Skip to comments.Social Security: The Unsustainable Promise
Posted on 10/18/2013 9:41:16 AM PDT by Kaslin
I have written numerous times about pension problems in the US. Let's cross the Atlantic and take a peek at the setup in Spain, then let's compare the two setups.
Via translation from Libre Mercado, please consider The Chart That Will Shake Future Pensioners.
Workers vs. Pensioners
Given that eight million people age 65 and 16.7 million workers cannot sustain the current pension, imagine what will happen in the coming decades as the differential goes back even closer.
Pensions today promise Social Security payments of 100% of the average wage in the last 25 years for those with 37 years of Social Security contributions. Such payments are absolutely unsustainable. The relative income of pensioners relative to the average income of the society will sink (without massive tax looting of active workers).
Immigration could partially alleviate the problem, making the demographic transition somewhat smoother, but if new rights accrue to future pensions, immigration only delays the problem. In any case, it might be a good idea to allow free immigration to Spain in exchange for not accrue rights to Social Security.
The most important practical advice to draw from the above chart is simple: save and invest. If you trust your retirement to politicians, you will end up poor and feeling cheated.
Total Annual Cost of Social Security 1967-Present
Social Security Beneficiaries vs. Total Non-Farm Employment
Ratio of Workers to Social Security Beneficiaries
Social Security Benefits Analysis
The system is currently running a deficit. Trends say that deficit is going to worsen with each passing year unless benefits are cut and/or taxes are hiked.
The next chart is courtesy of Reader Tim Wallace in a January 11, post.
Social Security Burden on Non-Farm Workers
Social Security Cliff Reading
Tip of the Iceberg
Unfortunately, Social Security is just a tip of the unsustainable payout promises problem. Public union pensions are trillions of dollars underfunded and several cities in California have gone bankrupt over those promises.
Detroit went bankrupt for the same reason as did Central Falls, Rhode Island (see Central Falls Set to File Bankruptcy Exit Plan; 50% Pension Reductions, 40% Slash in Police and Fire Budgets Coming Up).
Vallejo Round Two
Vallejo, California went bankrupt about two years ago and is headed there again because it did not shed pension promises in bankruptcy: Vallejo, Mired in Pension Debt Again; Lesson for Stockton and Detroit - Shed Those Pension Obligations Now!
As I said in the above link, Stockton and Detroit have a choice. They can cut pensions now, or cut them later in a second bankruptcy, just like Vallejo will.
Pension Promises Not Sacrosanct
Yet people keep emailing me that pension are guaranteed by law. Tell that to residents of Central Falls. Their pensions were cut 50% in bankruptcy.
Here's reality: haircuts are coming. Unions need to negotiate benefit cuts now, in a sensible manner (with the highest beneficiaries taking the biggest cuts). The alternative is across the board benefit cuts à la Central Falls.
Meanwhile please consider the solid advice from Libre Mercado:
"The most important practical advice to draw from the above chart is simple: save and invest. If you trust your retirement to politicians [or promises], you will end up poor and feeling cheated."
I mean, nobody has actually spent that money already, right?
Ha, ha, the answer is to save and invest? So that politicians can inflate away the value of your savings and/or just confiscate it as they have done in other countries?
Somebody please come up with a better answer than that!
I hope to draw my last SS check the day I did, if it lasts that long. After that, I don’t really care. Selfish, ain’t it.
....last day I died......
Government - The Unsustainable Promise.
How come we never hear about Welfare running out of money?
What's interesting, the first group "worked for" their money...
the second........ didn't!!
I earned it, I deserve it, I sacrificed for this country, I WAS PROMISED, I payed into it, I worked hard,
It is all I have, I will starve, I paid so can you, the politicians stole it, it is mismanaged, cut the other spending first
Did I miss anything? Social Security is a social income transfer scheme designed to beholden the middle class to the Democraticm Party. Other wise known as welfare. It has been hugely successful just as Obamacare will be.
First, since you have so many wonderful numbers and charts there to tell the story, how about a few that actually tell the story, like:
- What percentage of people currently receiving a Social Security check (OF ANY TYPE) paid into the system for more than 20 years? What percentage of people currently receiving a Social Security check (OF ANY TYPE) never paid a penny into the system?
- What would happen to the ‘problem’ if the Social Security Disability rules of 1980 were put back into place?
