Skip to comments.Two Bexar County K-9s dead after night left inside hot cruiser
Posted on 07/27/2012 5:41:17 AM PDT by chessplayer
SAN ANTONIO -- The Bexar County Sheriff's Department says two of its K-9s have died after they were left inside a patrol vehicle overnight.
According to a statement from the Sheriff's Office, the dogs were "inadvertently" left inside the vehicle overnight and died from apparent heat exposure.
(Excerpt) Read more at kens5.com ...
The guy responsible for the dogs probably had been drinking or got into the evidence room or both...
No, He needs to be Arrested and Charged with 2nd Degree Murder of a Peace Officer, just like ANYONE ELSE WOULD BE if they KILLED A POLICE DOG regardless of the circumstances.
A couple badges need to be surrendered, along with their pensions.
So sad and so senseless. How stupid do you have to be to allow this to happen?
Those responsible need a Felony conviction and loss of gun “rights”.
According to the statement, Benoy is “completely devastated by the tragic accident.”
Devastated my butt. When something like this happens it shows the dogs owner actually doesn’t much care for the dog. Otherwise they wouldn’t “forget” about them.
Hopefully, his wife won’t allow him to transport their children anywhere in the summer.
Yup. Haven’t we been told all along that a police dog is an “officer” and the consequences for harming one are the same as harming a patrolman or trooper?
What consequence would result from an officer locking a partner in a cruiser in summer heat until he died? Manslaughter at least.
But, they’re cops. Killing dogs is in their DNA, apparently.
Gosh, sounds like involuntary manslaughter of a police officer to me. So...will the morons who left their PARTNERS in the car be fired, arrested and charged with their killings??
Time to prove that the cops are not above the law.
This criminal should die from lead poisoning.
On top of the obvious ethical problems, trained dogs cost the department $6000 apiece.
If the dogs had barked, one of the deputies might have at least shot them. /s
Seems like he considered the dogs as nothing more than a piece of equipment,,,like his badge or nightstick. And at the end, those poor dogs were probably calling out to their “friend” for help.
You have expressed your opinion. Allow me to express mine.
It's a dog. NOT a human. Therefore it is NOT murder. It is perhaps animal negligence, maybe even animal cruelty. But it is NOT murder.
Havent we been told all along that a police dog is an officer and the consequences for harming one are the same as harming a patrolman or trooper?
Hmm, never heard that put in quite the same language. I understand your particular feelings for the animals, and I appreciate the bond that forms between the officer and his dog. But that doesn't change the fact that this is a dog, not a human.
The definition of murder:
of a human
by another human
with malice aforethought.
I think it is dangerous to use terms that inflame or incite those in an attempt to manipulate the act and the punishment that may be meted out.
It is a shame when two valuable resources of law enforcement are lost. I am saddened when a expensive police helicopter is lost or damaged in a crash. But murder? IMHO, this is not a murder. It is a loss of a valuable resource, and should be addressed and punished appropriately.
Apparently no dog is safe from the police- not even their own....
When did you stop eating dogs?
Dogs and pets are at our mercy which deserves special attention for their safety.
Will the officer be brought up on murder charges for killing two fellow police officers?
“... he considered the dogs as nothing more than a piece of equipment”.
Makes me think what type of person would do this. The dogs were trained to protect him... give their life for him if necessary. Their death was nothing short of agony. IMHO, the cop should lose his job. If he was this irresponsible... why does he deserve a badge? The cop was given the opportunity to be a K9 officer and cost the taxpayers a lot of money (added to pain and suffering the dogs went through). Just my two cents...
Nope. Never have. And I do NOT support them. Battery maybe. But sorry, NOT murder. JMHO though.
You're opinion would probably impress most "pro-choice" people and make them happy to hear you utilize one of their memes.
Wow! Attack! It's OK, I expected it. Nope, not "pro-choice" at all. In fact, I am very much "pro-life". For PEOPLE!!! I don't anthropomorphise animals, or trains, or helicopters. OK, maybe a little bit with some machines, but never animals. Read my tagline.
