Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Tallahassee Democrat reporter suspended for e-mail criticizing Arabs
herald tribune ^ | Jan 03, 2003 | By BRENDAN FARRINGTON

Posted on 01/03/2003 1:37:05 PM PST by dennisw

Tallahassee Democrat reporter suspended for e-mail criticizing Arabs

By BRENDAN FARRINGTON Associated Press Writer

A Tallahassee Democrat reporter was suspended Thursday for using strong language in an e-mail criticizing Arab nations for the way they've reacted to Israel.

Political writer and columnist Bill Cotterell, in an e-mail exchange, wrote "Except for Jordan and Egypt, no Arab nation has a peace treaty with Israel. They've had 54 years to get over it. They choose not to."

The Washington-based Council on American-Islamic Relations sent an alert to its members calling the remarks anti-Muslim and anti-Arab.

Council spokesman Ibrahim Hooper said the e-mail's recipient had previously complained about a political cartoon that briefly appeared on the newspaper's Web site, asking "What would Mohammed drive?" and depicting a Ryder truck carrying a missile. The cartoon was not published in the paper.

The complaint started an exchange with Cotterell, who also wrote, "I don't give a damn if Israel kills a few in collateral damage while defending itself. So be it."

Cotterell was suspended a week without pay. Democrat Executive Editor John Winn Miller apologized for the remarks.

"They absolutely do not represent the views and sensitivities of this newspaper. Worse, they run counter to many of the values we hold dearest, among them tolerance, diversity and inclusiveness," Miller said in a written statement issued by the newspaper and carried in a story for Friday editions telling of Cotterell's suspension.

The cartoon was drawn by Doug Marlette, who draws from his home in Hillsborough, N.C.

Miller said Cotterell immediately regretted the remarks after sending the message on his company e-mail account and apologized to his colleagues "for the hurt and embarrassment he knows he caused."

"I was wrong and I am sorry," Cotterell said. "My remarks were grossly inappropriate and do not reflect my views toward Muslim people."

Hooper said the punishment was fair.

"It will send a positive message to the Muslim community in Florida that this kind of bigotry will not be tolerated and I appreciate the swift action of the Tallahassee Democrat in resolving this issue," he said. "We don't want to be vindictive in this. We just want to make sure bigoted views don't color the news related to Muslim and American-Arab issues."


TOPICS: Business/Economy; Constitution/Conservatism; Crime/Corruption; Culture/Society; Extended News; Free Republic
KEYWORDS: arab
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-34 last
To: Rummyfan
I don't have CAIR but I have these two. One is the editor and the other the suspended writer. I sent out an e-mail.

jwmiller@taldem.com ; bcotterell@taldem.com

21 posted on 01/03/2003 5:14:44 PM PST by dennisw
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 20 | View Replies]

To: dennisw
"I was not wrong and I am only sorry that I almost got fired," Cotterell said. "My remarks were grossly inappropriate accurate and do not reflect my views toward Muslim people. Unfortunately, the thought police forced me into making this public confession to keep my job, freedom of speech/the press notwithstanding."

22 posted on 01/03/2003 7:41:11 PM PST by ppaul
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: ppaul
Makes ya puke bump.
23 posted on 01/03/2003 8:23:59 PM PST by Ciexyz
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | View Replies]

To: dennisw
Ibrahim Hooper aspires to became the "Jesse Jackson" of Muslim Americans. Hooper cries bigotry when ever his views are challenged.
24 posted on 01/03/2003 8:40:53 PM PST by Kuksool
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: dennisw
How can these people sleep at night, knowing their disservice to their readership, to America. . .knowing they have chosen to abdicate their responsibility as journalists. . .

While realizing the tentacles of politcal correctness affect us everyday, this story, nonetheless is particularly depressing and frightening.

I would like to think they are choking on their political correctness; but I fear they are taking more comfort in their 'kill the messenger' response.

25 posted on 01/04/2003 2:22:46 AM PST by cricket
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: dennisw
I'm going to take a chance. I saw the headline, barely scanned the article, but I ccouldn't resist posting something pointing out the hyprocisy of a Big Media outlet that is supposed to be a guardian of the First Amendment doing this.
26 posted on 01/04/2003 2:28:12 AM PST by Looking4Truth
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: second_half_recovery
Do these liberals realize how idiotic they look when they recite these buzzwords, then intolerantly reduce the diversity of their workforce by excluding someone with a different opinion?

