Skip to comments.George Zimmerman: Self-defense hearing could dismiss death charge(FL)
Posted on 04/13/2012 6:47:55 AM PDT by marktwain
George Zimmerman can ask to have the second-degree-murder charge against him dropped without having to stand trial in the death of Trayvon Martin.
Two years ago, the Florida Supreme Court ruled that anyone claiming "stand your ground" immunity in a death, battery or assault case can request a hearing on the evidence.
The hearing allows the prosecution and defense to argue all the elements of self-defense in the case evidence. To get charges dismissed, the accused must convince the judge that a reasonable person would believe that using deadly force or the threat of deadly force was the only way to protect his or her life, court records show.
The state's "stand your ground" law passed in 2005 says:
"A person who is not engaged in an unlawful activity and who is attacked in any other place where he or she has a right to be has no duty to retreat and has the right to stand his or her ground and meet force with force, including deadly force if he or she reasonably believes it is necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony."
Berman said he thinks Mark O'Mara, Zimmerman's lawyer, will request an evidentiary hearing as part of his defense of Zimmerman's "stand your ground" claim.
(Excerpt) Read more at articles.orlandosentinel.com ...
I heard that too this AM and it ROYALLY pissed me off.
She is pathetic, honest to God.
I emailed Fox & Friends when she said it and called her the liar she is.
You won't find an honest one that could claim either way. They need more than a screech heard from a distance through an iffy cell phone microphone to have any level of confidence, plus a number of samples of similar "speech" from both parties.
We know he ran off and wasn’t with Zimmerman since the 911 cal didn’t feature Trayvon in the background.
Later Trayvon seemed to teleport himself on top of Zimmerman according to witnesses where he was starting to beat him to death.
He was referring to the FL Supreme court ability and action during the 2000 Presidential election.
Even if you can come up with a news storythat mentions this account the fact that phony “social” accounts are so easy to manufacture would make it hard to prove that it is really Zimmerman's account.
Of course if you can't come up with a reliable source that may prove that you are a venom spewer too. Or perhaps you just failed to put a necessary /sarc tag on your post. Until you fail to come up with something real to support your post I will assume the latter.
If Zimmerman is telling the truth, he had no chance to retreat—Martin came up and attacked him.
I have a question about the girlfriend.
Why didn’t she call anyone when the phone went dead?
She’s talking to Trayvon, he says a guy is following him, she hears the beginnings of a confrontation, the phone goes dead, and....well thats it.
Tracy Martin was completely in the dark, the next day, when he discovered Trayvon was missing. So the girlfriend obviously didn’t call him, or the cousin, or Trayvon’s mom...nobody. The phone went dead, and she never heard from him again...and just continued on with her day?
This is why I doubt the veracity of her statements so far. They don’t logically fit with her complete inaction, after the phone call. I’m sure this will all get sorted out in court.
Bingo. What reasonable person would not call the police after hearing a person they had a relationship with getting assaulted? She supposedly told him to run because she was in fear for his safety and then after the line goes dead, it’s oh well, time for a new boyfriend? Come on, no one is going to believe that truckload of manure.
I think if this girl is called to testify, her testimony may get impeached quick, fast and in a hurry.
Unfortunately I think we’re in the Twilight Zone where the usual rules (of Law) don’t apply.
This is why I doubt the veracity of her statements so far.
Hey, I've got an idea. Let's wait until she gives her side of the story before we decide if she's a liar.
Unfortunately, it appears to me that, regardless of what happens, Zimmerman will spend the rest of his life in prison, either:
1) Because he is convicted (which carries a minimum of 25 years and a maximum of life); or,
2) If he is acquitted, or after he gets out of prison following a conviction, he will have to go into permanent hiding (giving up his life, thus a very real form of prison) because of the vigilantes who would want to hunt him down.
Too bad, especially if he is acquitted.
IOW...you have no proof that what you said is true. thank you for your round-about admission.