- What would happen if we took the over eighty (80) Federal programs that welfare has been scattered into and totaled it? What would be the single biggest amount spent by the Federal Government? Would it be larger than Social Security and the Military spending combined?
- The good news is that for every day that thousands of baby boomers turn 65, hundreds die. That ratio will continue to evolve until on any give day more will die than will turn 65. And one day they will be gone altogether. Then, assuming there is a country remaining, the poor naive sheeple remaining will suddenly have the light come on and realize the problem has been right in front of them all along.
And NOBODY, not even the most far right politician, wants to talk about the real problem - we are going broke because millions of worthless cancers are happy to sit on their a$$ everyday and let the government pay them.
(And if any of the facts and figures I through out seem bogus, go to the website of a group called the Heritage.org and they will show you in black and white what the truth is.)
The reason Social Security isn't stopped is the payments going in from the young are still feeding the slush fund. In a few years the liars in government today will be talking about ObamaCare being an ‘entitlement’ and they'll try to force people to keep paying while dumping everyone except the most loyal democrat supporters.
Liberal la la land:
where gubmint pensions are a holy sacrosanct sacrament and marriages are no-fault divorces for Adam and Steve.
You did not pay into anything and there is no account with your name on it. What you paid for was the SS that went to your parents and grandparents. There was nothing put aside for you or anyone else.
Finally, if there were more than 2 workers for each recipient, the system would be better off.
Maybe if the Pres. and Congress would make this country economically viable again, that would also help the system.
We need to move to the Chilean model which seems to work very well and retirees get more money montly than SS here in the states. Newt was touting it in the 2012 campaign. Or private accounts that move with you from job to job.
There are lots of answers but if we do that the govt won’t be able to steal the money that we have all paid monthly for our whole lives. Right now all of that money gets sucked up by Uncle Sugar every month.
“save and invest”
Your response only takes into account the ‘save’ part of that. There are many investments (stocks, real estate, etc.) that do quite well in an inflationary environment, so do the saving so you have money to invest wisely.
But, but we were promised! Here is what SSA said about the system back in 1964!
From the SSA website (You have to hunt for it!)
“The program is designed so that contributions plus interest on the investments of the social security trust funds will be sufficient to meet all of the costs of benefits and administration, now and into the indefinite future—without any subsidy from the general funds of the Government.
Both the Congress and the Executive Branch, regardless of political party in power, have scrupulously provided in advance for full financing of all liberalizations in the program.”
And HERE is where YOUR MONEY went. Read and weep.
Yep. Bond investors won’t be the only ones to take “haircuts.” Those will be passed on to the consumers (pensioners).
I retired at 62 and regard at least part of my monthly SS check as a fee payable for democrat cowardice in abandoning those of us who were winning in Vietnam.
You silly person. Didn’t you get the note from sky guy that you’re supposed to give up on your money? I bet he has a vested interest in our giving up the money. To him.
Yet every year they sent an invoice to my house with my name on it detailing every year that I paid into it and telling me the amount. This year I reached my full retirement age and started taking the amount they say I earned. Since I feel no shame, I will not be returning it.
My husband did 2 tours in Vietnam and he volunteered for both of them
That was exactly what President Bush wanted, but he was ridiculed by the left and by some in here.
I believe that there is a great number of people drawing SS, disability, etc., that either paid in nothing at all or the bare minimum, (worked for a few hours per year for as little as 10 years). Therefore, the solution should be that we should either get rid of SS, or save it for the people who paid in their entire life: 30 or more years, full time. If people want disability, they can buy insurance.
I had a conversation with a 69 year old who believes that there is a savings account in her name that has been accumulating high rates of interest.
I will take mine in the form of American Gold Eagles and happily disappear into the Idaho wilderness. Who is John Galt?
“Save and invest” in assets that are expensive and difficult to confiscate.
Please give your husband a big “Welcome Home” hug.
I volunteered for Vietnam too, but for a single year. Though I remember a door gunner for the Blue Ghost CO (F Troop 8th Air Cavalry). He wanted the war to go on forever. He loved his flying gig that much.
‘Wonder whatever became of him.
Invest in goods, not politician’s promises.
Buy a house: Rent it, the asset will make you money, and hold most of its value.
Buy stock: As the money inflates, the value in dollars will increase.
Buy Gold: As the money inflates, the value in dollars will increase.
Buy farmland: Rent it, the asset will make you money and hold most of its value.