Good 'catch phrase'. When a conservative or other 'troublemaker' gets pegged for being un-PC the reply could be 'If my opinion is to be ridiculed or stifled doesn't that indicate an intolerant reduction of diversity?

I know of a couple of response to that comeback or something like it. You either get the 'deer in the headlights look' or get attacked with liberal emotion-non-logic rants.

27 posted on 01/04/2003 2:36:22 AM PST by Looking4Truth
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 12 | View Replies]

To: swarthyguy
In a rational world, President Bush would have shut down CAIR. They are as much a jihadi and terror supporting group as anyone else. They've NEVER condemned any jihadis anywhere. Hooper is a liar.

I saw Hooper interviewed by Sean Hannity a few weeks ago and he just couldn't bring himself to admit that Palestinian suicide bombers were terrorists. ...NOR did he admit that bin Laden a terrorist. Sean kept pressing for him to use the "t" word, buy Hooper refused. It was sickening.

What's the worst that could happen to Bush (politically) if he shut down CAIR? He wouldn't get the A-Rab/Muslim vote? Big friggen deal. Take a stand to protect the country, and forget this PC crapola.

28 posted on 01/04/2003 8:24:20 AM PST by Mr. Mojo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: Blue Screen of Death
Yep..... Truth, justice, and honor barely appear on the radar screens of the PC/leftist crowd. Hell, they probably would have difficultly even defining them.
29 posted on 01/04/2003 8:34:04 AM PST by Mr. Mojo
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: dennisw
Worse, they run counter to many of the values we hold dearest, among them tolerance, diversity and inclusiveness,

This is just sick. To be tolerant of Arab states insisting on wiping all Jews off the face of the earth is just plain evil. It's like turning a blind eye on Hitler in the name of "tolerance." Apparently the Jews are allowed into the inclusiveness mix as long as they are dead... but included.

30 posted on 01/04/2003 7:36:05 PM PST by 69ConvertibleFirebird
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

Comment #31 Removed by Moderator

To: Joseph_CutlerUSA
yup!!!
32 posted on 01/05/2003 11:22:05 PM PST by dennisw
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | View Replies]

To: dennisw
Click to scroll to commentary.

For A "Tolerant, Diverse, Inclusive" Press: Newspaper Apologizes For WWII Coverage
Toogood Reports ^ | 6 January 2003 | Nicholas Stix

Posted on 01/06/2003 11:39 AM PST by mrustow

Toogood Reports [Monday, January 6, 2003; 12:01 a.m. EST]
URL: http://ToogoodReports.com/

No, Tallahassee Democrat Executive Editor John Winn Miller didn't really apologize to our old Nazi and Japanese enemies from World War II — not yet, anyway — but he might as well have. Miller forced veteran political reporter and columnist Bill Cotterell to apologize, and suspended Cotterell for one week without pay, for making a couple of statements in private e-mails that were sympathetic to the Israelis, and critical of Arab attempts, since 1948, to annihilate the Jews of Israel. Had Cotterell, who served in the U.S Marine Corps for four years, has written for the newspaper since 1985, and has been working press since 1967, refused to apologize, he would have been fired.

Cotterell reportedly wrote, "Except for Jordan and Egypt, no Arab nation has a peace treaty with Israel. They've had 54 years to get over it. They choose not to," and "OK, they can squat around the camel-dung fire and grumble about it, or they can put their bottoms in the air five times a day and pray for deliverance; that's their business .... And I don't give a damn if Israel kills a few in collateral damage while defending itself. So be it."

Note that Bill Cotterell did not go out looking for an argument — he got suckered into one by a cowardly, pan-Arabist instigator. The instigator — referred to deceptively as "the recipient," as if he just sat at home and either accidentally received Cotterell's e-mail, or Cotterell sent out e-mails to pan-Arabists, hoping to get a rise out of them (which sounds like something I would do) — has a history of taking swings at the newspaper (and surely others), and then calling on the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) to beat up on it for him. The knucklehead had recently complained about a political cartoon that appeared on the Democrat's web site by Pulitzer Prize-winning political cartoonist Doug Marlette. According to the Associated Press' Brendan Farrington, "Council spokesman Ibrahim Hooper said the e-mail's recipient had previously complained about a political cartoon that briefly appeared on the newspaper's Web site, asking 'What would Mohammed drive?' and depicting a Ryder truck carrying a missile. The cartoon was not published in the paper."

Reading between the cautious Farrington's lines, Marlette's cartoon was apparently censored the moment Hooper started screaming. Al Qaeda and Islamic Jihad are apparently now in charge of America's press.

