Posted on 04/05/2002 8:01:29 AM PST by Tai_Chung
RALEIGH - A Superior Court judge ripped state leaders Thursday and ordered them to take definitive steps to ensure every child gets an adequate public school education.
N.C. leaders must put a certified teacher in every classroom, respond more quickly and emphatically to failing schools, and ensure that every child has the resources to perform at least at grade level, Wake County Judge Howard Manning wrote. Such steps are necessary for the state to meet its constitutional mandate to give every child a "sound basic education," he said in his final ruling in the landmark Leandro school-funding lawsuit.
Most of all, the 112-page ruling chastises state officials for failing at-risk children and calls on them to provide firm, politically brave leadership.
State leaders cannot, he wrote, rely on county and city school systems to meet the Constitution's mandate.
Manning ordered the state to update him every 90 days.
"The State must step in with an iron hand and get the mess straight," he wrote. "If it takes removing an ineffective Superintendent, principal, teacher or group of teachers and putting effective, competent ones in their place, so be it."
Gov. Mike Easley and N.C. leaders may appeal. On Thursday evening, they were busy trying to figure out just what the ruling meant.
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Mike Ward said he believed the N.C. Board of Education is "in sync" with Manning when it comes to helping students who are at-risk -- a term Manning doesn't define, though he says it has as much to do with preparation as with wealth and background. But Ward worried about Manning's suggestion that the state play a more active role in the day-to-day operation of school systems to ensure equity in all 117 school districts.
"That potentially could upend the structure of how we govern schools in North Carolina," Ward said. "Traditionally, local systems hire superintendents, hire principals and hire teachers."
Nora Carr, spokeswoman for Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools, said the district has devoted considerable attention to at-risk students, and district leaders agree more should be done.
But considering the state's woeful budget situation, she's not sure how state officials will accomplish that.
"Where is the money going to come from?" she asked. "... How you can accomplish this without additional dollars isn't clear."
Manning didn't order the state to spend more. Instead, he made seemingly expensive suggestions -- smaller classes, individual tutorials, more remedial classes -- and left it up to the state to decide how to respond.
"Really, what the judge did was make it clear that the state can't pass the buck," said Bob Spearman, lawyer for the five rural school districts that originally sued the state in 1994. "The state is going to have to accept responsibility, somehow."
The rural districts -- Cumberland, Halifax, Hoke, Robeson and Vance counties -- argued the state's system of doling out education money based on population unfairly penalized their children and prevented them from competing. The lawsuit is called Leandro after the name of one of the plaintiffs.
A collection of urban systems, including Charlotte-Mecklenburg, later joined the suit. The bigger, wealthier districts contended that because of their size and diverse population, including a higher percentage of at-risk and students with disabilities, they, too, were shortchanged under the state funding formula.
As part of the case, the N.C. Supreme Court ruled in 1997 that North Carolina's Constitution guarantees each child a "sound basic education." The courts have broadly defined that as an education that ensures high school graduates can compete for jobs or admission to college or vocational schools.
Manning has made four rulings in the lawsuit.
First, he said the state's system of funding schools was constitutional, though not necessarily adequate. Then he ordered lawmakers to enact a prekindergarten program for all at-risk students. In March 2001, he gave the state and local districts a year to reroute existing money to help at-risk kids, and noted they have begun to do so.
In Thursday's ruling, Manning ordered the state to take whatever action is necessary to ensure every child is well-educated.
He said every classroom should have a certified teacher, essentially someone with an education degree and trained in the subject area. That's been a goal among state administrators for years, but one that has proved difficult in a time of teacher shortages.
Nearly 15 percent of the state's 86,000 teachers, and 60 percent of new teachers, had some form of temporary, provisional or emergency license last school year.
Manning also demanded that state leaders raise their standards.
State lawyers had argued that students who achieved what's considered "below grade level," or just above failing, were being given a "sound, basic education." Manning rejected that, saying a grade-level achievement should be the goal for every child.
He said the ABC program, which rewards schools and teachers for improvement and sends high-quality administrative teams to faltering schools, shows the state's failures and gives it a way to assess future progress.
This year, 12 high schools have state-mandated assistance teams. The assessment teams, which are led by current teachers and former and current principals, can recommend removing a teacher, a principal or even school system superintendents in places where students perform poorly on end-of-year tests.
"The state cannot escape or deny the importance of the ABC system as proof of the failure of thousands of students to obtain a sound basic education by failing to perform at or above grade level all the way through high school," Manning wrote.
"... What has been going on in Leandro is a shell game between the (local districts) and the State of North Carolina as to which governmental unit is at fault when the fact remains, they both are at fault."
To read Manning's entire ruling, go to www.charlotte.com/multimedia/charlotte/judgedoc.pdf
Oxymoron.
Yesterday he predicted the following programs will be implemented "for the children" in an effort to properly educate them...
Get a Clue at 2
Learning is Fun at 1
and, Be a winner in the womb
Honestly, how long before that is a reality? He had one for age 3, but I cant remember it.
NCHS's beware!!!
But... but... I thought our former Guv, Jim Hunt, had already made our schools perfect?!? You mean he didn't?
>/sarcasm<
Hunt lied!
All this means is that the Creeps will want to tax us at 90% instead of their current tax rate to justify meeting the Judge's demands.
No way will he run again.
He's now a member (Partner) with the prestigious NC law firm of Womble Carlyle Sandridge & Rice, PLLC.
Hunt is probably making too much to go back to a gummint job.
Was that during the presidential debates when Gore lied about Hunt shutting down failing public schools? I still have this link about it from October,2000:
Unfortnately, they'll probably use this as justification for another tax hike. I'm also not happy about the possibilty of more consolidation of power at the state level rather than the local community. They've already held back funds that were supposed to be distributed back to counties due to the "budget shortfall". I really don't think they've proven to be more responsible than local communities at budgeting or education.
What a crock.
I'm sure they'll find funding for their "sexual agenda" programs though.
MKM
Wasn't Hunt under consideration for Education Czar in the newly elected Dubya administration?
Close call...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.