Diversify: Politicians are unlikely to break all their promises at once. As they move up on breaking one or the other, you can decrease your holdings in one type of asset and increase your holdings in another.
SS is to some extent an insurance program.
My cousin gets payments. She is disabled, and was covered by it for that reason. She is in an assisted living situation, and has been since she was about 30.
Part of the problem is the government doesn’t invest the money wisely. Example: All the bureaucrats in the Department of Agriculture don’t increase productivity by a penny.
get all you get. before the well runs dry.
It really is sad, and tragic for our nation.
Free Republic, and American, "ain't what it used to be." The only real threads that inspire me these days are the ones about Jesus Christ.
There are many Freepers who believe in Him, and we are discovering that the world is growing darker, just as He predicted.
I remember when the threads were full of the American spirit, and of hope.
Today, the threads are full of anger that goes off in a direction that is completely irrational or on a cause that is completely un-winnable politically.
I was in the military 21 years, but I never was an advocate of suicide missions unless the cause itself could be advanced, and I still am not. Today, we have Freepers who advocated (and went on) missions to cut our own belly, and then they rail against those who watched us do it.
There are too many Freepers who are living themselves in poverty or near poverty, and nobody listens.
There are too many Freepers who want "their" government program, but will scream at other spending - NOT because it is bad for the country, but because they see it as threatening their spending.
Now, I can apply that standard to myself (and I must if I am to remain honest before Christ), but here is the difference. I ACKNOWLEDGE and I say here, that my military pension is on the table towards Cola reform or other solutions (in the spirit of Simpson-Bowles) towards solving our fiscal death spiral.
I have found that 99.9% of Freepers, sadly, never, ever say the same thing about their Social Security, Medicare, or whatever else.
I DO distinguish between earned and unearned Entitlements. Earned are Social Security, Medicare, Govt pensions, and military pensions. They contributed and earned them.
Unearned are SS Disability (which is helping to bankrupting the SS system), TANF welfare, EBT Food Stamps, Unemployment (sorry, it is unearned after a few weeks), Section 8 housing, and these:
Universal Program for Subsidized Phones for Low Income (ObamaPhones), Medicaid, Unemployment Asistance, EITC, Foster Care Title IV, Old Age Assistance, AFDC, General Assistance Cash, Assets for Independence, General Assistance to Native Americans, SCHiP State Supplemental Health Insurance Program, Consolidated Health Centers, Consolidated Community Health, Maternal and Child Health Assistance Fund, Healthy Start, School Lunch, Job Assistance, Job Training, Minority Job Assistance, Job Relocation, Woman Infants and Children's Program, Nutrition for the Elderly, Summer Program, Summer Jobs Program, Minority Summer Jobs, Hispanic Jobs Program, African-American Jobs Program, Commodity Supplemental Food Program, Special Milk Program, Needy Families, Farmer's Market Nutrition Program, Public Housing, Low Income Energy Assistance, Migrant Education, Title One Grants to Local Education Authorities, Education for Homeless Children and Youth, Even Start, Job Corps, Social Security Disability, Social Security for Refugees, Social Security for Humanitarian Cases, Social Security for Asylum, Health Marriage and Responsible Fatherhood Grants, TANF Child Care, Empowerment Zones for Minority Communities, Urban Development Action Grants, and Family Planning (abortion).
Freepers better wake up. It is all coming down, and soon.
Your only hope is Christ.
Amen to that.
Oh by the way, when I was in my 20's, 30's and 40's I was also fighting against SS. I have other assets and have prepared (prepped) for my family. If the well runs dry it is a good thing I live by the lake.
We’ll just devalue the currency by 50% while giving them a 25% increase over 10 years, and we’ll have solved that problem...
Well, not so fast. As part of that deal Reagan and Tip O’neil implemented to “save” social security, the congress critters raised the social securtiy taxes so that the baby boomers could be covered when they reached retirement age.
So for years, an excess was paid into social security and non-negotiable government bonds were purchased as an investment. It’s part of the national debt.
True there’s no specific account with your name on it, but still it did not all go to support granny and the parents, some was put aside for the future retirement problem posed by the boomers.
As far as pensions in general, lots of people in banking found out during the Clinton era financial closings/crisis, that when your company goes bankrupt, your pension is all gone too. Company benefits are not guaranteed-the bond holders come first.