In Doug Marlette's case, Tallahassee Democrat Executive Editor John Winn Miller put up token resistance to Hooper, to at least give the impression of journalistic independence. "... I defend Doug's right to ridicule anyone. While the vast majority of Muslims are a peaceful people and preach a peaceful religion, there are some who have subverted the message of the Prophet Muhammad for their own violent purposes.... Lampooning fanatics who believe they have a religious basis for murder is fair game."

Doug Marlette's work was censored only six months after the Tallahassee Democrat had celebrated hiring the famous, veteran political cartoonist.

Regarding Bill Cotterell, CAIR's Ibrahim Hooper said, with perfectly forked tongue, "Any journalist has a right to his or her political and religious views, but when those views are expressed in such bigoted terms, it raises questions about a media outlet's journalistic balance and objectivity."

In Bill Cotterell's case, however, John Winn Miller did not bother covering his obscene surrender with a fig leaf of pro-freedom rhetoric.

In last Friday's edition, Miller publicly apologized:

"They absolutely do not represent the views and sensitivities of this newspaper. Worse, they run counter to many of the values we hold dearest, among them tolerance, diversity and inclusiveness."

Translated from the newspeak, that would be "tolerance, diversity and inclusiveness for America's enemies."

Miller also forced Cotterell to make a show trial-type confession:

"I was wrong and I am sorry. My remarks were grossly inappropriate and do not reflect my views toward Muslim people."

And how is it that the pan-Arabist coward who started this has managed to keep his name a secret?

I get e-mails from morons all the time, some of whom I put in their place. In my case, the knuckleheads are usually racist blacks who assume that my name is a pseudonym. But mainstream journalists already live in fear of saying the "wrong" thing. The Cotterell case will have a chilling effect in further intimidating them from writing what they think, or responding to readers' letters.

But what if Cotterell had said what he did without first being suckered into it? The first statement was true, and the other was morally correct. For 54 years, the Arab world has sought to murder all of the Jews of Israel. And Israel has the right to defend itself, a defense which cannot help but involve "collateral damage." But while the Israelis kill civilians by accident, the Arabs kill Jewish civilians on purpose. And the same Arabs seeking to destroy Israel seek to destroy America, with the help of non-Arab Moslems around the world.

On 911, Islam attacked America. When George Bush started saying, at a Washington, D.C. interfaith service a few days later, that "Islam is peace," he didn't fool anyone. Moslems didn't believe it, and among "infidels," the phrase immediately became a punch line. But Bush had to say such nonsense, because he comes from the Don Corleone school of international relations: "Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer." There was no advantage to Bush saying what everyone knew to be true; but in using deception, he could get help from some Islamic nations, in order to beat others. Bush well understands that international relations are always conducted in the state of nature of the war of all against all (or at least, some against others), in which honesty and transparency towards one's enemies are fatal mistakes.

But one cannot tolerate such deception from one's own citizens in wartime. It is not Christian and Jewish Americans who need to apologize to Moslems, but the other way around. At the very least, Moslems need to prove their patriotism, the same way German and Japanese Americans were obliged to do so sixty years ago.

Many Moslems have complained since 911, that they are offended that people would question their patriotism. There's a reason for such doubts; the complainers' patriotism is questionable. And that includes you, Ibrahim Hooper.

Hooper pronounced himself pleased with the kowtowing.

"It will send a positive message to the Muslim community in Florida that this kind of bigotry will not be tolerated and I appreciate the swift action of the Tallahassee Democrat in resolving this issue. We don't want to be vindictive in this. We just want to make sure bigoted views don't color the news related to Muslim and American-Arab issues."

If the newspapers had acted this way 60 years ago, America might well today be divided between German-speaking and Japanese-speaking halves.

Ibrahim Hooper is demanding that American journalists show allegiance to America's enemies. Maybe I'm a simple fellow, but that sounds to me like a Philadelphia lawyer's sort of fancy pants treason. And John Winn Miller, an American, went along with it.

To comment on this article or express your opinion directly to the author, you are invited to e-mail Nicholas at adddda@earthlink.net .



33 posted on 01/07/2003 1:56:14 PM PST by mrustow
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: 69ConvertibleFirebird
Post #33 may be of interest to you. I originally posted it as "Newspaper Apologizes to Nazis and Japs for WWII Coverage," but the thread nannies didn't like that, and changed it.
34 posted on 01/07/2003 2:03:07 PM PST by mrustow
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 30 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-2021-34 last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson