately. This is f’in outrageous...it’s treason.
But the liberals will claim he’s a hero.
Anyone who participated in this should hang or face a firing squad.
Unfortunately, they will probably make the rounds on the network news shows, giving TV interviews. Next comes the book deal.
In a country that believed in something, these people would be facing capital charges.
And yet another example - this one clearly stated and apparently cited - of the ongoing war between the CIA and the duly elected U.S. government.
This is outrageous (though I am not surprised at all).
Where are the Sedition laws in this country.
I’m so sick of Bush and his pathetic leadership.
Yeah, right. There’s nothing to believe at this point about their stories.
This is not huge. This is stupid.
If outing a desk clerk at the C.I.A. gets you 3 years then outing a covert operation in war time should get you at least 25 years in Leavenworth!
Hard labor! :(
These people need to be sought and informed permanently of their vow to the United States and to keep secrets no matter how much they disagreed with those secrets.
When I drove out to the CIA, I thought we would be a team, Maloof recalled ... By October, it was open warfare. They began leaking and making accusations and accusing us of setting up an operation to bypass the agency."
Is it any wonder why the MI5 considers the CIA to be useless?
ANY operative, ANY person sworn to secrecy needs held to the fire and fined, jailed or terminated based on the extent at which they have betrayed our country. It is NOT up to them to blab to the media. If something is going on, they can blab to watchdog groups but if it ends up on the Times, they need some time.
These leaks were all partisan. They were intended to smear Bush. While my regard of him is at an extreme low due to Jorge’s amnesty, position, the Potus should NOT have to deal with leaks on this level by AMERICANS! There are channels to solve these issues..those were bypassed to make political hay.
These actions, by the CIA employees, can be characterized in various ways: insubordination, espionage, treason, mutiny, anarchy, bad hair day.
In Sabotage, you'll learn:
* How CIA analysts repeatedly leak details about classified intelligence programs with the dual intent of ending them and damaging the president
* How, on at least eight occasions, intelligence officials have made serious allegations of wrongdoing against the president's men--which turned out to be false
* Why, contrary to popular belief, the CIA has become predominantly liberal
* How a CIA turf battle prevented special operators from pursuing and capturing a notorious Taliban leader
* How current and former CIA officers fueled conspiracy theories that President Bush orchestrated the 9/11 attacks on America
* How a CIA leak to the New York Times deprived the U.S. of critical information in the War on Terror
* How press leaks by the CIA have damaged relations with our foreign allies in the War on Terror
* How a CIA analyst worked with Democrats to sabotage the nomination of John Bolton to the UN
* How Clinton's downsizing of the CIA led to the closing of stations in scores of jihadist breeding grounds--including Hamburg, Germany, where the 9/11 plot was hatched
From amazon's page on that book.
Notice the total disconnect between the Plamegate "crime of the century" rhetoric and the glorification of other leaks of classified secrets.
There is a guy name Pollard who is spending twenty years in jail for illegally giving secret information to our ally (israel).
This treason is equally as bad.
Bush needs to start doing the right thing for a change. If he had dealt properly and harshly with the NYT for their first disclosure of a classified program to catch terrorists, maybe there wouldn't have been a second disclosure.
These two in particular had Top Secret clearance. Another guy cleared to the gills (NSA, CIA, CPB, DOD) was a huge apologist for every enemy of the US you might bring up. I overheard him discuss how Condi Rice's own family didn't like her and on and on. Another individual joked about how we should nuke Utah and Texas and how sympathetic he was to the plight of the illegal alien. He was working for Customs Border Protection and one would have thought he'd have been more concerned about the plight of keeping illegal aliens out of the US.
The most strange thing that happened was having Phil Landfried call everyone at the building up to the top of the Kingstowne building to chastise the well educated well paid (several million dollars in salaries were there that day) in their hygiene habits. It turns out one of the well cleared individuals was getting crap all over the place in the restroom and not flushing and many people were leaving trash and sanitary napkins in inappropriate places. It turns out with all the cameras and even after installing security swipe locks on the bathrooms they had failed to catch the offending individual in a period of over two years.