However, if you are a union workers such as the UAW, you might have a president step in and ignore the law, and save your pension to the detriment of the bond holders(which impacts other people’s pensions, since lots of those bonds were held by pension funds other than UAW).
Even if there’s no “cut” in benefits, the government is making sure that the purchasing power of social security will be reduced to the point where it will just be a spit in the “basket” compared to what that basket used to hold since helicopter Ben started printing money hand over fist.
Worse than a 25% haircut for sure.
Government confiscates hundreds of thousands from people's incomes over their employment histories and you suggest they should just roll over and forget about it?
Tell ya what Mr. pilot, I actually wish government would tell everyone tomorrow they're no longer going to get any of the money back which was confiscated from them by threat of imprisonment and death.
What a sight that would be..
like the boomers haven't shelled out enough money and enough years already......WE are not posing any problems....the problems were heaped upon us...
instead of reducing payments to seniors by just a tiny amount back in the early 80's, instead the workers got to pay more and more, including ever increasing medicare taxes, AND told that they had to work even longer....BS...
SS started out miniscule...then it changed to be a huge bite out or our paychecks....wasn't it like 0.5% when it started?...and now its just under 8%...
which all means is that there are people collecting now that paid hardly anything....not to mention the billions thrown out to "disabled" people with the bad knees.....etc....not to mention the new immigrants who just happend to have lost their BC but swear they are over age 62...I know this happens...
multiply that my millions....there you are...
and disability....I work in a hospital and the number of younger people....younger than me for sure....on "disability" is astounding....it stinks.....everyone not in a wheelchair or blind or with some calamtous injury should be required to do some kind of work....
Govt pensions, and military pensions. They contributed and earned them.
So the cop who retires at 50 years old and collecting $80,000++ per year in tax paid government pensions on top of those gold plated government medical benefits are perfectly legitimate?
I hear you. I am a baby boomer too. I don’t remember what the % contribution rate was. I do seem to recall that 16 workers support 1 retired person. Now it’s like 3 people supporting a retired person.
Boomers are given a bad rap, like we were all a bunch of raving idiot liberal hippie type pot heads. Tain’t true at all. Out here in fly over country plenty of conservative, bitter clingers.
The rates were raised, and I don’t remember hearing a single person gripe about it. We knew that granny and our parents were dependent on it.
I know I have done all I could to help my kids and my parents, and be able to stay self supporting. I don’t want my kids to have to send more than half their paycheck to the government-that’s for sure.
I know a cop who retired at 25 years and collects a State pension, who will eventually collect a Federal pension. I wish I had that but I will not.
Let me ask you though...are the .0000046778 % in this country who fall into that category causing our fiscal collapse, or is it Medicare, Social Security, Disability, and Medicaid? I can show you a chart.
I’ll start getting my SS checks very shortly (God willing) and I am looking forward to that! I’ll use that money for my boat payments, casino trips, and vacations. I will, however, be quite willing to forego those checks for the good of the nation and our grandchildren...
...AFTER you cut off the Democrat party’s base of moochers, bums, deadbeats, and parasites from welfare, food stamps, WIC, “free” school breakfasts and lunches, Section 8 housing, Obamaphones, Medicaid, SSDI “crazy checks”, government services for illegal aliens, etc.
THEN talk to me about trimming back benefits for us seniors who dumped their hard-earned money down the government toilet their entire working lives.
Until then, everybody can STFU.
Excellent post. I’m with you 100%.
it's the double whammy....
in my husbands family, we support his father, his mother, his brother, his sil, his sister and her husband who are both "disabled"(thru a shyster lawyer of course)and at least one deceased nephews child until he is 18....the rule about how many people are working to support just one SS recipient shows insanity...and in my husbands family alone the two of us working while the rest are collecting is INSANE...
Taxes are taxes...we Can discuss that.
Unearned are SS Disability (which is helping to bankrupting the SS system), TANF welfare, EBT Food Stamps, Unemployment (sorry, it is unearned after a few weeks), Section 8 housing, and these:
There you go! You have nicely listed the priority in which government needs to trim back spending. Once the "unearned" (welfare) crap is trimmed to the bone, THEN let's talk about reforming the "earned" stuff.
Are you kidding? You know who the biggest employer in America now is?
It’s governemnt...Government pensions at all levels are literately economically gang banging the American private sector.
This is no secret.
Elect a White House and Senate, then convince the American public (who every day turn more away from God) and then.........magic. We will have what you want.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.