Skip to comments.A dark week for democracy (Euro-snot alert)
Posted on 11/09/2002 5:54:54 PM PST by Pokey78
The stranglehold the far Right has now taken on America will make it a more divided, reactionary and illiberal country
The election in Georgia said it all. The Democrat governor, Roy Barnes, had dared to remove the Confederate symbol from the state flag last year. His Republican challenger wanted to bring it back, to honour, he said, 300,000 Confederate 'veterans'. A Republican has not occupied Georgia's governor's mansion since 1872. After last Tuesday, one does, courtesy of wanting to celebrate a civil war fought to defend slavery.
Europeans do not understand the curious civilisation that the current America is becoming, and the grip that a visceral and idiosyncratic conservatism has on its national discourse. They especially do not understand the undercurrents of an increasingly self-confident and subtle racism that is its own variant of the forces that in Europe gave us Le Pen and Pim Fortuyn. George Bush Jnr is a chip off the old multilateralist, transatlantic establishment, runs the European argument. He may seem hawkishly conservative but, in the end, he seeks UN resolutions like other American Presidents. Even at home, his bark is worse than his bite.
Wrong, wrong and wrong again. Anyone who thinks the Tory party is 'nasty' has not encountered contemporary American republicanism. Georgia's Republican Party, for example, is now lead by Ralph Reed, a long-time crusader against abortion, divorce and single parent families. He would regard last week's vote in the House of Lords allowing unmarried and gay couples to adopt as the work of Satan. He is part of US conservatism's ideological hard core.
Reed played every card he could. If the governorship was to be won celebrating the Confederacy, the race for the Senate seat would be no less shameless. The Democrat incumbent had lost three limbs fighting in Vietnam, but was attacked for being unpatriotic - the worst accusation in today's US - because he believed that unions should be able to recruit in the newly established Department of Homeland Security.
And so one of American liberalism's darkest days was repeated across the country. Minnesota and Missouri, long-time Democrat strongholds, fell. Governor Jeb Bush, despite the Democrats insisting that justice now be done for those infamous chads, won in Florida. As if to underscore conservatism's ascendancy, the only Democrat gain was in Arkansas where the Republican senator had suffered a messy divorce and his Democrat challenger was even more pro-gun and pro-Bible than the incumbent.
The result is that the Republicans now control the Senate, House and the presidency for the first time since President Eisenhower. The consolidation of America as an ultra conservative country is going to take place rapidly. Mr Bush may have offered a few tit-bits to show his credentials as a 'compassionate conservative', like his concern to reduce the price of prescription drugs for the elderly, but the core of the Republican programme is anything but. There will be radical tax cuts for the rich and the corporations; a freezing of all efforts to stiffen regulation in the wake of America's corporate scandals; moves to privatise the social security system; and a roll-back of environmental protection.
Abroad, there will be the continued construction of a new international order built around the prejudices of the American Right; unqualified support for Israel, building the National Missile Defence System and tepid support for the framework of international law and treaties.
Nor do the Conservatives' ambitions stop there. Following the ideas of the high priest of ultra conservatism, Leo Strauss, they want to construct a republic of 'moral', god-fearing citizens who adhere to traditional virtues, rewarding the rich who can only have become rich through the virtue of hard work and penalising the poor who are only poor because of their own fecklessness. Above all, by now having the opportunity to pack the judiciary with extreme right-wing judges, they intend to do away with the famous Roe v Wade judgment that legalised abortion. This is the most fiercely reactionary programme to have emerged in any Western democracy since the war, and for which last Tuesday's vote, argue Republicans, is an explicit mandate.
Horseshit. George Bush has al-Qaeda and a low turn-out to thank for his victory. The central message of his five-day tour of 15 key states in the last week of the election was to play on Americans' fears about terrorism, rallying them behind their national leader. When the electorate voted locally, the Democrats had the edge, winning governorships in four of the biggest industrial states - Illinois, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Michigan. The Democrats I have spoken to are so traumatised by the overall defeat that they dismiss these gains as irrelevant; I think they are wrong.
America is not a happy place. A generation of increasingly conservative policies has shrunk the American middle and induced not just fantastic inequality but a sharp decline in social mobility and opportunity. The US's social contract, never more than minimalist, is now threadbare. Consumer confidence is low; job insecurity high. American capitalism is viewed with deep scepticism. Nor are the majority of Americans social conservatives and closet racists; they do not want the clock put back over women's rights, the environment and race.
The trouble was that this silent liberal majority was only prepared to voice its preoccupations at state rather than national level, if it bothered to vote at all. The Democrats had to find a way of voicing the concerns of the mass of Americans while not undermining the President during a national emergency, but to do that they had to have a powerful pitch based on a liberal ideology as animating and dynamic as that of the conservatives. They didn't and they lost.
But the game isn't up. America's conservatives, blinded by their ideology and in control of every lever of government, will overreach themselves and the reality of what they plan will become evident to all, stirring the apathetic voter and reminding the best of America what it stands for. Last week represented the highwater mark of American conservatism and, although it looks bleak, the beginnings of the long-awaited liberal revival. Not just the United States, but the world, needs it badly. In the meantime, despite its flaws, give thanks to the European Union for partial shelter from the conservative storm.