I marveled that if they couldn't catch the secret sh***r it is no wonder they couldn't catch illegal aliens. I did know many good people. My boss was a conservative and a good guy and the border guys from the field were good too but they were outnumbered. The group think in Washington is horrible. They need loyalty tests more than credit checks in DC.
Here is a picture posted in the restroom. lol
The CIA traitors aren’t the only ones:
The next President (Republican, I hope) needs to completely clean out both departments.
In fact, the question should be put to them all.
"If elected, would you be willing to seek out and remove all employees who leaked any information during the last 10 years?"
Sadly you are right. Bush needs to stop trying to make friends with Ted Kennedy and have a few CIA big mouths clamped in irons. And the “religion of peace” business is beyond old.
“They need loyalty tests more than credit checks in DC.”
DC needs a total house cleaning from the ground up.
This is unreal. If this is true, the CIA employees who did this should be found at all costs, sparing no expense or effort. These traitors should be tried and suffer the punishment due to treason. They are no better than the Rosenbergs. If we “tolerate” traitors like this, we are through as a nation. This is an outrage.
Im not going to speculate as to why such a decision was made here, but you can be well rest assured that it has to do with political correctness. The sad truth is that we have no assets of our own on the ground, at least not here in Southeast Asia. That is unless you count our agents lounging around the swimming pools at Hiltons worldwide reading USA Today and waiting for their local translators to give them the "scoop" or the FBI and DEA guys up in Bangkok who spend their days trying to score a kilo or two of smack from the Hmong.
Those are some disturbing stories. Wow.
I was watching Fox n Friends this morning - with one eye open - and they had a well-known guy on who has written a book about the clandestine group with the CIA that is leaking all the classified stuff; whose whole goal is to make Bush look bad.
The name of the book is, “Sabotage”. I had not heard a peep about this book before, so I’m hoping he shows up on O’Reilly, Hannity and a few other places. Looks like I have another book to add to my collection of “must reads”.
What’s funny about the bathroom story you tell isn’t just the CIA’s inability to catch a dump leaver, but the psychology behind someone who would do that or do any of the other nasty things you mentioned, like leave tampons or trash around, because it shows people who have a contempt for others. People who are well-mannered (and normal) don’t trash a common area unless they are selfish misanthropes, not the type of people we need in a field where dealing with people is instrumental to doing a good job. They sound like a bunch of miserable bastards driven by infighting and turf battles who literally shit to mark their territory (like animals).
Thanks, it does answer a lot of questions.
Great links in this thread:
Who is Mary McCarthy? [The Great One, Mark Levin, weighs in...]
NRO ^ | 4/22/2006 | Mark Levin
Posted on 04/22/2006 3:03:40 PM EDT by Uncledave
Who is Mary McCarthy?
Well, as of this morning (Saturday) most of the big media don’t care. They’re fixated with the weather and gas prices and anything else that will divert the public’s attention from the stunning revelation that a Sandy Berger crony has apparently been leaking top-secret information from her high post at the CIA. The media will continue to downplay this story as they cover-up their own role in exposing our nation’s secrets, including the supposed existence of CIA prisons in Europe. She’ll be called a “whistleblower” and praised as some kind of patriot (a patriot, in the eyes of the media, is anybody who undermines this administration and the war effort by leaking national security secrets to them). They will downplay that McCarthy was a Clintonoid who somehow managed to land a top post at the CIA, ultimately winding up in the CIA’s Inspector General’s Office, from where she could monitor CIA internal investigations of, well, leaks, among other things.
The news spin, to the extent attention is being paid to this by the big media outlets, is that McCarthy’s firing is unprecedented! Or it’s Bush’s fault! In one of the most absurd comments by any newsman anywhere, Newsbusters.org notes that Bob Schieffer of CBS Evening News asserted that it is no secret that the current administration does not like its people hanging out with news reporters without permission and he described the firing as a first a dubious first, to be sure. Here. Is this guy for real?
If she leaked she must be charged. I wonder what Schieffer would say then? I suppose he would urge that she receive the Presidential Medal of Freedom. After all, the Washington Post’s Dana Priest, who apparently served as McCarthy’s stenographer, was just awarded the Pulitzer Prize.
