Posted on 04/16/2012 7:20:11 AM PDT by Baynative
Taliban-led insurgents opened a spring offensive Sunday with a wave of coordinated suicide missions, firing at embassies and government offices from seized buildings in Kabul and attacking U.S. bases and police stations in three eastern provinces.
The strikes, which seemed to catch U.S.-led forces and Afghan authorities by surprise, sparked fierce firefights in Kabul and two other cities that underscored the insurgency's lethality as U.S. combat troops gird for the second phase of a withdrawal due to end in 2014.
(Excerpt) Read more at mcclatchydc.com ...
I was in Danang, Vietnam during the Tet offensive. I remember it very well.
I guess you remember it very well indeed. I was just speaking as an average American stateside who watched the events on TV, as presented by the “media.” The term “mainstream media” had not been invented yet because there were no real alternatives available.
I guess you remember it very well indeed. I was just speaking as an average American stateside who watched the events on TV, as presented by the “media.” The term “mainstream media” had not been invented yet because there were no real alternatives available.
No, we were actually winning the war. The Tet Offensive was a desperate attempt to change the direction of the war. The result was that a large portion of the VC was wiped out in the mistaken belief that the offensive would cause a popular uprising supporting them. Unfortunately, it was portrayed as a defeat for us, but the reality on the ground was much different. Once Walter Cronkite declared the war unwinnable, public and political support started to decline rapidly.
Here is a good site to track the timeline of the war in Vietnam
I thank God my son is out of that hell-hole now. Prayers up for our soldiers who are still there and trying to fight Obozo’s lost war. IMHO our soldiers should be brought home right now if this feckless Pres__ent is unwilling to allow our troops to win.
According to my son, who, thanks to God, has been back from that hell-hole since the end of January, there is no military mission in Afghanistan anymore.
It wasn’t about Walter Cronkite. It was seeing that the enemy was still capable of mounting attacks simultaneously across the entire country, and nearly overrunning our embassy that made people stop and wonder.
You weren’t in the US, but what caused the public and popular support to decline rapidly was not only the Tet offensive, but, even more importantly, the end of student deferments. Once middle class and upper class kids lost their exemption from military service, their parents started asking much more serious questions about just what was going on in Vietnam. That was the beginning of the end of the war.
Its really a police mission.
That should be handled by the locals.
Much like Iraq has been handled by the locals, fairly well so far, everything considered.
Heavens! It’s a quagmire! Just like Vietnam! But Fireless Leader knows what to do! He’ll negotiate!/s
"As the TET offensive continued into February, the anchorman for the CBS evening news, Walter Cronkite, traveled to Vietnam and filed several reports. Upon his return, Cronkite took an unprecedented step of presenting his "editorial opinion" at the end of the news broadcast on February 27th. "For it seems now more certain than ever," Cronkite said, "that the bloody experience of Vietnam is to end in a stalemate." After watching Cronkite's broadcast, LBJ was quoted as saying. "That's it. If I've lost Cronkite, I've lost middle America."
You weren’t in the US, but what caused the public and popular support to decline rapidly was not only the Tet offensive, but, even more importantly, the end of student deferments. Once middle class and upper class kids lost their exemption from military service, their parents started asking much more serious questions about just what was going on in Vietnam. That was the beginning of the end of the war.
I didn't spend the entire time in Vietnam during my 7 years of service, 1965-72--just one year in country and another 8 months off the coast. I was aware of what was going on in the US, including having two brothers who got student deferments. The reality is that student deferments ended in 1971 almost at the end of the war.
The Military Selective Service Act of 1967 expanded the ages of conscription to the ages of 18 to 35. It still granted student deferments, but ended them upon either the student's completion of a four-year degree or his 24th birthday, whichever came first. The act was amended in 1971 ending student deferments except for Divinity students, who received a 2-D Selective Service classification.
According to the Veteran's Administration, 9.2 million men served in the military between 1964 and 1975. Nearly 3.5 million men served in the Vietnam theater of operations. From a pool of approximately 27 million, the draft raised 2,215,000 men for military service during the Vietnam era. It has also been credited with "encouraging" many of the 8.7 million "volunteers" to join rather than risk being drafted.
