Skip to comments.Naval History: All 4 Winners of Top Award Are Women
Posted on 07/28/2010 2:59:40 AM PDT by smokingfrog
History was made this week in a little noticed ceremony in Washington when the U.S. Navy awarded its "Sailor of the Year" award to four women.
The Navy gave the awards, among the most prestigious for enlisted personnel, to two hospital corpsmen, Ingrid Cortez and Shalanda Brewer, Navy reservist Samira McBride and cryptologic technician Cassandra Foote. Each was promoted to chief petty officer.
At a ceremony held at the Navy Memorial, Master Chief Petty Officer of the Navy Rick West, the service's highest ranking enlisted man said, according to a Navy news release:
"This is a great day for our Navy, and today we are making history with all four Sailors of the Year being women. These sailors have proven themselves as professional sailors, experts in their rates, role models to our junior sailors and youth, and most importantly, true leaders," said West.
(Excerpt) Read more at npr.org ...
Congratulations to the four Sailors.
But all four?
I detect a wee bit of PC propagandizing...
And two of them are corpsemens.
Could be true but I was happy to see that it was little noticed at least in Washington. I would find it hard to believe that it was a staged PC thing only because each Sailor goes before a different board, but crazier things have happened. That is for sure.
Glorifying women in the Navy (as well as cultural diversity) is one of CNO Roughead’s pet projects. The word has gone out to push women forward whether they are qualified or not for this kind of stuff.
In this climate, anyone who does NOT select a woman or person of color for these things had better have good reasons why. The “disadvantaged” person doesn’t have to prove they deserve anything; the person awarding anything (promotions, etc.) has to prove why they do NOT. This is the climate they have created, and those women will always be regarded as suspect recipients even if they thoroughly deserve those awards.
Without getting into the question of what it means to "deserve" these awards - I would think it bespeaks a major crisis if there is not a single man, not a single male human being, in the Navy who would deserve one.
That’s a good point; the powers that be aren’t concerned with that aspect of it. Political correctness is so prevalent in government work I don’t know why a “white” or Asian guy would even get into it (the private sector is tough enough, but if you have the skills to make money for a company you can rise above it).
You think? We all know all four of these women are the most deserving. It’s obvious the Navy is not looking for the best people. I have hard time believing that all 4 women are the best Navy SEALS (Which I am sure NONE OF THEM ARE), Fighter Pilots, Naval Ship or Sub Commander. This is freaking joke and the Navy has disgraced it’s name all to look as if they are actually fair. I have no doubt this will promote division at all levels within the Navy.
This is ridiculous.
Women have no serious business in fighting forces aside from bureaucratic, administrative and secretarial work.
PC run amok.
You know, I must say that these issues were vetted in Canada in the late 1970s, as promotions were given in the CAF based on whether a soldier was bilingual or not. There was a wave of early retirements.And so Trudeau, Canada's quintessential liberal fascist at the time ,succeeded in all but destroying the CAF, using political correctness and budget reduction.He too saw Canada's military as a colonial tool to be destroyed. He got rid of regular service regiments which were of Scottish tradition and made them into reserve units. Only now under Harper has the CAF begun its long climb out of its evolution away from being a peace corps like organization with political correctness ruling national defense.
This is the way Obama intends to demoralize and dehumanize real combat soldiers, not that this award alone would do it, it is a symptom, and indicator of the direction Obama intends to take on military culture. Obama intends to destroy our military culture, and substitute a fasist one, in which the military will become a threat to the general American populace. For Obama and his fascists, the military is a colonial military, one which exploits racial and ethnic minorities ( cannon fodder), and forwards capitalist colonialism around the world.Thus America will become weak militarily, subject to a diminution of its role in the world, and its national defense array inviting invasion from the South in particular.
Soon, the next images we may see is that such awards will have at least one open gay in the line up, to demoralize our military further.
Not so long ago Canada was presented with the image of two gay male RCMP officers in full scarlet dress, being married in Nova Scotia. SO you need to know where Obama is going with this, and the effect it will have in the future on our military.
