Skip to comments.
Ohio Concealed Weapons Ban Unconstitutional
Hamilton County Court of Appeals ^
| Hamilton Cty. Ct. of Appeals
Posted on 04/10/2002 8:26:53 AM PDT by Kaisersrsic
The Ohio Court of Appeals has affirmed the decision in Klein v. Simon -- finding that Ohio's ban on concealed carry violates the Ohio Constitution.
TOPICS: Extended News; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: banglist; concealed; guns; ohio
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-50, 51-66 next last
Congratulations to the folks who worked on this! Those of us who have been watching appreciate your efforts. If my link to the decision does not work, help please.
To: Kaisersrsic; *bang_list
To: AnnaZ; HangFire; Lady Jenn; Kithlyara; AZ Spartacus; feinswinesuksass; abigail2...
posted on 04/10/2002 8:32:19 AM PDT
The Court says: "We are not England, where hunting was once the preserve of the landed rich, we are America, where the Pilgrams shot their Thanksgiving turkeys." That makes it sound like this was the right three judge panel to hear this case!
posted on 04/10/2002 8:35:51 AM PDT
Congrats to all of you Buckeyes.
I especially like the part in the decision where it states "We are not a country where power is maintained by people with guns over people without guns."
posted on 04/10/2002 8:35:58 AM PDT
Eat your hearts out, gun grabbers.....
posted on 04/10/2002 8:37:32 AM PDT
This is great news for Ohio. We are working hard here in Minnesota for shall issue CCW, it's a long tough fight.
Congratulations and good work Ohio.
posted on 04/10/2002 8:40:16 AM PDT
A common sense and historically proven way to keep those dangerous and destructive GUNS out of YOUR life.
MEMBERSHIPS AVAILABLE NOW!
Concerned about the easy availability of guns in our society?
Alarmed about the "gun nuts" and other freedom wackos the government allows to run loose?
Wish the government would just repeal the Second Amendment and confiscate all the guns because you believe sensible people shouldn't suffer because of some idiotic notion about some antiquated right?
While we can't take the guns away from the people, we CAN take the people (or at least SOME of them) away from their guns.
At CAMP GUNFREE, we have created an atmosphere of near-total tranquility where you and your family will experience the benefits of a GUN FREE environment.
The unique main gate at Camp GunFree. Most arriving camp guests never see this view from their comfortable rail cars.
Each of our camps is a gated community designed to keep guns away from camp guests. Firmly enforced security measures ensure that these dangerous and destructive devices are kept outside. Each camp boasts 24 hour, 7 day a week sentries and state-of-the-art enclosure systems, guard dogs, trenches and surveillance equipment to absolutely GUARANTEE that no firearms enter the facility. Rigidly controlled access ensures that no guns can ever be smuggled in.
No cost has been spared to ensure that Camp GunFree remains gun free.
All camp members are given distinctive uniforms to distinguish them from any gun-toting barbarians who might attempt to evade our security measures. Each camp member is also assigned a distinctive ID number to ensure that only the right people are allowed within the camp.
Room and board are provided to each member in exchange for rewarding tasks designed to provide a sense of accomplishment and to demonstrate that large numbers of people CAN exist in a gun violence free community.
Camp members engaged in one of our many fun-filled organized work activities.
The current headlines prompt us to remind you that there has NEVER been a shooting by a student in any of the camp schools and we can GUARANTEE that there never will be!!
For more information, call 1-800-GUNFREE
OR visit our new website at
(This idea from a pamphlet originally created by The Minnesota Center for Individual Liberty, PO Box 32170, Minneapolis, MN 55432-0170)
posted on 04/10/2002 8:44:52 AM PDT
A great day for the great State of Ohio!
In case you missed the posting on the Local Board:
next MN chapter meeting:
Roseville Perkins - Just South of 36 on Snelling
April 20th - About 9:30 AM
Hope to see you there!
To: Kaisersrsic ; Deadeye Division
There is only on effective way to get a Vermont law passed....through the courts. Since if the laws are struck down, there is no CCW law.