Of the nearly 16 million men not engaged in active military service, 96% were exempted (typically because of jobs including other military service), deferred (usually for educational reasons), or disqualified (usually for physical and mental deficiencies but also for criminal records to include draft violations). Draft offenders in the last category numbered nearly 500,000 but less than 10,000 were convicted or imprisoned for draft violations. Finally, as many as 100,000 draft eligible males fled the country.
With the end of active U.S. ground participation in Vietnam, December 1972 saw the last men conscripted, who were born in 1952 and who reported for duty in June 1973. On February 2, 1972, a drawing was held to determine draft priority numbers for men born in 1953, but in early 1973 it was announced that no further draft orders would be issued. In March 1973, 1974, and 1975 the Selective Service assigned draft priority numbers for all men born in 1954, 1955, and 1956, in case the draft was extended, but it never was
Interesting memories. I was a little kid during the Tet offensive. It was on tv. My father, a WW2 vet and an old Indo-China hand, commented on how well the journalists were covering it.
He shook his head, and brought up the topic of Den Bein Fu. He always said it would go no better for the Americans than it did for the French. He said this although he loved US servicemen - he said they saved everyone in Aust during WW2.
He lived long enough to see the Soviets invade Afghanistan, and of course he was easily able to predict that would be a disaster.
In Australia, the draft affected comparatively few people, yet the social impact was immense.
One still meets Vietnam vets. They often have that “look”. What a war ...
SoldierDad,
I just said a prayer thanking GOD for your sons safe return.
Which I figure is about 999,999,999 short of how many you offered up.
Your answer is about what I figure.
IMO, our troops should be brought home now. The Afghan government, the Taliban, and Al Queda should be placed on notice that if there are any further instances of terrorism that is traced to any group in Afghanistan the U.S. WILL NOT PLACE BOOTS ON THE GROUND, but will bomb the crap out of Afghanistan, and to hell with collateral damage.
I give thanks to you for your prayer. I wasn’t keeping track, but, yes, many times per day over the course of his deployment, beginning with his pre-deployment training, I offered prayers for his and his fellow soldier’s safety. I continue to offer prayers for those still deployed, and for the leaders who command them, and for this war to come to a conclusion so our soldiers can come home.
As to the draft, I forgot when it ended, but I remember very clearly the drawing in December 1969 when myself and millions of other draft age college students were assigned their numbers, in preparation for the end of deferments. I got a high number and the draft board skipped over me, but for the first time, millions of “safe” college students no longer felt safe. We were in the mix. I noticed a big difference in the antiwar demonstrations thereafter. Whereas before, the demonstrators were pretty much the more radical elements of the campus, by 1970 and 1971, the support was much broader, (I was at the University of Texas). Now who can say with any certainty why that was? I obviously have my opinion, which I have stated already. In fact that experience led me to the conclusion that we should not abandon the draft in favor of a volunteer armed forces, because I felt that if the general public were exempted from serving in our wars, then we would be more likely to get involved in them when we shouldn't, or stay in those future wars longer than we should. (My belief is that it should be politically costly to fight wars when the general population is not willing to fight in them.) By the way, most accounts indicate that Nixon came to the same conclusion, feeling that if he did away with the draft, the opposition to the war would drop.
One last comment about Cronkite. When LBJ was quoted as saying “If I lost Cronkite, I've lost middle America” I attributed that to LBJ's six sense politically. To me, Cronkite was a little slow intellectually, not as interesting as Huntley/Brinkley who I preferred, but he was the very archetype of the bedrock middle American. He was the embodiment of their values, their hopes and dreams and their reaction to the world. LBJ was right to look out of his bubble in D.C. and see what Cronkite made of what was going on. Because when he lost Cronkite after Tet, he had also lost much of middle America. But Cronkite was not the cause.
As to the reporting on the Tet offensive, how would you expect the media to report on such a massive attack? What was shocking at the time was that the communists were capable of launching a simultaneous attack against more than 100 cities and towns in Vietnam, and almost overrunning our embassy. That was what shocked us at the time, that they had the capability to launch such attacks. I suppose the media could have just reported, “There were some communist attacks in Vietnam yesterday, but they were quickly subdued.” But, really, that's not why we have a free press. They have an obligation to tell us what's going on, regardless. At least, I hope they feel that way.
Well, that's my take on what happened.
It’s too bad that all that accumulated wisdom such as your dad’s is not accessed by politicians worldwide. George Bush says he never asked his father’s advice on the wars in Iraq or Afghanistan. I think it would have been helpful.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.