I must say, however, that the media’s sickening hypocrisy knows no bounds. They came to the defense of Joe Wilson and his wife, Valerie Plame, who worked behind-the-scenes to get her husband that fact-finding trip to Niger. They demanded an investigation into who leaked Plames identity to Bob Novak which ensnared their own reporters. They hoped they would critically wound the president, and they failed. Clearly Plame was not undercover and the revelation of her identity was not a crime. Lewis Libby now stands accused of lying about a crime that never occurred and the media think thats a good thing.
Now comes Mary McCarthy, who apparently leaked real classified national-security secrets and the media largely dismiss it or defend it. They have no curiosity about McCarthy, the extent of her leaks, to whom she leaked (beyond Priest, did she leak to other reporters, members of Congress, other governments?), how she secured top security posts, and her ties to the Clinton administration. Surely there is every reason the government should pursue this investigation at least as vigorously as the Plame matter has been pursued. Dana Priest, among others, should have her day before a grand jury.
And watch the congressional Democrats follow the medias lead. Long ago they put party and power above victory in this war. McCarthys ties to Clinton threaten to take attention from their unrelenting attack on the Bush administration and their claims of incompetence in the management of the war, which they see as their ticket to majority status in 2006.
Putting that aside, the discovery of McCarthy does make you wonder how many more of her ilk have squirreled themselves into the bureaucracy, from where they seek to undermine the country. ~
Look at this. Back in December, Jack Wheeler thought that a CIA weasel leaked the intel to John McCain who then leaked it to the Washington Post. Hummmmmmmm. We may want to pursue this angle further.
The Rogue Weasels Club (John McCain and the CIA leakers)
To The Point ^ | December 16, 2005 | Dr. Jack Wheeler
Posted on 12/17/2005 1:32:49 PM EST by quidnunc
How upset are you over the CIA secret prison scandal? Maybe you said, What scandal?, or maybe youve glanced at stories about it carried in the back pages of your newspaper. Here in Europe, its the giant screaming front page headline story on every paper you pick up from England to Germany.
The Europeans are in a state of high emotional froth over CIA renditions of Moslem terrorists seized in one of their countries and taken to a secret prison in Poland or elsewhere. The Euroweenies are far more concerned with the human rights of the terrorists than they are about the threat of terrorists to kill them.
If you think all of this is just an excuse to bash the CIA and indulge in anti-Americanism, youre right just as planned by the weasels.
Everyone on the right, it seems nowadays, from the editorials in the Wall Street Journal to conservative columnists like Mona Charen and bloggers like John Hinderacker, are issuing calls to Investigate the CIA! They have been suckered by the left.
They should instead be demanding, Investigate the weasels, not the agency! All of them have been accusing the CIA of conducting a covert war against the Bush Administration by leaking damaging classified information to leftwing journalists in the press. That the most damaging leak of all to date, the secret prisons story leaked to the Washington Post, is incredibly damaging to the CIA itself has not given them pause.
Why would the CIA conduct a covert war against itself? Because the agency is now being run by an ally of George Bush who is trying to root out left wing rogue weasels from its midst: Porter Goss.
You could call it, as some of the good guys at Langley are starting to, the Rogue Weasel Club. According to one member of the intel community, its members include:
This is the cabal of leftwing spooks Bush and Goss are up against, who are purposefully damaging the president with leaks to the press and folks in Congress who wish them ill. One of them is the culprit who leaked the secret prison story to John McCain, who in turn leaked it to the Washington Post.
They are the ones who should be investigated and its about time conservative critics of the CIA figured it out.
1 posted on 12/17/2005 1:32:49 PM EST by quidnunc
I think we need to post the list of Rogue Weasels here, in case something happens to the source. They are the ones who should be investigated and its about time conservative critics of the CIA figured it out.
