Skip to comments.To Win Burbs, Romney May Pick 'Double-Vanilla' Veep
Posted on 04/19/2012 11:57:18 AM PDT by Kaslin
Some 20 million Americans in primaries and caucuses will take part in selecting the Republican presidential nominee. One person will choose the vice presidential nominee.
This has long struck me as absurd: One person choosing someone who, as a result, might become president for as long as 10 years. But just about everyone in politics says it's the only proper way.
Over the last 25 years, presidential nominees of both parties have engaged in conscientious consultation and have mostly made pretty good choices. No more picks at five o'clock in the morning to meet a convention deadline.
For even longer, every vice president has done constructive work of governance. Voters have come to expect a VP nominee who can contribute substance more than one who can balance a ticket.
Ticket-balancing suggestions have come in to Mitt Romney. He should endorse a fiery cultural conservative, some Republicans say, although he's not likely to name the undisciplined Rick Santorum.
He needs to name a Latino, say others. But the most obvious choice, the eloquent Sen. Marco Rubio, has reiterated his unwillingness to run. So has New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez.
The argument that Republicans need additional support from Latinos may be overstated. The 2010 exit poll shows Republicans won 38 percent of the Latino vote -- and that that was enough for a national majority, since they carried whites by a record 60 to 37 percent.
Anyway, ticket-balancing is not the only successful approach, as Bill Clinton understood. When he clinched the Democratic nomination in 1992 as a Southern moderate, it was widely assumed he would pick a Northern liberal, as Jimmy Carter had.
Instead, he chose a fellow Southern Baptist of his own generation with a reputation for moderation and congressional experience in national security issues, Al Gore. They were from adjoining Southern states, and when the ticket was announced they met on the bridge between West Memphis, Ark., and Memphis, Tenn.
This unbalanced ticket won two elections, carrying six of 14 Southern states in both 1992 and 1996. Democratic nominees from Massachusetts, both with Southern running mates, carried none in 1988 and 2004.
A similar approach for Mitt Romney would be what opponents might call a double-vanilla ticket, with another white male as vice presidential nominee.
Four possibilities come to mind. One is Paul Ryan, the House Budget Committee Chairman who endorsed Romney and campaigned with him all over Wisconsin. Romney has praised Ryan's budget proposals and has endorsed the fundamentals of Ryan's Medicare plan.
Ryan's in-depth knowledge of budget numbers surely appeals to Romney. The strongest argument against a Ryan nomination is that a President Romney would need him championing his budget and entitlement plans in the House.
Another possible choice is Sen. Rob Portman, who campaigned all over Ohio with Romney. Like Romney, Portman comes from a family with Midwestern manufacturing management experience.
But he's also served in the House and as special trade representative and budget director. And he's had experience in presidential campaigns: He played Democratic nominees in debate prep for Dick Cheney in 2000 and 2004 and John McCain in 2008.
Two governors should make any short list, Mitch Daniels of Indiana and Bob McDonnell of Virginia. Daniels also served as budget director for Bush and is a crusader for entitlement reform. McDonnell has ties to the military as a longtime reservist and as the father of a daughter who served in Iraq.
All four of these potential vanilla running mates take conservative stands on cultural issues but are careful to show respect for those who differ. All have emphasized economics in their campaigns and have run especially well in affluent suburbs, as Romney has in Republican primaries.
Ryan wins big every year in Waukesha County west of Milwaukee. Portman ran well enough in suburbs to carry Ohio's three biggest metro areas in 2010.
Daniels won a higher percentage in Indiana's most affluent area, Hamilton County, than Ronald Reagan did in 1984. And in 2009, McDonnell carried Washington's Northern Virginia suburbs, where he grew up, though they had voted heavily for Obama the year before.
A double-vanilla ticket will be attacked as un-diverse by the media. But if the nominees have rapport and energy, as Clinton and Gore did in 1992, who cares?
The Clinton-Gore ticket regained Southern ground for Democrats. A double-vanilla ticket might enable Republicans to regain ground in affluent suburbs this year.
I saw a 5 minute interview with a guy who was in the race for about 5 days...but I was favorably impressed.
Anyone have an opinion on Thaddeus McCotter? The Wikipedia entry shows him all over the map.
Will Comrade Obama dump foot-in-the-mouth Biden?
In his defense, his old district had a large part of Wayne County so he had to be.
the strategy appears to be smile, sit back, keep your noses clean and just wait for Team Obama to implode.
Ladies and Gentlemen, I present to you - Rob Portman.
Just pick a conservative.
Sounds like a good strategy
In which case, Biden had better watch out: Obama might eat him.
He will do something conventional. It’ll probably be a woman and likely a minority woman. I expect she’ll be more liberal than Romney.
I’m betting if Condi Rice was interested in the job he’d offer it to her in a heart beat.
When we look at how Mormons value woman and people of color we know who wont be a VP pick.
I first heard of him while watching Red Eye on Fox a few years back. McCotter is (or seems to be) an average Joe kind of guy with a wit so dry it would make Steven Wright seem like Sam Kinison, and I tossed a little support to him when he first announced his presidential run. And then he threw his support to Romney after he bailed leaving me with a sour taste. Make of that what you will.
He’s middle of the road with conservative tendencies. That’s the best way I can describe his political outlook. But being from Michigan, I guess has no choice and needs to be that way. Considering what could be in his seat, I don’t have tons to complain about. His voting record doesn’t reflect my stronger conservative views, but overall he is someone I wouldn’t mind seeing in the VP spot. (Doubt it will happen, though)
If he picks McDonnell, I will not only not vote for them, I will activel campaign against them. McDonnell is the worst governor I have seen in Virginia and Doug Wilder and Tim Kaine are both on the list.
