Posted on 09/15/2011 3:46:24 AM PDT by Virginia Ridgerunner
The Naked Politics blog is repeating the reporting of the National Enquirer about Sarah Palin having an affair with former Miami Heat basketball player Glenn Rice.
It is on the FRONT PAGE of The Herald website.
So as a journalist, I ask:
Do we know this story to be TRUE? Are we certain it is TRUE because weve done the work or have a reasonable certainty that is TRUE?
Did anyone actually try to confirm this story before giving it Herald front page credibility? Did anyone call Glenn Rice to get independent confirmation? He lives in Miami, you know.
Is it now OK to repeat any report from the National Enquirer on the front page of the Heralds website without actually reporting even one fact independently? The blog calls The Enquirers sources solid. How do we know the Enquirers sources plural? And if we know the Enquirers sources, cant we work them ourselves to see if theyre truly solid?
Question: Can I repeat on my blog any allegation made by the Enquirer culled from any book just because, well, if its in a book or in the Enquirer, Herald policy is now to assume it must be true?
There have been a couple of good Enquirer stories on athletes coming from other planets. Those are in bounds now?
If this Rice story, unconfirmed and unreported by us, can be published on our site, do the alien stories not meet the same standards?
These, by the way, are my questions relative to journalism. But there are other things at play here. The Herald, like it or not, admit it or not, is widely viewed as a liberal newspaper. Palin is a conservative.
So we put this story on our website and conservatives that read us ask why The Herald didnt report the stories of President Obama being gay in 2007 and 2008? Those stories were in the Globe, a competitor to the Enquirer. The allegations were brought by the person who said he had a drug-crazed, gay affair with the President.
http://www.globemagazine.com/story/424
Obviously this is tabloid fodder. And we rightly never gave the Obama stuff any play because, I suppose, there was no confirmation or independent reporting done on the story.
So why is it OK to do the right thing on behalf of one presidential candidate having an unconfirmed affair but not on behalf of another potential presidential candidate having an unconfirmed affair?
We ignored the one back in 2008 and continue to do so to this day. But we run out and repeat the other first chance we get? They call that a double standard in my country.
And that also is bad journalism.
I remember when the Herald broke the Gary Hart affair story. Ive been proud to work at a paper that did that kind of work. But this cutting and pasting and unprincipled gossiping were doing on this National Enquirer story is a journalistic embarrassment at best and comparative agenda writing at worst.
Just my opinion,
Armando Salguero
I am just happy that I am not Todd. ,I know I would be in jail as I would have killed that SOB a long time ago.
I dont know why you are saying this. He is a sports reporter for the Herald and has a show on one of the local sports talk radio stations. .... LRoggy
That's right, Blowhard. Armando Salguero's job at the Miami Herald is to cover the Miami Dolphins.
The most contreversial topics that Armando covers at the Miami Herald are whether or not Chad Henne is a lost cause (apparently not after his last game) and whether or not Tony Sparano's fat butt should be fired (apparently "yes" after the last season and "yes" after the last game).
Armando is a conservative. As the Dolphins reporter, he did not have to stick up for Palin and defend her from the political writers, ..... but he did.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.