Skip to comments.What if Catholic bishops arenít bluffing? (To close hospitals and schools because of HHS Mandate)
Posted on 03/01/2012 6:50:36 AM PST by SeekAndFind
Earlier this week, Francis Cardinal George of the archdiocese of Chicago sent a message to parishioners in Barack Obama’s home town that imposition of the HHS mandate to fund and facilitate contraception, abortifacients, and sterilization would force the Catholic Church to close its hospitals, clinics, schools, and all other organizations that would otherwise have to comply. “Two Lents from now,” Cardinal George warned, “unless something changes, the page [listing Catholic organizations] will be blank.” At the time, some commenters wrote that this has been Obama’s plan all along — to force religious charities out of business to make people more dependent on government. Others, including myself, figure that Obama just thinks the bishops are bluffing, and wants to engage in a high-stakes bout of brinksmanship to force them to kneel to secular authority over doctrine.
But how high are those stakes? In my column for The Fiscal Times today, I did a little research just on Catholic hospitals and their significance in American health care. As it turns out, this bet involved nearly $100 billion in annual costs and about one-seventh of all hospital beds in the US — and that’s not all:
The Catholic Church has perhaps the most extensive private health-care delivery system in the nation. It operates 12.6 percent of hospitals in the U.S., according to the Catholic Health Association of the U.S., accounting for 15.6 percent of all admissions and 14.5 percent of all hospital expenses, a total for Catholic hospitals in 2010 of $98.6 billion. Whom do these hospitals serve? Catholic hospitals handle more than their share of Medicare (16.6 percent) and Medicaid (13.65) discharges, meaning that more than one in six seniors and disabled patients get attention from these hospitals, and more than one in every eight low-income patients as well. Almost a third (32 percent) of these hospitals are located in rural areas, where patients usually have few other options for care.
Compared to their competition, Catholic hospitals take a leading role in providing less-profitable services to patients. They lead the sector in breast cancer screenings, nutrition programs, trauma, geriatric services, and social work. In most of these areas, other non-profits come close, but hospitals run by state and local governments fall significantly off the pace. Where patients have trouble paying for care, Catholic hospitals cover more of the costs. For instance, Catholic Health Services in Florida provides free care to families below 200 percent of federal poverty line, accepting Medicaid reimbursements as payment in full, and caps costs at 20 percent of household income for families that fall between 200 percent and 400 percent of the federal poverty line.
Imagine the impact if these hospitals shut down, discounting the other 400-plus health centers and 1,500 specialized homes that the Catholic Church operates as part of its mission that would also disappear. Thanks to the economic models of these hospitals, no one will rush to buy them. One in six patients in the current system would have to vie for service in the remaining system, which would have to absorb almost $100 billion in costs each year to treat them. Over 120,000 beds would disappear from an already-stressed system.
The poor and working class families that get assistance from Catholic benefactors would end up having to pay more for their care than they do under the current system. Rural patients would have to travel farther for medical care, and services like social work and breast-cancer screenings would fall to the less-efficient government-run institutions. That would not only impact the poor and working class patients, but would create much longer wait times for everyone else in the system. Finally, over a half-million people employed by Catholic hospitals now would lose their jobs almost overnight, which would have a big impact on the economy as well as on health care.
Of course, it’s not just hospitals. The Catholic Church runs over 7500 primary and secondary education schools in the US (where over a third of students are non-Catholics), educating more than 2.5 million students. Thanks to a near-blanket moratorium on vouchers, taxpayer money doesn’t get used in teaching these students in a system that has a 99% graduation rate and a 97% success rate at placing students in college. Based on an average student cost of $8000 in public schools, Catholic schools save taxpayers about $20 billion dollars a year.
Perhaps with schools, though, the notion that Obama wants to crowd out private enterprise in favor of the public sector makes more sense. How about charities? Catholic Charities would also have to close its doors if the bishops refuse to comply with the HHS mandate. In 2003, the latest data available, they provided emergency food services to 6.5 million people, temporary shelter to over 200,000 people, and a range of other assistance to another 1.5 million people, including assistance in clothing, finances, utilities, and even medication. Those efforts would disappear overnight, along with schools and hospitals.