>>>The SYG law quite probably has no application in the Zimmerman case, but this case will be used to demonize the law. Count on it.
Will be?? Too late. Already has...
I never spewed venom about anyone. Try to follow who posted what - I know it's difficult for you Einstein but try to make the effort.
That assumes ZImmerman willingly presented the firearm. Given the incredible amount of restraint the majority of known evidence indicates, I do not believe the gun was intentionally displayed.
You’re evading the question, why has there been no mention . . . none . . . of Zimmerman’s “datniggytb” account?
Just about everyone gushed over Martin’s maybe or maybe not real twitter account. It proved he was a violent, gangsta-wannabe, gold-toothed, drug-dealing, tattooed thug. It also said he was 5’8” and 19 years old.
If phony social accounts are so easy to manufacture, how can you be sure that “@no_limit_nigga” is an actual account belonging to Trayvon Martin? Citation, please . . . a reliable source, not a news story or site that merely mentions the account.
The furor over the no limit nigga account was due to the fact the MSM tried to paint TM as a 12 yo school boy just out walking around when he was shot by a no good white hispanic.
Read the facts, not the MSM BS, listen to the 911 calls, read the eyewitness accounts, there is no doubt it was self defense.
You, of course, have made up your mind and decided to get on FR and stir up some sh**. Good luck with that, you'll need it.
Thank you for shooting down the propaganda postings here.
the fl gov is already setting special hearing to “study” syg and how to change it.
IOW the criminal protection act. his excuse? lower crime.
That is an excellent question and one I haven't heard anyone pose before. I didn't think of that either. Most of us would call someone, the police, a friend, his parents, someone. Being on the other end of a call like that would scare the crap out of most people.
He also said, They always get away, f'n blank holes and he kept following Trayvon.
Apparently you haven't been following this story very well.
Lawyer: Girl on phone with Trayvon Martin cuts shooter's self-defense claim
A girl who overheard part of an incident involving Florida teenager Trayvon Martin can help prove he was killed "in cold blood" by George Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch volunteer, an attorney for Martin's family said Tuesday.
The girl -- who he said does not wish to be identified -- "connects the dots" about what happened that day when she lays out what she overheard while on the phone with him, he said.
Speaking on the phone shortly before he was shot, Martin told the girl that someone was following him and that he was trying to get away, Crump said.
The girl said that, during the phone call, she heard someone ask Martin what he was doing and heard Martin ask why the person was following him, Crump said. The girl then got the impression that there was an altercation in which the earpiece fell out of Martin's ear and the connection went dead, Crump said.
Hey! I've got an idea. Why don't you read up on this story before shooting from the lip.
Another poster asked about it and I gave him a link to info on it. Do you have anything useful to add or just that made up nonsense?
The PD coverup just didn't work. The Sanford Police Chief should just resign cuz it's going to get worse for him as the evidence and the omissions start to drip out in trial.
Drip, drip, drip. I think there could be a case made that the Sanford Police Chief engaged in OBSTRUCTION as he indicated that the case was all wrapped up; as wrapped up as a young man in a body bag in a morgue with a giant gaping hole in his chest.
Yeah, nothing to see there.
Why didn’t Trayvon call 911?
I think you can assume that after you are rendered unconscious by your attacker that he will find the gun no matter where you concealed it.
Zimmerman had to assume that the guy who attacked him and was pounding his head into the concrete was not only going to take the gun from him after he was out, but to use it on him to eliminate any potential witness to the attack.
Let me ask you if you had a gun and a guy you didn't know and whom you suspected to be a burglar or other felon had you down on the ground and was bashing your head against the concrete, do you think you would not hesitate to pull out your gun from it's concealed location and use it?
Would you feel OK with the knowledge that if you were knocked out, that the attacker would not find the gun and use it on you because you had not "displayed" it?
“She said that she heard the sound of pushing and that Martin’s headset suddenly went silent, leading her to believe that he had been pushed. She attempted to call him back immediately, but was unable to reach him”
And her statement is mentioned in the charging affidavit.
