Your job was to objectively apply the law to the existing facts. Nothing more. You sound like you did more than your job, maybe too much emotion involved.
You weren’t there, so you don’t know what you’re talking about. You don’t know the charges, the evidence we heard, or anything else. You don’t know the commentary we got from the prosecuting attorney or the judge after we rendered our decision and the trial was over. [Both the judge and the assistant distract attorney agreed that we came to what they considered the fairest conclusion.]
So, I’ll discard your idle comment for the trash it is.