I guess there must be something inherently noble in killing babies in the womb, dishonoring one's marriage vows, and raising kids without the benefit of a father. Yeah, Ralph, you really are a terrible guy.
"America is not a happy place"
It's certainly happier than it was last Monday.
All I can say is that I think that I got hit with some of this guy's spit from HERE!
Pro-gun? Oh yeah, that silly Second Amendment thing. And pro-Bible? The horror!
Yeah, all those right-wing Clinton judicial appointments. And Jimmy Carter was president within this last generation. Everyone knows what a reactionary whacko he is.
Why the quotation marks, Mr Hutton? Are casualties
in a losing war not veterans? What do you call your
dead redcoats from the War of American Independence?
Listen, you sniveling elitist punk, if it weren't for the USA and George W. Bush, the whole European continent would be speaking Arabic.
I'm not usually envious but, DAMN, I wish I could get paid for being this stupid.
I don't know about "Europeans", but Will Hutton certainly doesn't. He doesn't have a clue about what's going on.
"The Democrat incumbent had lost three limbs fighting in Vietnam, but was attacked for being unpatriotic"
Either this is intentional dysinformation, or Hutton has not been paying attention.
Saxby Chambliss clearly and carefully stated:
"I am not questioning your patriotism. I am questioning your judgment."
If Hutton does not know this, he should.
And how do YOU regard it, you British twit??
A more pointed reply, though I do agree, might be Russian / Eisenhower thru Reagan! Whining of a small mosquito - SLAP!
Yes, it is a dark day for America because we are still full of people who think like you do . . . and want to mess our society up even more than we were messed up by eradicating the family and kill as many babies as possible to appease the god of this world.
Not for a moment do I believe the Republican party will cure all that ails America; they are just the lesser of the evils that threaten to destroy us.
??? Umm.. Not that I am really offended, but profanity in a "newspaper" says alot about where said paper is coming from. Sort of like the Village Voice in NY.
Is that all? The ones in TV are contemplating cyanide laced Kool Aid.
If he's upset now, just wait until the storm sweeps over Britain and the rest of Europe. Then he is going to be in a tizzy.
In other words, after taxes, he takes home less than my nanny.
He is entertaining, though. I do so enjoy hearing Lefties whine and gnash their teeth at their setbacks.
... Last week represented the highwater mark of American conservatism and, although it looks bleak, the beginnings of the long-awaited liberal revival ...Yikes. If I ever become this detached from reality, please shoot me. Not that I'd notice.
I wish I could be so optimistic.
Far-right: Anyone to the right of Josef Stalin.
Listen, I have many European friends, and I lived over there for several years. My point is this: name a major accomplishment of *any* European state since WWII.
Curiously , their last major accomplishment *was* WWII.
Since then every Western European nation has lapsed into a socialist stasis. Every European, fat 'n happy on generous welfare , lives in a depressing , gray , middle-classness. If anyone is blinded it's *them*.
They can live that way because *American* blood has provided them with the means. They hadn't the cajones or the foresight to solve any of their self-created problems: the Kaiser, Hitler, Stalin, Milosovic, etc,etc.
We see these attitudes because those in power now in Europe are the generation who have never really lived in a non-peaceful europe. Short memories!
To those leftists who believe America is "imperialist", my answer is this: "you ain't seen nothin yet"
Timeline goes like this: Monroe Doctrine => Roosevelt Corrolary => Bush Doctrine.
Each time an American leader has asserted American authority , power, and most importantly American *values* in the world, the world has become a better place.
Bush will prove these European simpletons wrong, (again!)
This statement truly shows how little this fool knows of the Republicans that typically inhabit national office in this country.
The men and women who are elected to congress in the United States quickly loose whatever backbone they had prior to being sworn in.
Any convictions that they harbored as candidates are viciously rented from their bodies by the old guard. They are instructed to play ball if they want to be players.
In order to get things done they have to go along to get along.
The freshman class the was brought in under Newts Republican Revolution is a prime example. In the early days they had impact. Their numbers gave them power. But it lasted only so long as they maintained their unity. But they were soon subsumed in to the morass of the larger power structure and lost the power of their convictions that made them different.
I hope I am wrong but I doubt that I am. This Republican Revolution will also pass. And the status quo will remain.
GWs push for the prescription drug plan is ample proof of this fact.
Please pass the popcorn!
Which is only right since she is smarter and more politically astute.
File this guy's rant under left-wing polemics and forget it.
Is this guy still upset about that whole American Revolution thing?
It's obvious this man is on drugs.
Give the Brits credit for hanging on after France fell. They were mighty alone about the time of Dunkirk in 1940. The Russians at that time were cozy with the Nazis, what with the Ribbentrop-Molotov non-aggression treaty. I admire what the RAF did during a very black period.
That said, you're right. Without the United States, all Europe including the Soviet Union probably would have fallen to the Germans.
Will Hutton, editor of The Observer.