Now, does Ohio have a premption law that says all gun control laws have to be from the state and not localities? If not, get that passed pronto. It is saving us in Michigan.
BTW = KUDOS to the Second Amendment Foundation.
They are ones behind this.
To: Dick Bachert
I'm going to steal it to give to a couple of teachers I know.
To: LasVegasDave; Conspiratoristo; pontiac;
2A Buckeye Bump.
Yes, its now binding throughout the state, not just in the county it was originally in effect. Ohio is now an "open carry" state. Congratulations to everyone for their hard work on this. It must be a glum day for Sarah Brady and the gun banners. Bwahahaha!!!
To: lowbridge; Kaisersrsic; Sir Gawain
HIP HIP HOORAY!
Thanks for the ping, Lowbridge! This is absolutely wonderful.
posted on 04/10/2002 9:03:38 AM PDT
To: Dan from Michigan
That's right Dan. SAF is doing a lot of heavy lifting for us.
Anybody wondering how they can support our Second Ammendment rights can get in touch with the Second Ammendment Foundation saf.org is thier website and they are behind the Emerson cas as well.
To: Joe Brower
One for the good guys. Hamilton County, Ohio, seems to have just become Vermont-Style concealed carry free.
posted on 04/10/2002 9:04:59 AM PDT
Awright! Now, can someone explain what this really means in a legal & practical manner, especially for non-residents?
"finding that Ohio's ban on concealed carry violates the Ohio Constitution"
What does Ohios constitution say about it? How does Ohios version of the 2nd read?
Now let's get a few states to amend their constitutions to reflect the wordage found in Ohio's ... and push the gun grabbers even further back toward total irrelevance.
posted on 04/10/2002 9:11:18 AM PDT
Cincinnati radio (WLW) is reporting that the ban on concealed carry has been lifted in Hamilton County (pending likely appeals). How does the court's ruling affect the rest of the state? Just curious if you know?
I'll bump that!
ohio isn't an open carry state - this only applies to one county, where, if the injunction is lifted, concealed carry is now legal, without a permit (a-la vermont style concealed carry)
posted on 04/10/2002 9:17:10 AM PDT
Sarah Brady comments: GAKKK!!!!!
Judge Ruehlman's ruling applied only to Hamilton County --- that is to the environs of Cincinnati and surrounding communities in the county. The Ohio Appeals Court which granted the previous stay of the ruling has now lifted it AND affirmed the trial court's ruling and now the decision is binding statewide, not just in Hamilton County. This means Ohio citizens can openly carry firearms on their persons without fear of arrest, indictment, prosecution, and conviction. Today is truly a day a blow has been struck FOR the Constitution of Ohio AND the Second Amendment. Ohio now joins the ranks of states in which its possible to carry weapons without having to rely on the county sheriff or police chief to grant that precious permit. In a free society people should have the right to protect their persons and their homes. The Ohio Appeals Court affirmed this fundamental right. Now the politicians of Ohio including Governor Robert Taft, have to decide whether to obey the Constitution or submit to the likes of Sarah Brady and Josh Sugarman.
I think the Stat Appeals Court decision extended the ruling throughout the state. Whether the State Legislature decides to adopt a shall issue concealed carry permit law remains to be seen. However whether they do or do not act, the fact remains Ohioans can now carry guns on their persons without a permit, whether openly or concealed. And yes we can expect the gun banners to come forth with a barrage of hysterical propaganda about how all this will turn Ohio into a shooting gallery. It hasn't happened in any of the other 34 states in which you can be issued a permit or in Vermont where none has ever been needed.
To: goldstategop; Cyber Liberty
I'll bump this again. This is exciting!
posted on 04/10/2002 9:24:15 AM PDT
Hey, you in "Hog Heaven" yet?
No, no, no - concealed carry is now legal, open cary is not. Go read the decision.
And I do not know Ohio law well enough to be certain, but most appelate court decisions are binding only in the court's district.
That would mean that concealed carry is only legal in hamilton county.
posted on 04/10/2002 9:29:03 AM PDT
The Ohio Constitution, Section 4, Article I, states, The people have the right to bear arms for their defense and security * * *.