Signees to letter to Senator John McCain, December 9, 2005:
ROBERT BAER, former Case Officer, Directorate of Operations, CIA
VINCENT CANNISTRARO, former director of the CIA Counterterrorism Center
KATHLEEN CHRISTISON, former Analyst, Directorate of Intelligence, CIA
WILLIAM CHRISTISON, former National Intelligence Officer and Director, Office of Regional & Political Analysis, CIA
RICHARD CLARKE, former advisor, National Security Council
RAY CLOSE, former Chief of Station Officer, CIA
VICKI DIVOLL, former Assistant General Counsel, CIA
GRAHAM FULLER, former Vice-Chairman of the National Intelligence Council, CIA
MELVIN A. GOODMAN, former Analyst, Directorate of Intelligence, CIA
PHILIP GIRALDI, former Case Officer, Directorate of Operations, CIA
MICHAEL GRIMALDI, former Analyst, Directorate of Intelligence, CIA
RALPH M. HOCKLEY, Col. USA (ret), former intelligence officer
ARTHUR S. HULNICK, former intelligence officer, US Air Force, former CIA
LARRY C. JOHNSON, former Analyst, Directorate of Intelligence, CIA
EDWARD R. M. KANE, former Chief of Station, CIA
CAMERON LA CLAIR, former Executive Officer of Area Division, CIA
W. PATRICK LANG, Col. USA (ret), Chief of DIA Middle East Division, Director Defense Humint Services
LYNNE A. LARKIN, former Case Officer, Directorate of Operations, CIA
DAVID MACMICHAEL, former National Intelligence Council officer, CIA
TOM MAERTENS, former analyst, Intelligence and Research, Department of State
EUGENE A. MANNING, former Analyst, Office of National Estimates, Directorate of Intelligence, and Counterintelligence Center, CIA
JAMES MARCINKOWSKI, former Case Officer, Directorate of Operations, CIA
JOHN E. MARSH, former Case Officer, Directorate of Operations, CIA
RICHARD MCDERMOTT, former Army Counterintelligence Special Agent
RAY MCGOVERN, former Analyst, Directorate of Intelligence, CIA
DAVID RUPP, former Case Officer, Directorate of Operations, CIA
GARETH A. SHELLMAN, former intelligence analyst, U.S. Army Security Agency
JOHN P. SONTAG, former intelligence analyst, CIA and Department of State
LEWIS R. SORLEY, former Director, National Intelligence Emergency Support Office, CIA
ROBERT DAVID STEELE VIVAS, former clandestine officer, CIA
STANSFIELD TURNER, former Director of Central Intelligence
AMB. (RET) PHILIP C. WILCOX, JR., former Ambassador at Large for Counter Terrorism at Department of State
AUSTIN YAMADA, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Special Operations and Combating Terrorism
13 posted on 12/17/2005 2:04:13 PM EST by Cicero (Marcus Tullius)
Mary O. McCarthy’s name would probably also be on the above list if she had been a “former” CIA analyst.
56 posted on 04/22/2006 3:59:35 PM EDT by Matchett-PI
In light of my post here — http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/1619604/posts?page=56#56 — I wonder if Jack Wheeler has any idea who might have leaked the intel to James Risen of the NYT, hummmmmmm????
Excerpt from John Gibson’s commentary linked below:
“...Next up? Whoever was leaking to James Risen of The New York Times.
His story about the secret NSA wiretapping program probably did damage to national security, because it may have tipped off Al Qaeda that we could listen to their cell phone conversations to people inside this country. ...”
The Secret War Against President Bush
Fox News ^ | 04/21/2006 | By John Gibson
Posted on 04/22/2006 12:35:38 PM EDT by oxcart
On Friday, the CIA busted one of its own — http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,192640,00.html — and charged him or her with leaking classified information.
68 posted on 04/22/2006 4:18:12 PM EDT by Matchett-PI
“..And it now appears that a number of people in our intelligence and military have direct pipelines and own allegiance to the Donkey Party and their lib flunkies. The Fifth Column Party is a better term for them.” ~ driftless
Bush vs The Beltway: How the CIA and the State Department Tried to Stop the War on Terror
Amazon.com ^ | 7-29-03 | Laurie Mylroie
Posted on 07/29/2003 12:31:38 PM EDT by Matchett-PI
Bush vs. the Beltway: How the CIA and the State Department Tried to Stop the War on Terror (Hardcover)
by Laurie Mylroie “MORE THAN ANY OTHER assault experienced by America, even, than any attacks of September 11, 2001-the anthrax letters that followed those strikes perfectly illus the...” (more) Click here: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0060580127/qid=1059493952/sr=2-1/104-2003831-4261530?s=books&v=glance&n=283155
Quote: “We went to war because senior administration officials believe Iraq was involved in 9/11. But as we did that and they tried to articulate it, they heard, and it would come out in the form of disgruntled individuals within the bureaucracies, including the CIA, leaking to the press ‘there is no evidence,’ this cry always, what the Wall Street Journal called an echo chamber, ‘there is no evidence.’ ~ LAURIE MYLROIE
15 posted on 02/14/2004 7:31:18 AM EST by kcvl
Laurie Mylroie: Clintonized CIA Blocks Iraq-9/11 Evidence The Connection Between 9/11 and Iraq.
Newsmax and Fox News ^ | Thursday Jan. 30, 2003; 11:24 a.m. EST & Thursday, September 11, 2003
Posted on 03/23/2004 12:49:37 PM EST by april15Bendovr
There are lots of important links in this thread, including this one: http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1103732/posts?page=25#25
“Free Republic is a great place—a lot of people read it.” ~ Dr. Laurie Mylroie
Dr. Laurie Mylroie ^ | July 15, 2003 | Dr. Laurie Mylroie
Posted on 07/16/2003 1:18:30 PM EDT by Matchett-PI
73 posted on 04/22/2006 4:30:29 PM EDT by Matchett-PI
* * * *
Can You Trust the Washington Post’s Reporters?
Dana Priest has an article about possible CIA secret prisons today in the WaPo. Who is Dana Priest, and why should we believe her?
she is married to William Goodfellow, executive director of the “Center for International Policy”. The Center’s mission? It seems to be a very left-leaning organization founded by old peace activists. From their website:
Promoting a U.S. foreign policy based on international cooperation, demilitarization and respect for basic human rights The Center for International Policy was founded in 1975, in the wake of the Vietnam War, by former diplomats and peace activists....In the 1990s the Center attracted a number of senior diplomats to its staff and expanded its agenda to include reform of the nation’s intelligence agencies.
So Priest today reports on the CIA, while her husband heads a left-wing organization that wants to “reform the CIA”. Interesting.
74 posted on 04/22/2006 4:37:22 PM EDT by kcvl
I never dreamed Bush would turn out to be so weak. He's the friggin President, yet he can't (or won't) clean the socialist scum and other Clintonites out of the CIA and the Justice Department. These failures will be a big part of his "legacy".
Pres. Bush's fault is not that it happened once, or twice,
but that he did nothing each time, and allowed it to continue, and continue, and continue
as threat to America (but not to Mexico, so who cares, anyway?)
That doesn’t fit in with the “new tone”. We need to reach across the aisle and come to a consensus. We need to unite and not divide. Give them Scooter Libby. Give them Rumsfeld. Give them Alberto Gonzalez, Cheney, Wolfowitz, etc., etc., etc.
Amazing isn't it? You'd think if you can fill out the paperwork for a clearance you can figure out how to flush the toilet? I feel your pain, everyday...
“Yeah, blame GW for what some liberal CIA traitors did without the consent of his adminstration. You truly are dumb”
Yes I do blame him.. WHY ARE THEY THERE?
The CIA has been undermining this putz since the begining and THEY ARE STILL THERE.
You call me dumb? Uh hello.. did I insult you? Does GWB need you to defend his honor? If you think, then you are dumb just like he is.
A ex-CIA guy demostrated just how ignorant the thinking at the CIA is last night on Glenn Beck’s CNN show. I posted a transcript here...
These guys think the Jihad is something like a Marxist movement instead of a religious movement. Unbelievable.
It’s both. It is a political system. And it squashes out any other religious devotion. You MUST submit to Islam one way or another.
I’ve never experienced that kind of thing before. I’d heard complaints about people missing the urinal and stuff like that but never did I dream of being a part of a meeting on the top of a parking garage to discuss personal hygiene. It was a good environment to work in overall but the contrasts were interesting to say the least. I do believe that unless we clean house and make sure the people in our intelligence and security agencies are loyal Americans we will always face an uphill battle against an enemy who offers hidden sabotage and calls it analysis.
This isn’t about Democrat or Republican, it is about making sure that people who want America to win are the only ones with access to the to those secrets that if exposed will compromise our safety and our strength as a nation.