The fascist goal is to destroy our all volunteer military and return to a draft system of national service,in which young Americans can chose national service ( Acorn Domestic Military force)or military service. That process has begun. Soon we will have young Americans patrolling our states in twos, bearing sub machine-guns, to keep order between racial and ethnic minorities, run by an ACORN like hierarchy?
You bet this is propagandizing, and this is the direction in which we are headed, according to what I have seen i Canada with a very similar historical liberal fascist evolution.
Note that I am not denegrating the service of these young women. I am denegrating the use to which they are being put as propaganda tools.No one should be standing up there on a platform as an icon of service without combat experience, male or female.I wonder which of them has that?
This is interesting. I was curious to know the raw percentages of men vs. women in the US Navy.
I found this information very difficult to find, and I looked in a lot of places. I know it has to be out there, but this information should be EASY to find.
It isn’t, and I am not a slouch at searching. Could be me on an off morning.
But, the best I could find is that 15% of the Active Duty Navy are women.
15%. And the FOUR BEST SAILORS IN THE ENTIRE US NAVY JUST HAPPEN TO BE WOMEN.
Sorry. I don’t buy it. Not in the least. Not that there aren’t women who serve with distinction, but this reeks of a push from above.
As the son of a 30 year naval vet, and having served myself in the USN, I find this type of thing damned embarrassing. I hope to God that if we ever get into a shooting war, that our operational readiness isn’t compromised because people were placed in jobs they weren’t qualified for to satisfy a PC requirement.
but how can you be so clear-thinking and eloquent so early in the morning?
crikey...i've posted "nom nom" on a thread about Obama at a sub shop...and even THAT took a cup of coffee first.
Nice to see you up and around so early Zin! I am off to do some financial stuff today and have an early start.
Just more “affirmative action”.
This began in full force during bubba. All promotions had merit at the bottom of the scale and gender and race at the top.
You are aware that this is an award for enlisted, and that only officers command ships or subs or fly aircraft? Or at least you would be aware if you a: had read the story, or b: ever served in the navy.
PC run amuck. Four women and two of them minorities. Not sure what percentage of naval personnel are now female, but it’s probably 20% or less. And from a small fraction of sailors come all four of the most outstanding.
Women comprise what part of the total naval population?
Probably 10%. Yet they win 100% of the awards?
Utter PC BS.
Make that 3 minorities. 2 you can tell right off the
bat, the third one, Cortez probably is a wee bit hispanic.
In a few short years the four winners will all be homosexuals.
Yeah, I noticed that when I read the photo caption after posting. This is such a farce that one wonders when the participants in these farces might begin to realize they are making such awards a laughing stock to the portion of the nation that tries to think objectively once in a while.
Expect to see more, MUCH more of this until we can drive these bastards out of office.
Fairness is one thing, but these people skew (politically correct)"fairness" so far to the opposite spectrum that the new outcome is now not just unfair, but ABSURDLY UNFAIR.
Liberalthink has bastardized the Nobel Peace, Economics, and Literature prizes.
It has made a joke of climate science.
It’s corrupting the Navy...with AF not far behind.
Don’t know about the Army...at least nothing’s appeared yet.
Hopefully, the Marines will hold out.
Gads, I love the Marines (and I’m from the USAF)!
This is PC undermining of the services. “Diversity” must be served.
Likely at least one of 'em, anyway.
David R Ray, Hospital Corpsman Second Class, USN, received the Medal of Honor for his service in Viet Nam, as did four corpsmen on Iwo Jima, three on Okinawa, and about fourteen other corpsmen. I can imagine a corpsman deserving both a “top sailor” award and a Medal of Honor (I’ve met several great men who earned that award and survived), but I’m a little curious what these women did that puts them above every single person in the Navy who serves at the pointy end of the spear.
I tend to doubt it (as an accomplished rifle and pistol expert and a WSQ swimmer in the Corps, I'm tempted to take him shooting and swimming. My bet is that he is a NSF AND a ROCK.), especially since there have been SO FEW black SEALS (1% or less from what I can glean).
