Skip to comments.An Emergency Review (Thomas Sowell)
Posted on 01/07/2009 7:41:05 PM PST by jazusamo
This is an emergency book review.
Before you do anything else, make a note to read "The Top Ten Myths of American Health Care" by Sally C. Pipes. It might literally save your life, by checking the political stampede toward a government-controlled medical profession usually presented politically as "universal health care."
It is one of the painful signs of our times that millions of people are so easily swayed by rhetoric that they show virtually no interest at all in finding out the hard facts. Any number of other countries already have government-controlled medical professions. Yet few Americans show any interest in what actually happens to medical care in those countries.
Instead, we are being lured into a one-way process much like entering a Venus fly trap by the oldest of all confidence rackets, the promise of something for nothing.
Fortunately, Sally C. Pipes is one of the few who has explored the reality of government-controlled medical treatment in Canada and other countries. Among the things she discovered is that new life-saving medications that go immediately into the market in the United States take a much longer time to become available to Canadian patients if they ever get approved by the bureaucrats.
No doubt that lowers the cost of medications if you count costs solely in money terms, rather than in terms of how many people literally pay with their lives when the bureaucrats are reluctant to buy new pharmaceutical drugs, while they can continue to approve obsolete and cheaper drugs for the same illnesses.
Cancer survival rates are higher in the United States than in Europe. A recent report by the Fraser Institute in Vancouver estimates that annually tens of thousands of Canadians seek medical treatment outside of Canada, even though treatment is free inside Canada and they have to pay themselves for treatment elsewhere.
Other studies show that waiting times for surgery are months longer in Canada, Britain and Australia all countries with government-controlled medical care than in the United States.
Among the many issues explained in plain English in "The Top Ten Myths of American Health Care" are why pharmaceutical drugs cost so much, why it is misleading to talk about uninsured Americans as if they do not get medical care, and how politicians make existing insurance more expensive by blithely mandating coverage that people would not voluntarily pay for with their own money, if it was left up to them.
In various states, these mandated coverages include alcoholism, acupuncture, breast reduction and treatment for baldness, among other things. You may just want insurance to cover you in case you get hit with some big-time medical problem, but many state laws will not allow an insurance company to sell you that "major medical" coverage, without all the add-ons that politicians and special interests have come up with.
The net result is more expensive insurance, which in turn can mean more people being uninsured.
As with so many government programs, "the poor" are used as a political justification for imposing government-controlled medical care on everyone. But "The Top Ten Myths of American Medical Care" shows what a fraud that is. First of all, the average uninsured American has above-average income and people living in poverty are already eligible for Medicaid.
There are of course some serious problems with Medicaid, as there is with government medical treatment at Veterans Administration hospitals and with Medicare. But such things only highlight the dangers of having the government take over the rest of the medical sector, given its dangerous failures where it is already involved in medical matters.
The lure of something for nothing may be seductive when you are in good health. But it can become a bitter irony when you are waiting for months for surgery to relieve your pain or when your life hangs in the balance while some bureaucrat decides whether you can get the best medication or something older and cheaper.
"The Top Ten Myths About American Medical Care" can literally be a life-saver. What it reveals is unlikely to be told by the mainstream media or by other enthusiasts for the magic phrase "universal health care."
He can say that again. Thomas Sowell for President, Supreme Court, or just about anything!
Thanks for the ping jaz. Will watch for that book.
Instead we got an unqualified slimy Chicago political hack who gives a bad name to the entire human race, not just the African race, and may not even be constitutionally eligible for the office.
A great website, The Real Cuba shows what exactly happens to medical care in the phalanx that is "universal health care".
I’ve read nothing but horror stories about medical care in Cuba. Thanks for the link!
Ive got about 10 year left of practicing Medicine. I could work longer but hope I will not have too. I am going to cry for this country when we get socialized Health Care. I am glad my whole life did not have to be lived in chains. The scary thing is the years when I will need excellent health care the most it will not be available. This makes me angry.
As with all things FDR, LBJ, and now BHO have foisted upon us. Isolate it, and render it obsolete.
In health care this could mean offshoring to nearby country with less legislation and litigation.
Sometimes things that seem like spelling errors are just typing errors. I do not always use spell check when I am rushed. So do not worry. But even so a poor speller could be a great physician. Spelling is not everything and some people are just bad at it just like some can not do math well. Different strokes for different folks. Now grammer is not my thing. Had poor teachers all they way through. Plus they changed to New English and this and that every 2 years.
My address? Send the dumbocrats to Pt Barrow where they can take care of the Polar Bears!
“It is one of the painful signs of our times that millions of people are so easily swayed by rhetoric that they show virtually no interest at all in finding out the hard facts.”
Again Thomas Sowell identifies one of the most serious cracks in our Republic.
God forbid that the United States ever adopt anything like the nightmare “health” systems of England and Canada! Health will be the first thing to go.
Congratulations! Not one typo or spelling error!
“A great website, The Real Cuba shows what exactly happens to medical care in the phalanx that is “universal health care”.”
Thank you! That’s a great web site.
“He can say that again. Thomas Sowell for President, Supreme Court, or just about anything!
Bears repeating!! “
How about: “Palin/Sowell/2012”?
Again Thomas Sowell identifies one of the most serious cracks in our Republic.It is one of the painful signs of our times that millions of people are so easily swayed by rhetoric that they show virtually no interest at all in finding out the hard facts.
Yes. But I would identify the root of the problem in the monopoly which promotes the idea of the easy, cheap solution - the form of "press" created by the monopoly Associated Press in the mid-Nineteenth Century.
Big Journalism flatters its audience just as "Self esteem" education flatters students. Rather than challenging people to think, flattery denigrates the idea that thinking is necessary. "You are so great that your emotional reactions are superior to other people's best rational analysis." Doesn't that make you feel good? You don't have to think about anything at all! Nobody can be smarter than you!
What are the costs and benefits of government price caps on health care services?
A great website, The Real Cuba shows what exactly happens to medical care in the phalanx that is universal health care.And to think Michale Moore had used it as an example of great health care in Sicko .
This will definitely be a must-read!
“And to think Michale Moore had used it as an example of great health care in Sicko . “
The way they do for tourists in Russia and China.
National Hell Care
Wrong. “Grammar” is not spelled “grammer”.
Thanks for the ping. Let me flatter you c_I_c and THANK YOU for your OUTSTANDING posts, observations, essays, links, research, thinking.
Repinging the list to Post #32. Huntress has provided a link that “The Top Ten Myths of American Health Care” can be downloaded in pdf format.
Thank you very much, Huntress!
Thanks. Downloaded for later reading, but I was already scared by the stampede to Cuba style healthcare and dictatorship.
That is a good “about page.” :)
Goes to show how the leftist mind works, it’s pathetic.
Amen. God bless all doctors and *gulp* dentists.
I heard Mark Levin talking about this issue on a tape delay broadcast earlier this evening. It truly scares me how so many people have bought into the sham that is about to crash upon us in less than three weeks.
We definitely need to watch, fight...and PRAY.
an emergency book review....