The last time I checked a "police helicopter" doesn't learn, think, feel pain, breath, eat, drink.....etc. So you're equation of one "tool" to the other is most definitley your "opinion". But then again, those are the traits that pro-choice people like to say babies in the womb don't have either.
Hmm; Touche. But it (a helicopter) is a valuable resource, and incredibly fascinating to me. And infinitely more harder to replace from a financial standpoint. But a dog is a living being, I understand that. I just don't share your incredible defense of an animal. That's OK! We just have different opinions on what is important to us.
BTW, I have very specific ideas about people and especially babies in the womb, etc. I would defend their rights the same way I would (and do) defend any helpless HUMAN.
I know many people have strong feelings about dogs. (and cats, horses, chickens etc.) I do not wish or cause any undo harm or abuse to animals. I just don't share your feelings. That's OK too!
Aside from the dogs cruel deaths that is 20-30 thousand dollars flushed down the toilet by some idiot cop. It costs that much to buy and properly train these breeds
It’s a dog. NOT a human. Therefore it is NOT murder. It is perhaps animal negligence, maybe even animal cruelty.
PERHAPS negligence? Wow.
I find it incredulous that a department could afford 2 K-9’s yet couldn’t afford the automatic thermometer system that should should be installed in all K-9 cruisers. Our K-9 cruiser has it, it constantly monitors the temperature and if it gets too hot it sends an alarm to the police officer, if the officer doesn’t respond it pops the door.
Nonetheless, what a tragic unnecessary pair of deaths that are truly nothing short of murder, due to criminal negligence.
Thanks. I didn’t know K-9 cruisers could have those installed. And you are right. If a dept. can afford a K-9 unit, they should certainly been able to afford a thermometer. It would have saved these two dogs lives. It should be a requirement that all departments with K-9 units have those type of thermometers installed. Happy to hear your department has them.
Here is what those poor dogs went through.
“A matter of minutes, five or 10 minutes” is all it takes on a hot day for a dog to wind up organ-damaged or dead, Messonnier says.
“Here’s how it progresses: First, the dog pants hard, trying the only way it can to cool off. As the temperature rises and the dog realizes it’s in trouble, it becomes frantic, tries to get out, scratching at windows or digging at the seat or floor. It’s an awful moment, the dog’s moment of realization. “If you want to compare it to humans,” says Messonnier, “it would be this: The person is too hot, stifling, feeling trapped. But a person knows things can be done,” like smashing a window or blowing the horn for help. Dogs, of course, panic, since they can devise no strategies other than digging desperately. They often bloody themselves in this effort to survive. Some have heart attacks.”
“The panic doesn’t last long. Very quickly the dog goes prostrate, begins vomiting, having diarrhea and lapsing into unconsciousness. Organs are disintegrating. “All organs function properly within a certain temperature range, and when body temperature reaches a certain level, organ cells begin dying. There’s inflammation, white blood cells rush in a cascade of things happens in minutes,” he says. Liver, brain, kidneys are dying.”
“When you do an autopsy on a dog that died this way, the organs are soupy.”
Even if caught “in time,” the dog may have permanent kidney and liver damage. Hard to think of a more horrible way to die.
Unlike fetuses, dogs never become human. So the argument that dogs aren’t human and therefore shouldn’t be allotted the same level of legal protection stands to reason. Otherwise we risk abusing the rights of humans where crimes against animals occur.
That is how I see it also.
Well put. If anything, a trained dog handler should probably be held to an even higher standard than your average thug who kills a K9.
The average cop has 2 guns and 80 IQ points.
Otherwise we risk abusing the rights of humans where crimes against animals occur.
How would punishing a Michael Vick for what he did be an abuse of human rights?
Well, I hope those dogs are safe in Heaven, now. Yes, I’m one of those that believes God takes animals into Heaven.
As always the severity of the crime plays a role. The severity must be weighed against the worth of the one accused. If Vick as a human being was worth the same a any dog he may have executed, he would have surely been executed himself. As much as I despise Vick as a human being, that would have been a miscarriage of justice.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.