He also said he used to "teach" NROTC at a certain university before he retired, but a search I did revealed a PDF version of a newsletter put out by the unit that ran that program. Each of the personnel had a bio on their military career. The Assistant Marine Officer Instructor, a Marine Gunny, had a very impressive, Two-Thirds-of-a-page bio that included medals awarded for service in the Gulf War and jump wings, etc.
My fellow employee's bio?
A FIFTH-OF-A-PAGE bio that indicated he was no more than the Supply Officer at the unit, and was an SK1 (a STORE KEEPER). There was NOTHING about being a SEAL or serving in the Gulf.
I have also found a couple of pictures of him with an online search, and ALL show a regular Squid cooking hot dogs and burgers at an event at one of his duty stations, and one in a dress uniform where no SEAL insignia is visible.
His BIO does list a three year tour as Navy Security Officer (I had a friend who had similar, temporary duty with a security unit charged with helping to guard nuclear weapon storage facilities for a few years, but this temp assignment and the training he received did NOT make him a RECON Marine) at the Naval Base in Panama. Maybe it was there that my fellow employee rubbed elbows with actual Navy SEALS, and gave him enough inside scoop to come up with his BS story, but it could have been books and TV specials that gave him the knowledge as well to try and bluff his way into gaining respect from those around him.
Any freepers that are, or were, SEALS that would know if being a SEAL, or, at least something to indicate being a SEAL, would be listed in an official BIO?
I am hard-pressed to believe this guy is telling the truth, especially given the statistics and the info I have uncovered.
Good point, and I wonder if any of these female Corpse-men have served with any combat units in Iraq or Afghanistan, or even if women Hospital Corpsmen do now serve with Marine combat units.
My guess of the outstanding Corpsman of the year would be one that had actually served with Marine units involved in combat,
They were awarded for not getting pregnant.
10 Ways to Spot a Fake US Navy SEAL
Welcome to Navy SEAL Directory
“For anyone who wants to report a fake US Navy SEAL listed in our site, you may email or call us for any of your other queries as well.”
Contests that do not require actual performance are becoming worthless in this and other countries.
DocH, I think post #38 might actually have been intended for you, as an answer to your SEAL question.
Sigh. Sounds like a fraud. I hate this kind of thing. It is sad, that someone would stoop to it...
I know I ought to feel anger and demand he be horsewhipped, but all I can feel is pity that someone feels they have to do that because it is the only thing that can make them feel worthwhile.
That's simply fabulous.
Okay. Black women, white women, maybe hispanic or asian woman (hard to tell)
What are the odds?
Again, these may be fine sailors. But I don’t think that is what this is all about, and I cannot stomach it. It grates on me.
And I can only imagine how guys in the Navy must feel. (Not that they want to get the award or anything, because most don’t really care about it, but...it is a pretty obvious PC thing)
He was so full of cr#p.
I've met several and went to school with one and they tend to be professional.
They really don't have to "prove" anything, cause they've "done everything". I like the way they fight. But that's just me.
The photo screeches volumes. It looks like a feminist taco.
Now you know why they call them "Mounties".
About 20 years ago I took my son to Washington, DC to visit the Air & Space museum at the Smithsonian. While wandering around the exhibits I spotted the names of the “First Four Women Naval Aviators” displayed on the wall.
Since I gone through flight training at Pensacola with these women, including making better grades and being named “Student of the Week” for two of my four phases, I felt a wee big “oppressed, downtrodden and disadvantaged”. But I got over it.... partly....
Now I am working on a Class Action Anti-Discrimination lawsuit against the NBA. Careful research has revealed endemic, system wide discrimination and EXCLUSION by the NBA against short, old, fat, out-of-shape, can’t-run/jump/shoot WHITE Guys!
I am only asking for reparations equaling the average rookie salary, plus four court-side season tickets from each team in the NBA. I plan to sell those to someone who actually cares about NBA basketball.
Never mind the fact that they are all women. It used to be that “sailors” went to sea. Now they sit on their bum ashore and get rewarded. Just think of all the poor men serving multiple deployments who go unrecognized. What a disgrace.
One of them, I don’t know which, was on a flight I was on late last week. The stewardess announced her and we gave her a round of applause.