Dr Johnston? Undoubtedly.
The comedian is simply another guy that borrows the Christian ethos and then launched into tirades about the evil Christians that not only practice that ethos but believe it deeply. I wish atheists would simply embrace the reductionism that is the essence of atheism and be done with it.
Both. Anyone who looks at the Ten Commandments and proclaims that he has kept every single one perfectly is a liar.
Why? It is much more fun to fully deconstruct this reductionism instead. If you think about it, where does the western idea of what is "good" and "right" come from? Why is it "correct" when a Christian gets dinged for not doing what is "good" or "right?"