Skip to comments.Paralyzed Victim Sawyer Rosenstein Gets $4.2 Million (paralyzed by school bully's assault)
Posted on 04/19/2012 7:02:38 PM PDT by Clintonfatigued
A N.J. bully's punch to the abdomen left a middle school student paralyzed. Now the New Jersey school district that allowed this incident to happen has agreed to pay a $4.2 million to settle a lawsuit from the victim's family.
Sawyer Rosenstein complained to school officials about being repeatedly attacked by a known violent bully at the Eric Smith Middle School. The bully punched Rosenstein in the face a year earlier.
On Feb. 9, 2006, Rosenstein, then 12, emailed school officials asking for help.
Just three months later, he was punched in the abdomen at school on May 16, 2006. He complained of a pain in his back later that day at home.
Two days later his parents heard a scream from his bedroom.
"We picked him up and called an ambulance," the Rosenstein's father told The New Jersey Record. "He hasn't walked since."
(Excerpt) Read more at ibtimes.com ...
This poor kid suffered permanent confinement to a wheelchair by a bully he had complained about for several months. But school systems will suspend kids who defend themselves from bullying. Parents need to stop using these institutions. They’re destructive to the young people they’re alleged to benefit.
That is a very sad story. It is too bad that a major portion of that does not come from the parents of the bully - and that the bully has not been incarcerated a minimum of 10 years for assault.
Lawyers probably got half if not more.
My question is why are the taxpayers responsible for this?
How about making the school OFFICIALS and bully pay out of their own pockets?
Yes. Yes. Yes.
I just read this and forwarded to another article for more info. Seems the “bully” is being protected -no info on him/her.
And Florida will prosecute victims who defend themselves from their attackers.
does this story smell funny to anyone else?
What 12 year old writes email to the school saying he would like “coping mechanisms”
Then... he screams and falls down in his bedroom.... not on the schoolyard where he was suposedly injured
what kind of a an injusry causes parlysis 2 days later? (not saying it is not possible)
I may be cynical, but I bet we see this kid up and around spending his 4.5 mil
the schools are not complaining because this plays into the current “bullying” fad- for which we are going to certainly needs $billions of “funding” to solve...
I hope the amount was sufficient to keep the bully's family beating on the bully every day.
because beating him everyday will certainly make him a better, less bitter person. :p
What kind of person doesn't click the link and read the article to find out?
Once he went back to class, he had to see his attacker every day. The violent bully had only received a few days of suspension.
Incredible. And what does the state care? It's not like the $4.2M is coming out of their pockets.
Nope, perhaps it would not - maybe just once ~might~ make him a better person.
But, I would imagine that the lack of punishment and guidance for the years prior have made that kid a rotten person that will never become a better person.
I do think that suits like this might be a good thing though. If there are enough of them it could help kill public education.
of that I have no doubt
“My question is why are the taxpayers responsible for this?”
Taxpayers voted to have public schools and require their attendance. They then also hired those school officials, voted the spending measures, etc. So, taxpayers are just as guilty as it is their government that allowed this to happen.
Not to mention - what kid is going to spend from middle school through the rest of his teenage years in a wheelchair - from 12 years old to 19 - in the hopes of possible payoff.
Don't know what you're on, but you might consider putting it away - forever.
Actually, school districts carry insurance for stuff like this. It was the decision of the insurance company to settle, not the school district.
They should stop protecting bullies at this level and try them as adults.
I am sure the parents have been punished far more than equity would allow, but, why do parents make their kids go back to schools where they are being bullied?
I wouldn’t go to work if people were hitting me there.
Have the parents of the bully charged with maintaining a public nuisance.
Not asked, nor even referred to, is the question of whether this bullying was an act of “anti-semitism” (if Rosenstein is Jewish).
New Jersey has its share of anti-semites, esp. at Rutgers, Princeton and some smaller colleges.
It would be interesting if someone would do a follow-up on this story as to why Rosenstein was being bullied. Could be just a personality issue or something else.
a punch to the stomach made this guy paralized... and people think that Zimmerman wasn’t justified to shoot Trayvon?
It doesn’t really take that much to kill or permentally damage someone, as this article proves.
The schools do nothing about this problem. If you complain, they tell you that you are the problem. The teacher’s behaviour actually encourages the bullies to pick on the one kid.
I think the teachers get in a mind set that they are kids them selves. If I go to another school event and hear a teacher or band leader say “These kids are sooooo awsome...”
They seem to adopt the lingo and immaturity of the students they teach and sadly in the case of this poor student do not act like adults when they should.
The headmaster of this school should do five years in jail!
Beat his arse, you are darn right. Wallop him upside the head night and day. Reduce him to tears and don't stop until he is huddled up in the fetal position in the corner of the bathroom...Seriously, that is all bad kids like this understand. You need to beat it out of them.
the VAST majority of government agencies are self-insured
That’s gonna build up a lot of empathy!
Ramsey, NJ is a very affluent area.....maybe this happened at a private school. Most of the kids in the Mawah - Ramsey area attend private schools. Just saying.
Bad kids are not capable of learning empathy. They are bad and only understand a whooping. They must learn a conditioned reflex. Do bad get whooped, like a shock reflex. You must recognize there is sometimes only good or evil and no inbetween. The evil must be beat back.
Parents: There are schools soooooo horrific that it would be better for the child to NEVER attend!
Illiterate and innumerate is better than paralyzed.
Illiterate and innumerate can be fixed paralyzed or dead can't.
Society plays mind games with children. They are told that schools are the “real world”. They are told that learning how to deal with bullies is somehow helping them to deal with the “real world”.
Yet....In the real “real world”, adults would win MILLIONS from their employer if subjected to this abuse, and in the real “real world”, adults are free to seek employment elsewhere.
Then....Parents and other adults wonder why teens grow sullen, answer in monosylables, and give them that 20 degree off-centered stare. This is behavior seen in prisoners. And...People wonder why there is a generation gap? Why should teens trust parents and adults who subject them to this institutional abuse?
In another article I read, it said the insurance company settled over the objections of the school district. As with most news articles, that may or may not be true.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.