Surely, some will think, the bishops are just bluffing, and won’t purposefully create such a social disaster. Perhaps, but consider the teachings of St. Ignatius of Loyola, the founder of the Jesuit order and a deeply influential figure in Catholic thinking:
Some may doubt that the bishops would create this kind of havoc and disruption, and perhaps President Obama believes Cardinal George and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops to be bluffing. However, Obama may want to read St. Ignatius of Loyola, the founder of the Jesuits, and his Principle and Foundation of faith, which informs Catholics on the priority of salvation. The first task of mankind, according to St. Ignatius, is to serve God and save his soul, and other things on the face of the earth should be used only as long as they serve that purpose. When they become a hindrance to salvation, St. Ignatius warns to rid himself of them.
If the HHS mandate forces the Catholic Church to fund and facilitate access to products and services they believe imperil souls, they will apply Ignatius’ principle and stick with salvation — which is the entire raison d’être of any religious organization. The implications for public-sector spending and services is massive, and Obama may be pushing all in with only a pair of jacks. Don’t count on the bishops to blink first.
This would also cause chaos with medical education. Many of the Catholic hospitals are conjoined with a Catholic university medical school.
I believe that this is part of der Fuehrer’s plan.
If the bishops fold on this, it’s going to be hard for me to stay in the Church. Already I don’t donate to CC or the schools. I just donate for my little parish church to keep its doors open and to Christian radio. I’ll find a parish with no school that doesn’t pledge to any one except Rome.
They will probably work out some phoney-baloney plastic banana good-time rock-and-roll arrangement like the one that Mercy Hospital has with UPMC here in Pittsburgh.
Under that deal UPMC gets to run the place and call all the shots, while they retain the name Mercy and become CINO (Catholic In Name Only). I presume that the Order of Nuns gets some cut of whatever profit UPMC can squeeze out of the place.
You will see the largest confiscation of church property since the Age of Terror.
Or since Henry the 8th.
It would give Obama every excuse he needs to officially nationalize the entire health-care industry.
Although I am not Catholic, I stand behind them on this.
The public school teacher unions will rejoice over Catholic schools closing.
Catholic Charities closed its adoption centers here in MA, because they would have been forced to adopt children out to sodomites.
There was barely a whimper from the public.
When the Church is forced to sell off hospitals, the reaction will be similar.
The Marxists formed our society in government schools. They are now simply reaping the harvest.
An abortifacient kills an innocent life. The Bible has only three instances where God approves the breaking of the law, and one of them is saving innocent life. See Exodus 1:17. The Catholic Church should defy the law and accept the punishment for doing so. I doubt even Obama wants nationwide television coverage of nuns and bishops being hauled off in cuffs.
And the goverment would decide which babies live and which babies are murdered and the smae for people who are ill.
-——They will serve as long as they can and then close the doors. Take away everything and it turns out they are OK with that. The brothers are not men who take their ethics lightly.-——
Catholic colleges went down the tubes when the religious-led boards were turned over to the laity.
1967 was the year.
God bless the good sisters, brothers, priests and bishops.
Looks like we’re headed for the catacombs. It might not be a bad thing.
As a Lifelong Catholic, I give this opinion.
The Church may sell these hospitals or turn them over to someone else to run, but they love money too much to just close them.
RE: I doubt even Obama wants nationwide television coverage of nuns and bishops being hauled off in cuffs.
They raided Gibson Guitars and seized a half-million dollars worth of property for “violating” ( note the quotes ) an inappropriate tariff code on wood from India and have not even filed any charges MONTHS LATER !!
First they came for Gibson and no one spoke up for them because guitars are not their business, then they’ll come for the Catholics, will anyone speak up for them?
———The Catholic Church should defy the law and accept the punishment for doing so. I doubt even Obama wants nationwide television coverage of nuns and bishops being hauled off in cuffs.-——
He won’t. He’ll just seize title and bank accounts. Sometime later the doors will be padlocked.
The Church simply doesn’t have the resources to support a sit-in. And what little She has will be confiscated.
Confrontation is justifiable, if not called for. It’s just hard to imagine an effective tactic.
Regardless, judging from past performance, the bishops lack the courage for confrontation, but then, so does the laity. We’re soft.
Really? What’s the profit margin on a Catholic Hospital?
I agree, Obama probably will use this as a pretext for confiscating Church property.