I am with you 100%, the entire charge against Zimmerman is OUTRAGEOUS
I see dead people.
I read the article, makes zero difference what they said then, these folks make up the rules as they go along. Matters not what they said yesterday,if a case is political the law and reasoning go out the window.
If phony social accounts are so easy to manufacture, how can you be sure that @no_limit_nigga is an actual account belonging to Trayvon Martin?
2) I am not citing the Martin account as proof of anything, you are citing some Zimmerman account as proof of something. I have nothing to prove, you do. So prove it. Or don't. Your decision.
That made up nonsense is from the charging Affidavit by the State Attorney but she’s a troll too?
George ssaid, it was f'n cold.
That is in the charging affidavit? Link please.
Let's not forget that I was replying to your accusation that I was "still going over the audio." An utterly stupid remark since I was giving info to someone who asked for it.
The DA is unsatisfactory to many posters here. She was called some great names as have I. Do a search for George Zimmerman Charging Affidavit and I think you can find it.
“Is there *any* doubt that the girlfriend will lie her a$$ off...”
Venom? Or a sweet bouquet of flowers and complements to a person you do not know? Perhaps someone else is posting as "circlecity" besides you?
The account was deleted, and the Google cache is now also gone.
However, I found the Google cache before it was gone, and it was for sure Trayvon Martin's account. The cache entry was dated Feb 6, 2012 12:29:45 GMT. It contained a birthday greeting from the lovely and charming EatYhurBrainz, aka Kia (whose ballistic background pic would have pleased Doc Edgerton). Kia turns out to attend the same high school as Martin. And her greeting would have been sent on the evening of 5 February. Martin was born on 5 February 1995.
Martin's Twitter account handle was NO_LIMIT_NIGGA (all caps). He listed his name as SLIMM, his location as YO HOE CRIB, and his favorite website as LIES.COM. Dude liked caps!
Oh, and speaking of background pictures, the one Martin chose to tile beneath his Twitter droppings was this:
That's the mugshot of rapper Corey Miller, aka C-Murder, who is doing life without parole for beating up and shooting to death 16-year-old Steve Thomas in 2002 at a night club in Harvey, Louisiana. Quite the role model for an up and coming wannabe gang banger, don't you think?
BTW, Martin's NO_LIMIT_NIGGA handle would appear to allude to C-Murder's record company, No Limit Records.
What does that excuse have to do with anything? If you have called her names why accuse me, as if it were a bad thing, of calling her a troll. Particularly in light of the fact that I didn't. Are you on drugs?
Why add an unsubstantiated unconsciousness to the mix?
And once a reasonable certainty of serious bodily harm is established, any supposition of the perpetrators previous legal history is irrelevant.
Point is, Zimmerman’s history of respect for law enforcement (ancient history aside) and the training he received from the sheriffs dept. instilled in him a certain amount of procedural restraint. Otherwise that gun would have come out the second he ran into Martin again. But it didn’t.
My hypothesis is, Zimmerman, expecting a patrol car any second, backpedaled and fended off Martin’s advances as long as he could. Martin gained the upper hand and the gun was exposed as a result of the struggle. Martin went for the weapon, that’s when Zimmerman’s cries for help began. Some 40 seconds later the trigger is pulled.
Some time ago, ABC published an article about the girlfriend and the phone calls. It had a photo of the T-Mobile bill for Martin's phone:
We see the two calls he received just before the fight. Then there is a gap until March 2, at which time someone used his phone to call 911.
Hmmm. Could that be when the Sanford PD finally got around to investigating the phone? Could the 911 call be the Sanford PD calling themselves in order to find out the phone's number?
It may be that the phone was passworded. Passworded phones can usually be used to call 911 without needing to know the password, I believe. If the phone was passworded, the police would have needed T-Mobile's assistance for any investigation other than discovering the number by calling themselves.
I think I read that Martin was carrying no ID. So, his phone would have been the quickest way to identify him, I would think. Why did it take until March 2?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.