Posted on 07/25/2002 1:37:28 AM PDT by Jeff Head
Alright, I finally got around to forking over the thirteen bucks for the First Volume.
I am reading it on my spare time and am already over two hundred pages in. This thing is a real page-turner, Jeff, no doubt about it.
Honestly, I only have one editorial criticism to offer so far (aside from the occasional type-setting misprint, like the part on page 96 where President Weisskopf tells the PLA ambassador that the Red Chinese SHOULD plan to obstruct the South China Sea? Maybe you mean that President Weisskopf tells the PLA ambassador that the Red Chinese SHOULD NOT plan to obstruct the South China Sea? A few other minor details, etc.).
My one editorial criticism is gonna sound "politically correct", but it's my genuine opinion. Your plot-writing is excellent. Like I said, a real page-turner. Your character-writing is *slightly* weak, IMHO. Particularly, the Black American characters from Chicago who are making their way to Self-Reliant Conservativism... ummm... how can I put this...
In fairness, Jeff, you are a White Man from the Midwest/Great West, and so am I. I like the way that you are highlighting the degradation of the Black Nuclear Family caused by the welfare state, and the sorry degradation of English Literacy among Urban Black Ebonics... but your Black Characters -- Leon, Alan, and Geneva -- though they are entirely likeable and sympathetic characters, their dialogue doesn't sound like Urban Black Ebonics. They sound like Amos-and-Andy StepandFetchits.
They really do. Honestly. It doesn't sound "real". Me, I don't have a clue how to talk "US Marine"; and by the same token, that dialogue does not really sound "Urban American Black". In my Rural American white-bread opinion, anyway.
And since I know for a fact that you don't have a racist bone in your body, I think that you will understand if I say that the LAST thing you want -- if you really want to take this sucker to National Print -- is for race-baiter Liberals to accuse you of "patronizing black people". It would NOT be fair to your Book, but you KNOW that they would try it if they could get away with it. Anything to paint you as a "racist" and thereby discount your Political Statements.
I think that you need to let a real Urban Black Conservative read and re-write the Story Dialogue offered by Leon, Alan, and Geneva, so it does not sound "contrived". I'd recommend an editorial review by either rdb3 from Ohio or Trueblackman from Baltimore.
And heck -- they may tell me I am totally off-base and your character writing is 100% spot-on... but y'know, it could not hurt.
Other than that, I am completely absorbed. Great little book.
Actually I was raised in Texas and went to school and played football with a group of black guys whom I became close friends with. My "eubonics" is dated by those experiences in the early to mid-70's ... but for that time, based on my experiences in North Central Texas ... I feel they are as accurate as I could make them given one major issue.
The one thing I know is wrong is the use of a number of very extrem profanities that I am not including in any case (both here and in several other instances) which any editor or major publisher will have to work around anyay. I will not move on that particular point.
Volume II is out and I believe you will find it even better done, addressing some of your concerns from Volume I. I am a self admitted novice and am trying to learn as I go, while still providing a compelling message into which are couched critical messages.
Best FRegards.
I look forward to your thoughts and comments on it as always.
God's best to you and yours up North. I have been down in Texas again working but am headed home tomorrow.
Aha!! I knew your black characters sounded more "Jeffersons" than "Dr. Dre".
The one thing I know is wrong is the use of a number of very extrem profanities that I am not including in any case (both here and in several other instances) which any editor or major publisher will have to work around anyay. I will not move on that particular point.
I'm totally in agreement with you here. You're under no obligation to write your own book under an NC-17 rating. If a reader thinks that the "street" characters should use more harsh language, they will just have to "imagine around" the written dialogue in their own minds. No biggie.
But, that is the reality of what we may face and I believe it needs to be told ... short of totally explicit material of course
Best regards.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.