Thanks, right after you posted that I found the full version of that article...
§ 1.04 Bearing arms; standing armies; military powers (1851)
The people have the right to bear arms for their defense and security; but standing armies, in time of peace, are dangerous to liberty, and shall not be kept up; and the military shall be in strict subordination to the civil power.
To: Dick Bachert
Your #10 is outstanding. I've never seen it before. Thanks much.
Good job, Buckeyes. Though an Army Brat and a Southerner by long-time residence, Dad was from Toledo and played for Woody at OSU, so I have a warm place in my heart for Ohio. Glad to see something positive happening there.
Echoing an earlier request, can anyone comment knowledgeably about what this means for visitors to the state? I currently have CCW reciprocity in all the states I'm in at all frequently; it would be nice if Ohio were added to the list, as I do go there from time to time.
and now the decision is binding statewide, not just in Hamilton Count
I hope you're right. It would make logical sense that a State appeals court ruling on the constitutionality of a State law would automatically apply statewide, but since when do logic and the law have to co-exist ? The afternoon drivetime talk shows in Cleveland will be full of nothing but this and the Indian's win streak.
posted on 04/10/2002 9:34:47 AM PDT
Yes, it's only legal in hamilton county. What remains to be seen is whether the county will appeal this to the state supreme court, risking state wide non-permit concealed carry, or leave hamilton as an isolated island where cc is legal.
posted on 04/10/2002 9:35:14 AM PDT
I read on another thread we(Buckeye here) are still required to jump thru hoops for our CCW.....but we are allowed to carry in plain sight now? At least until the legislature screws us again?
posted on 04/10/2002 9:35:53 AM PDT
How can a state appeals court ruling concerning a state law be binding in only one county? What you say doesn't make sense. Doesn't an appeals court speak for the status of law in the ENTIRE state?
Ohio is now an "open carry" state.
This is true since the court lifted its stay.
I urge all Ohioans to now carry a concealed weapon. Do so whether you feel the "need" to or not. This next part is important: Keep a diary of your activities. Entries in your log should be along the lines of "Carried a concealed weapon today; did not shoot anyone." There will come a time when the antis will allege that concealed carry will cause blood to run in the streets. You have the chance now to document a period in Ohio's history when no concealed carry law existed, yet no such carnage occured. Ohio could still get stuck with a concealed carry law in the future. By carrying concealed now and documenting the lack of violence, you will help the legislators who will argue against restictive language in any such future statute.
The best case scenario is that the General Assembly leaves the issue alone; a Vermont-style law. By documenting a high rate of concealed carry without a corresponding increase in violence, "shall issue" could be the "worst case" scenario. Failing to document a lack of violence during this period could get you stuck with a California style discretionary system. (If you're not a movie star or a big donor, you can forget the permit!)
START PACKIN' NOW!!
posted on 04/10/2002 9:38:37 AM PDT
Yes, I think so. I think people can even carry outside Hamilton County. Let the cops seriously attempt to enforce an UNCONSTITUTONAL law. And why would the sight of law abiding armed citizens disturb rank and file cops? I betcha most will soon get used to their presence. Ohio will be a lot safer now that criminals know they don't have a defenseless sheeple to plunder any more.
FINALLY ! A state upholding its OWN Constitution. They are some of the worst at ignoring them.
I think you are confusing Federal court districts vs a state appeals court. I assume this means that concealed carry cannot be prosecuted under the discarded law while open carry is still prohibited under a previous law they seemed to refer to in their decision. And it is state wide.
I imagine the outcome will be a shall issue law assuming the Supreme Court hears it and goes along. Seeing as how the appeals court effectively *itch slapped the city of Cincinnati, I would be surprised if the Supreme court reversed it.
Praise the Lord and pass the ammunition!
posted on 04/10/2002 9:48:30 AM PDT
posted on 04/10/2002 9:50:51 AM PDT
posted on 04/10/2002 9:52:30 AM PDT
posted on 04/10/2002 9:55:00 AM PDT
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-50, 51-66 next last
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson