Skip to comments.Children Stealing Gold in Beijing
Posted on 08/17/2008 10:11:47 AM PDT by AJKauf
Chinese coaches tried to hide the ages of the girls with enough makeup to shame a drag queen, but no amount of lipstick and eyeliner can hide the fact that the American gymnasts have curves and breasts and the Chinese ones dont. On average, the girls on the Chinese team are 3.5 inches shorter and 30 pounds lighter than their American counterparts....
(Excerpt) Read more at pajamasmedia.com ...
The IOC is sports’ equivalent of the UN.
China can (and will) cheat at will.
I noticed this even before it became a controversy- I saw the event on TV and I thought “Why are these nearly adult american girls competing against these little chinese children?”
The one Chinese girl looked about 9
are there age limits????? Must be pretty rough getting your clock cleaned by a kid in training undies.
This Olympics has made me very proud. Americans have acted with class and grace...where others have not.
Minimum age is supposed to be 16.
They have to be 16 in the year of the olympics they perform in. So as long as they turn 16 by 11:59:59 on Dec 31 they are OK.
As for the kid in undies comment, I am not sure what advantage a kid would have over an adolescent, but the rule is there for a reason.
did you watch the competition?
did you see Shawn Johnson standing next the Chinese?
“are there age limits????? Must be pretty rough getting your clock cleaned by a kid in training undies.”
It’s all about uneven bars.
prepubescent bodies have the advantage on bars - but not necessarily on the other events.
I enjoy tuning in to the occasional Olympic event from time to time, but at the end of the day I really don't give a rat's a** who wins. I have a life.
Shawn still looks like she is 13-14 to me.
I have seen 16 year olds look just like her.
I have not seen 16 year olds look like the Chinese.
Shawn looked like she could have babysat those girls.
The rules exist for 2 reasons
1) It is for the welfare of the child
2) Younger children have a huge advantage in events like the balance beam and the uneven bars
If they couldn’t cheat, they couldn’t win. That’s all.
enough makeup to shame a drag queen
Based on what I witnessed after that 100 meter dash, the rest of the world seems to have acquired the expertise necessary to perform an after-TD celebration and a sack dance.
Yes, and I’ve stood next to my share of Chinese women, too... Being 4 feet 6 inches, and 70 pounds and look about 15% years younger (3 years younger at age 20, 4 years younger at 30, etc) than they really are.
I’m 6 feet tall - slightly above average in the US. In most places in China I tower over everyone. Few and far between can come close to looking me in the eyes, and none really match my girth (size 64 jacket, size 46 slacks).
Pretty much most of Asia has women - and men - a lot smaller than we think, and fully developed leaves them looking a lot younger...
Are they too young? They may be! But simple looks and comparisons side-by-side are not good indicators, especially when considering the genetic differences between races.
Not to say the Chinese are not cheating with respect to age, they could be, and I am sure it is right to suspect them, but -
They are Chinese. The average American or European in a crowd in Hong Kong cannot fail to understand the physical differences. There are racial differences in build, height, etc.
Even for a population that is selected for a given physique like competitive athletes are (there are no 6’ women competing after all), the people chosen will reflect to a degree on the available pool.
And in a population of 1 Billion of disproportionately slight build, if slightness is of value in a sport, then it stands to reason that they will find slighter girls than we do out of 300 Million who are disproportionately rubustly-built.
Let the Weak be Crushed!
LOL, that's what I think of the WNBA.
I KNOW! That guy who won the silver acted like he won the Gold..it was kind of embarrassing!!!
The bottom line is the 20 year old American who won LOOKED so much better, meaning she was graceful and experienced. Alot of girls have balance and can tumble, but a gymnist is supposed to look graceful and elegant while doing it!
That's it in a nutshell.
They take these little girls away from their parents when they are babies, I believe about 3 years old.
They are intensely trained for years and live in gymnastic camps away from their parents.
One girl said she would like to see her parents more often; she sees them once a year.
Of course in most if not all cases, the parents are agreeable to the practices as it helps them be more acceptable to the oppressive communist dictatorship that is China.
Plus is is better than at 12 years old or so to be making the sneakers that the olympic contenders are wearing.
She did look gorgeous, and she managed to win despite getting ripped on her vault, bars, and beam scores.
It is good to see our girls triumph even while they are being cheated.
American girls develop at an earlier age than most Asians. My granddaughter is 12 and looks 17. I’m not kidding. She’s already 5’7”, 120lbs and a 34B. :-) She is often mistaken for a high school senior. She thinks it’s cool when guys in their 20’s flirt with her because they think she’s closer to their age. Me, I don’t think it’s so funny and I tell her so.