But I think his real objective is to replace the Church, just as Henry VIII did. In other words, he’ll try to peel off enough bishops and clergy to create a sham organization and will let them keep certain properties (such as the church buildings) and continue purely “religious” activities.
He’ll probably find many if not most Catholics will be just fine with that. Remember, only one bishop (St John Fisher) refused to go along with Henry VIII.
-——Not all. I’m Jesuit educated in the 1980’s and I’m probably one of the few kids who went into college an apathetic mind of mush and came out a coneservative.-——
It seems that there are only about 12 truly Catholic colleges left in America. The bishops have been negligent in failing to strip the word “Catholic” from the names of the nominal ones.
RE: It seems that there are only about 12 truly Catholic colleges left in America
Let me count a few...
Ave Maria University
Franciscan University of Steubenville
The College of Saint Thomas More
University of Dallas
University of St. Thomas (Houston, TX)
Aquinas College (Nashville, TN.)
College of the Holy Cross
I am stump because I can’t think of any more (so people, help me out ).
I can’t include the following colleges anymore -—
University of Notre Dame, Georgetown, Marist, Fordham, Villanova and a whole heap of others because I think they will compromise ( Notre Dame awarded Obama an honorary degree a few years ago ).
Ya got me.
I sincerely hope they are not bluffing.
Holy Cross in MA? You’ll have to cross that one off.
You can add Magdalene, a very small college in NH.
My reaction is that this is all part of the plan of Obama and his minions: close down the economic contributions of the Catholics. Those bastards want the Catholics and all other religious groups out of the economy.
If this happens they will just replace them with governments entities.
OK, after reading all of the above posts, I wish to add my two cents worth.
The only way to get Obama to back down is to somehow force the government to arrest the leaders of the Church and these facilities. That cannot be done by closing the hospitals and charities and schools. [especially the schools - as the government wants a monopoly on all education].
Our bishops need to lead the laity in active rebellion against an unjust government mandate. They can do this by keeping open the facilities and by refusing to change their insurance programs - or by refusing to pay the fine imposed by their disobediance. Somehow, we need to confront them and their abusive use of federal power against otherwise law-abiding citizens who refute their ideology. Unfortunately I think the arrest and imprisonment of bishops, nuns and laity over this stupid government mandate may be necessary to finally open the eyes of the majority of U.S. citizens. It will fire up the “silent majority’ of hard-working and conservative-minded people like no other way.
The bishops aren’t bluffing. But I think the probably have authority to close only a few of these schools and hospitals. Many of them probably have autonomous boards of trustees. And many of the executives and governing board members will defy the bishops and keep the hospitals and schools open.
Elementary and some high schools are more directly under bishops’ control, but even many of the high schools are run by religious orders who only indirectly answer to bishops.
Bishops can withdraw the name “Catholic” but if they do that, in most cases, people will yawn and shrug.
Our bishops need to lead the laity in active rebellion against an unjust government mandate. They can do this by keeping open the facilities and by refusing to change their insurance programs - or by refusing to pay the fine imposed by their disobediance. Somehow, we need to confront them and their abusive use of federal power against otherwise law-abiding citizens who refute their ideology. Unfortunately I think the arrest and imprisonment of bishops, nuns and laity over this stupid government mandate may be necessary to finally open the eyes of the majority of U.S. citizens. It will fire up the silent majority of hard-working and conservative-minded people like no other way."
I think you are correct. Simply closing the facilities will allow them to fade away with a whimper and the closures will be minimized and ignored by the MSM. We need high profile confrontations with the would be dictator to have any chance to turn back his effort to destroy Christianity in the US.
Shutting down Catholic hospitals would obviously reduce access to care which in turn reduces the cost of government health care. I would imagine, with so much uncompenstated and undercompensated care that in many if not most cases, operating margins are very low or negative for these hospitals. Shedding health care will permit the Bishops to concentrate on their core mission; that is saving souls. I think that the Bishops are fully aware that if they are co-opted by 0bama, the Catholic Church will not be taken seriously; they will be finished.
Thomas Aquinas College (CA)
Don’t think so , millions of new students but no new facilities/staff also the students showing everyone else just how poorly the public schools really are.
Sadly I believe that you are correct in your assesment of the situation & analysis of the strategy & tactics needed to defeat the govt. sadly however the Church will not go along with it as it does not have the will to do so at the very highest levels do to a lack of discipline and will to fight .