[Antoninus]

Thus, both as believers and as worshipers, Catholics who become Protestants are statistically better Christians than those who stay Catholic. We are losing the best, not the worst.

This is classic. Please keep in mind that "the best" in the view of this particular periodical, are pro-abortion, pro-divorce, pro-birth control, pro-homosexual, pro-women's ordination, cafeteria Catholics.

As a Catholic, I say that this is indeed good news. If people hold those views they should not darken the door of any Catholic Church. Protestants are welcome to them.

[marshmallow]

I looked through the article and nowhere did I see any mention of "doing what God requires of me" or anything about "serving God" or "fulfilling my obligations towards the Almighty". There's a fundamental difference in the way these people see religion and the way I see it. I see God in the center and me kneeling at His feet saying "here am I Lord, I come to do your will".

Those mentioned in the survey are talking about "my needs"......., "my likes.........".

Reese actually uses the word "product".

That's religion totally backwards, as far as I'm concerned. It's not about me.

It seems fairly clear (if we accept this at face value); those leaving are dissatisfied customers and Reese is parroting the old cliche that the "customer is always right" and we're not satisfying the customer.

When it comes to religion, he's not always right. The Church is right because it was founded by Jesus Christ. We're the sinners.

That concept appears to be entirely absent from his essay.