I don’t doubt that the Chinese cheat if it benefits them but they do tend to be smaller.
We have beens seeing plenty of chinese girls in our own country for many years now.
Many american couples are adopting vast numbers of abandoned little girls from chinese orphanages.
Many of those little girls have found their way into american gymastics programs.
If there is one group of asian children american gymnastics coaches have been exposed to the most - it would be chinese.
did you watch the competition?
What did your eyes tell you?
“Are they too young? They may be! But simple looks and comparisons side-by-side are not good indicators, especially when considering the genetic differences between races.”
Then this is a recent development in chinese gymnasts.
This controversy has only arisen in Athens and Beijing.
So - 16 year old chinese competitors from the past looked like teenagers - and now they don’t.
And chinese gymnasts living in american look their age, but chinese gymnasts in china do not.
Now they have baby teeth, and have even been reported as being younger in older chinese news articles.
That lookis like an old picture of Shawn Johnson, maybe from 2006 or 2007. She is now 16 years old.
LOL....the second biggest chicom troll on this forum makes its appearance.
As for the kid in undies comment, I am not sure what advantage a kid would have over an adolescent, but the rule is there for a reason.”
The younger ones are totally fearless, and they weigh considerably less, so balance is easier.
As gynmasts learn their routines, they grow “muscle memory”. As they mature, their larger breasts and wider hips can change how their routines that they have practiced for years get altered.
Muscle Memory is what gives you the ability to “always be able to ride a bike or a horse” if you ever learned as a kid. I am not saying those muscles are in great shape-—I am just saying “You never forget how to ride a bike or a horse”.
12 years ago, 15 year old American teens looked like 15 year olds. Now 12 year old American girls look like they are 17.
Our baseline of “teenager” has shifted. See Melinda’s post right above that you simply ignored to answer or address...
Anastatia/aka Nastia Liukin will turn 19 years old in November, I think. She’s officially listed as 18 years old. And, yes she is graceful and a great gymnast too. Both Nastia and Shawn were much better overall than the Chinese girl who came in third. That little girl got about 0.5 extra points on her balance beam routine which she did not earn, IMHO.
I don’t see a lot of curves on any of them, American or Chinese, because most gymnasts are not as developed as others their age, but the Chinese definitely look younger to me.
I work with a Korean lady that is almost 50 and looks 20. She has no curves and no wrinkles. Sometimes they just look younger. That’s why I can’t positively say the Chinese cheated unless tests were done to verify their ages.
Normally we kill our females at birth as they are not useful to the State, but for tricking you we always allow a few to survive!! Die you pathetic nation of sniveling Obamas! We shall conquer you and annihilate you!"
Yes, pointing out genetic differences makes me a troll... Ever seen a 21 year old Thai, or Malay woman? Compare them to a 16 year old American teenager - straight up.
Looks are quire deceiving when you go across races...
Which is why I asked my female Chinese friend what her opinion was. She said "those girls are maybe 13 years old".
(are there tests that can verify ages?)
The misnomer on the part of pajamasmedia must be noted: children are stealing anything. The Chinese gov’t, however, is...
“12 years ago, 15 year old American teens looked like 15 year olds. Now 12 year old American girls look like they are 17.”
The main reason being higher percentage of bodyfat due to more sedentary lifestyles - something gymnasts from all countries do not suffer from.
I will repeat my observations.
Chinese girls who are adopted by americans and placed in gymnastics programs will not appear to be 10 years old when they are really 16.
16 year olds from any country will not retain baby teeth.
16 year old chinese gymnasts, in past olympic games (except for Athens) looked older than these girls.
My physical therapist is a 46 year old Thai grandmother (her grandson is 5 years old). When I arrived for my first session I thought she was the receptionist. I was shocked she wasn’t the 22 I thought, and that she had two advanced degrees.
For a 5 foot tall, 100 pound woman she can seriously wrench on a limb!
That’d be a good SNL skit - having to take a timeout to change diapers.
A great summary. One has to wonder about a sport where being 12 is an advantage that can not be overcome. Perhaps these events should simply be eliminated. They are chlidish.
“I dont see a lot of curves on any of them, American or Chinese,”
Our girls had hips and breasts.
Our girls faces looked older.
Our girls had their adult teeth.
And the big giveaway - old articles about our girls in american competition consistently report their true age.
Older girls will also dance better and give a more mature presentation on beam and floor.
On the night of team competition the chinese put up a girl so immature she could not dance and was walking around the mat.
I was embarrassed for her.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.