Valerie Jarret? no Romney won’t pick her. First she is more liberal than Romney but she has a job, Obama’s handler.
Maybe a wise latina?
Will double vanilla beat the double choclate sprinkled with nut and broken cherries? I don’t know...
Maybe Romney will pick Jon Huntsman for the all-Mormon ticket.
C'mon Wolf... I know you don't like McDonnell and have read your contention about the light rail... but "worst" .. you're saying he's even worse than those two guys?
I like Barone, but come on..using “Biden” and “subtantial” in the same sentence...
I am sure that Romney would be happy and work well with just about any democrat.
Yeah, well it is personal with these toll projects. Kaine was worthless and got nothing accomplished. Wilder never reall did anything that personally affected me in this maner. Don’t fall for it. None of these tunnel/toll projects were ever intended to address congestion. At it’s core, this is an AUSTERITY MEASURE by VDOT on our backs. In the Midtown/Downtown Tunnel project, they’re forcing commuters to pay for their past financial mismanagement. When ERC (private company) assumes the maintenance & operation costs for the tunnels, VDOT will save millions a year in current maintenance costs, A BILLION in interest over the term of the plan, and many millions more in payroll and other operating costs. It will cost us $21 BILLION in tolls to make this happen, and they’ll keep charging us the same taxes, free to spend their savings on the Coalfields Expressway or anywhere else in the state, or even on another PPP giveaway.
Hillarys available.................................... That’s a guaranteed win for Romney! But it won’t happen. If he is looking for all around support, pick West and make it a good fight.
West would be a good choice for who and what he is, but not for being black because IMO he would not pick up one additional black vote.
Oh, I fear that, too... that would NOT surprise me at all!
Why not Newt? His baggage has been discussed at length. What else can they say about him?
Wisconsin Barone calls Ryan “double vanilla” in the Veepstakes ping
FReep Mail me if you want on, or off, this Wisconsin interest ping list.
Damn. That blouse looks like a rainbow on crack.
One person will choose the vice presidential nominee.
They still have to be voted on and nominated by the Delegates to the Convention.
the eloquent Sen. Marco Rubio, has reiterated his unwillingness to run. So has New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez.
Bull crap. As Larry Sabato said, they all say that. But, when offered, they accept in a heartbeat. When was the last time anyone on here knew of someone turning down the VP spot?
Out of the 4 “double-vanilla” possible VP picks (Ryan, Portman, Daniels and McDonnell, my first pick would be Ryan. My second pick would be Portman. I don’t see how the other two would be a big help to the Ticket; seriously.
Thaddeus McCotter is brilliant and has a “gift” of wit like Ronald Reagan. Not so sure he would “carry the day” so to speak. He’s very unknown. But, IF Thaddeus McCotter was the VP choice for the Ticket, I’D BE AS HAPPY AS BARNEY FRANK AT THE YMCA.
Ladies and Gentlemen, I present to you - Rob Portman.
Works for me. But, since you’re a Buckeye, tell us: Can Portman Deliver Ohio; seriously?
If Romney is smart, he will NOT go “double-vanilla” on his VP selection. If he is smart, he will choose...... a woman.....who is black.... with a Hispanic surname.... who is of the Jewish Faith.... but, her Mexican husband is a Catholic and ...... her Baptist son is married to an Oriental chick..... and her daughter is a lesbian.
Hell yeah; that’s the Ticket. Did I cover all the bases?
You left out a hill billy gay bob.
(But if he did run there, he surely would win big there...)
Don't mind you disagreeing because I have an answer for you. :>)They could for the GOP, but in my opinion, they wouldn't. Overwhelmingly they vote for Obama for two reasons: the first being that he's black and the second for the potential freebies, the freebies West would not promise.
My admiration for Rubio is unbounded, but he is not a native-born American citizen.
Whence the doctrine that an ill-defined demographic tagged “Latino,” a term also lacking definition, favors unrestricted migration of Mexicans into the U.S.A., legally or not, and are disinclined to vote for a candidate for POTUS that insists on only legal immigration?
Where did that notion come from?
“Anyone have an opinion on Thaddeus McCotter?”
Probably the most impressive unknown out there. I’ve heard him on John Batchelor for a couple of years. Impressive. Some may not like his sympathy for labor unions but he represents Michigan and those are his voters.
It’s been awhile since I’ve heard him but I recall him being ahead of the curve on the economic collapse; he understands the importance of having a strong manufacturing base; and he is concerned about potential military threats to the United States.
He seems to be a thinker and genuine enough in what he says, something all too uncommon in politicians.
McCotter of course can deliver the coveted Canine-American and Feline-American vote:
‘5. Proposed a tax break for pet owners.
McCotter asked fellow members of Congress to join him in supporting H. R. 3501, the Humanity and Pets Partnered Through the Years (HAPPY) Act. The bill proposes to allow pet owners a $3,500 annual tax deduction for “qualified pet-care expenses.”’
Mittwit needs someone ‘White and Delightsome’ to play the rear end of the ‘White Horse’.
Portman is VERY strong in Southwestern Ohio, as well as the suburbs. I would not go so far as to say that he would guarantee Ohio for the GOP, but if Obama wins Ohio with Portman on the ticket it would come after a lot of time, effort and money.
I think you've got that reversed. If Obama were on the GOP ticket, and championed GOP policies, he would get no more than 10% of the black vote. Clarence Thomas received black support because they figured a guy that dark couldn't possibly be all that conservative. Since then, they've regretted their decision and vilified him as a retard and a race traitor.
My pick is Ryan.
My pick is Ryan.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.