I am social and fiscal conservative. I bet a lot of people are. You can’t believe in social liberalism like sharing the wealth and cradle to grave welfare while being a fiscal conservative.
I would not vote for either of your hypothetical candidates. Of course neither will actually exist.
When push comes to shove, which hill would you fight to die on. The Social or Fiscal. Your examples are not social issues, they are fiscal issues. Social issues are abortion, gays, etc. Sharing the wealth and welfare are fiscal issues.