Skip to comments.Gingrich Mocks Romney's "Self-Deportation" Plan For Illegal Immigrants
Posted on 01/25/2012 1:00:13 PM PST by truthkeeper
MIAMI Former House speaker Newt Gingrich on Wednesday mocked as an Obama-level fantasy Mitt Romneys plan to deal with illegal immigration by encouraging self-deportation.
Gingrich made the comment as he began a day of outreach to Floridas Hispanic voters with an extensive interview on Spanish-language television and a speech at Florida International University in which he called for a more a forceful U.S. role in ending communist rule in Cuba, as well as an overhaul of U.S. economic policies toward all of Latin America.
In an interview with the Univision network, Gingrich said it was unrealistic for millions of illegal immigrants in the United States to voluntarily leave the country, as Romney, his chief rival for the Republican presidential nomination, suggested in a debate Monday ahead of Floridas Jan. 31 primary. Gingrich, who upset the GOP race by decisively winning Saturdays South Carolina primary, also used a question about the immigration issue to get in a few digs at the former Massachusetts governor over his wealth and tax returns.
You have to live in a world of Swiss bank accounts and Cayman Island accounts and automatic $20 million income for no work to have some fantasy this far from reality, Gingrich told Univision interviewer Jorge Ramos. For Romney to believe that somebodys grandmother is going to be so cut off that she is going to self-deport, I mean this is an Obama-level fantasy.
(Excerpt) Read more at washingtonpost.com ...
Nana Mocks Romney’s “Self-Deportation” Plan For Illegal Immigrants
and when teh Nana loves at ya...
ya been well and truly laughed at
ya big doofus...
You have to live in a world of Swiss bank accounts and Cayman Island accounts and automatic $20 million income for no work to have some fantasy this far from reality, Gingrich told Univision interviewer
How on earth is this type of comment coming from a so called strong conservative.
Newt’s right though. It’s fantastical to expect that millions are simply going to voluntarily self-deport once the border is sealed and the laws are enforced. Yes, some will leave. But many will remain.
I don’t want a private equity investment manager as my president. Does that make me not conservative?
Pandering for the illegal alien loving vote in the Florida primary might work, but how does Newt expect to outbid ObaMao in the general election?
And those that do can stay "in the shadows," as far as I am concerned. They don't deserve bennies from us.
We sure have. So, why does Newt mock the concept? Does it bother him, or does he think it will bother potential Florida voters? D'uh. They can't be conservatives, right?
Newt’s plans/rhetoric aside (cuz’I’m not really up on HIS particular stance), it really IS the key and states like Alabama have proven it so.
If we get tough and start JAILING people who rent, support and employ illegals, it will work.
Make this country HOSTILE to the notion of supporting those who come here illegally and take the tit from them.
In addition, I would love to see those who are responsible for the unlawful creation of “sanctuary citizens” to be perp-marched as well.
I agree they shouldn’t receive benefitsnobody is saying they should receive anything.
But you’re still going to have millions who remain here, supported off the books by their own people. There needs to be a plan for dealing with them.
Some birds will still stay in your yard if you take the bird feeder down, but they will tend to be the more industrious type who can get along fine without taxpayer handouts. IOW, not your typical La Raza voters.
Still at it I see. We both agree that attrition through enforcement works. And there is no need to legalize the status of those that remain. We just make our country as inhospitable to lawbreakers as we possibly can including shutting off the job magnet, checking the immigration of those on lawful stops, cutting off all benefits etc. No amnesty period.
Automatic 20 million for no work?
So Gingrich thinks someone dependent on money earned through investments is lazy and does not work.
Self-deportation is underway as we speak, thanks to the leadership of Arizona with Alabama, Georgia and other states following with strong measures.
I guess Gingrich disapproves of the self-deportation policies of his home state, Georgia. The guy is a walking bundle of contradictions whose reach in to leftist rhetoric to win conservative votes is a wonder to see.
The point of Newt’s comment was that Romney is out of touch with the realities most people face. That is undeniably true. It wasn’t class warfare rhetoric.
Like I said, I don’t want a private equity investment manager as my president. We’re not running for best CEO here.
The plan is called attrition thru enforcement. We should enforce our existing immigration laws. It is illegal for an employer to hire an illegal alien and it is illegal for an illegal alien to work. And we have laws against ID theft, driving without a license, tax evasion, etc. I really don't see the urgency of having to deal with those already here beyond normal law enforcement. No mass roundups and mass deportations. And you secure the borders and set up a system to track and deport visa overstays.
Newt Gingrich on self-deportation “Romney shows no concern for ‘Humanity’ of illegals”+
There was a time when Romney tried to out-gay and out-abortion Kennedy. Kennedy, a left winger, was amazed at the attempt from someone most saw as more conservative than him. Now Romney knows how Kennedy felt.
I live in Texas, most will leave when their reason for being here drys up. As for those that choose to remain? Well we can talk about that AFTER enforcement is put in place.
Nobody is talking about taking away Romney’s money. In fact, Newt proposes no cap gain tax for everyone and not just the middle class. Romney’s tax plan is the one with class warfare, not Newt’s.
But if all Romney has going for him is his record at Bain then it’s not much there.
Newt doesn’t disapprove of self-deportationdon’t be absurd.
But it’s sheer fantasy to think that self-deportation alone is going to address the problem as a whole.
How to Deport 10-20 Million Illegal Aliens (Self-Deportation)
More than 50,000 Americans have been killed by illegal aliens since 9/11.
Think about that.
More than 6,000 U.S. troops have been killed in Iraq and Afghanistan since that same date. But nearly ten times that number have been killed right here at home as a consequence of the Federal governments failure to secure our borders and protect its citizens, in direct violation of the Constitutions Article IV Section 4:
The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government, and shall protect each of them against Invasion; and on Application of the Legislature, or of the Executive (when the Legislature cannot be convened) against domestic Violence.
More than 50,000 dead as a direct result of this violation. Yet the media ignores the victims. And politicians dont recognize the loss of tens of thousands of families.
But today We The People remember.
Today is National Remembrance Day for Americans Killed By Illegal Aliens. A coalition of groups fighting against illegal immigration, including Stand With Arizona, the FIRE Coalition, and Congressmen Steve King (R-IA) and Walter Jones (R-NC) have joined together to recognize this day in honor of the victims.
So sorry, meant to add “I agree with you” at post #23.
Instead of going back many will move into crime, drug dealing, illegal gambling, prostitution.
You have to physically ship them out.
They already are. I should know, I'm surrounded by them.
Without getting into the political fight between Romney and Gingrich, the key to stopping illegal immigration is to deny access to employment and basic services. If you can't get a job and you can't get electricity, water, gas, etc., then you will go somewhere else.
The lowest impact across the board would be the creation of a guest agricultural worker program, which would allow the seasonal hiring of workers without their families. Then phase in a requirement that all employees be run through e-Verify.
I am unaware of any candidate who is saying that self-deportation, i.e., attrition thru enforcement alone, will solve the problem.
He’s not a conservative, he pretends to be.
Romney apparently does.
It’s no plan at all, like everything Romney says.
Somebody needs to inform Newt of the cold, hard facts ~ WE DON’T WANT THEM. They have homes they can go to. We don’t.
It's time to cut off the gravy train. Send them back. Let them take their cars and trucks with them.
In 2006 I had a room addition built. My BF, who was the general contractor, said the two local Home Depots were ringed with illegals on all sides. They would practically jump into their truck every time he and his crew pulled into the lot for supplies. As of last year, he said there are only about a dozen of them hanging around the lots. Due to our lousy economy, their numbers have been greatly reduced.
The process of self-deportation has, in fact, already begun.
That is because no candidate is proposing self-deportation only.
We came out of the paleolithic into the neolithic with almost no one farming. Human beings simply aren't made for it.
Starve the beast.
We have one it's called deportation.
The illegals are already into crime. First, get rid of their cover ~
It is fantastical because millions will still remain and pose huge problems.
There doesn't seem to be any way to win on this issue, does there? Either they claim "no one can round up 11 million (ha!) illegals and send them home" or "self-deportation alone won't work."
Don't they call that having your cake and eating it too?
LOL! Was that a joke?
Well while I do not like Myth, I do agree with Myth’s plan, I dislike Newt’s immigration position even less, let’s hope we can get Newt to rethink his position.
Well, call me Pollyanna but hopefully we can actually DISCUSS THE ISSUE on this thread without it deteriorating into a bash-fest.
Despite the berry growers having some really cool looking berry picking machines they still need a lot of manual (in this area that means Manuel) labor.
It is simple. People say it's hard becaue they don't want to deal with it.