FreeRepublic.com "A Conservative News Forum"
[ Last | Latest Posts | Latest Articles | Self Search | Add Bookmark | Post | Abuse | Help! ]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

BLOOD TRAIL :RCMP hint at blood probe charges

News/Current Events Breaking News News
Source: Toronto Star
Published: 11/15/99 Author: By Tim Harper
Posted on 11/15/1999 05:13:04 PST by Brian Mosely

OTTAWA - It's taken almost two years and cost more than $2 million, but there are now signs that the pieces from one of the most complex puzzles ever handed to the RCMP are beginning to fall into place.

The criminal probe into this country's tainted blood scandal begins a ``new phase'' as early as this week, with investigators hinting at more dramatic developments in the weeks ahead.

Although they will not discuss a time frame, there now seems little doubt that charges will be laid in what has been described as one of this country's greatest injustices.

Victims are cautiously allowing hopes to be buoyed.

Senior RCMP officers, mindful of huge, fruitless probes into Airbus and Air India in recent years, concede there is pressure to move on a file which has taken investigators around the world.

``We are moving at a more intense pace,'' said Inspector Rod Knecht, the lead investigator who heads a team which works from an unmarked, nondescript building in the shadow of the RCMP detachment in Newmarket.


`We have put our trust in the RCMP. We want them to get their man. It's extremely important for the memory of those victims, both living and dead.'
- Mike McCarthy, hemophiliac and leader in compensation battle

``We have become very focused in our efforts and very clear in the direction we're heading. Something might be happening in the next couple of weeks.''

For Ontario hemophiliac Mike McCarthy and other victims, there is a sense that a long wait for justice might be coming to an end.

``We have put our trust in the RCMP,'' McCarthy said. ``We want them to get their man. It's extremely important for the memory of those victims, both living and dead.''

Between 1983 and 1987, tens of thousands of Canadians were infected with HIV - the virus that causes AIDS - and hepatitis C from bad blood or blood products.

The task force has already eaten up about $2.3 million from a cash-strapped RCMP budget.

Fourteen full-time staff work under tight security in the Newmarket office, including police investigators, medical and legal specialists and liaison officers who work with victims. They also have their own support staff.

They have interviewed more than 1,000 people and seized more than 100,000 documents.

The probe has taken them across Canada and the United States, as well as Costa Rica, France, Germany, Belgium, Switzerland, the Netherlands and Australia.

They have logged more than 700 calls to a toll-free tips line.

Next week marks the second anniversary of the release of the report of the inquiry into the tainted blood scandal by Mr. Justice Horace Krever. In the wake of his report, the RCMP immediately pledged to see whether there was enough information for a criminal probe.

Their inquiry was upgraded to a full-fledged investigation in February, 1998.

Still, there is concern that RCMP investigators may not be setting their sights high enough and may be content with charging middle-level bureaucrats.

``I've always said they should be going as high on the food chain as possible,'' said a Toronto man who holds key information and has twice been interviewed by the RCMP. ``I was always taught that the buck stops with the political masters.''

McCarthy, while saying no one wants a witch hunt, said many victims would like to see the French experience repeated in Canada.

In France, former prime minister Laurent Fabius and former ministers Edmond Hervé and Georgina Dufoix were charged with manslaughter in that country's tainted blood scandal. Only Hervé was convicted, although he was given no penalty.

RCMP spokesperson Sergeant André Guertin would not discuss whether former ministers in Canada were interviewed.

``We've gone wherever the investigation has taken us,'' Guertin said.

There are at least four separate threads woven into the police investigation.

  • There is the destruction of documents by bureaucrats in the now defunct Canadian Blood Committee, itself the subject of a separate probe within the probe.

    Eight years worth of audio tapes and transcripts were trashed by officials in a decision made by Dr. Jo Hauser, then the executive director of the committee.

    Information commissioner John Grace, in a report released three years ago, found the documents were destroyed after the committee received a request for them under Access to Information legislation.

  • There is the role of the federal bureau of biologics and the Canadian Red Cross in allowing Canadians to become infected with tainted blood.

    In his report, Krever fingered the charitable organization - and he named its former deputy national director of blood transfusion services, Dr. Martin Davey - for allowing its response to the blood-borne AIDS crisis to lag behind other nations in the mid-1980s.

  • There is the separate issue of the importation of tainted blood from prisoners in Arkansas, brought into Canada by a Montreal-based blood broker and used by Canadian hemophiliacs. The same tainted blood product was exported around the world by the Canadian broker.

    An Arkansas doctor, Michael Galster, blew the whistle on the for-profit bleeding of prisoners at Cummins Prison. Many of those prisoners were HIV positive or intravenous drug users.

    After the U.S. Food and Drug Administration cracked down on the use of prison blood in 1983, the prison exported blood to Canada through Montreal-based Continental Pharma Cryosan.

    About 1,000 Canadian hemophiliacs infected by that blood product, including the estates of those who have died, have launched a $1.1 billion lawsuit claiming Ottawa negligently allowed it into the country.

    ``The RCMP is our only hope of spurring an investigation here,'' Galster said from Arkansas. ``I've always prayed the RCMP would stay on top of this as hard as possible to do something officially, so our FBI and justice department would be forced to act.''

    Last January, Galster turned over his documentation to RCMP officers.

    The RCMP, however, has not inquired about an incident last May when Galster's clinic in Pine Bluff, Ark., was firebombed.

    In a curious twist, files were stolen from the Montreal offices of the Canadian Hemophilia Society the same night.

    No charges have been laid in either incident.

  • There are the actions of Armour Pharmaceutical Co., a U.S.-based manufacturer of blood products which supplied the Canadian Red Cross.

    Krever was told the company ignored warnings that its method of heat-treating the product to protect against the HIV virus was not totally effective.

    At least seven hemophiliacs, most of them children, contracted HIV from two lots of Armour blood products which had been cleared by Health Canada's bureau of biologics.


    1 Posted on 11/15/1999 05:13:04 PST by Brian Mosely
    [ Reply | Private Reply | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    Last January, Galster turned over his documentation to RCMP officers.

    The RCMP, however, has not inquired about an incident last May when Galster's clinic in Pine Bluff, Ark., was firebombed.

    In a curious twist, files were stolen from the Montreal offices of the Canadian Hemophilia Society the same night.

    No charges have been laid in either incident.

    This outrage needs to keep getting publicity.

    2 Posted on 11/15/1999 05:25:42 PST by aristeides (demosthenes@olg.com)
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: aristeides

    A disgusted bump.

    3 Posted on 11/15/1999 05:32:08 PST by truthkeeper
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | Top | Last ]


    To: truthkeeper

    bump again

    4 Posted on 11/15/1999 06:24:40 PST by Brian Mosely
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely


    5 Posted on 11/15/1999 06:36:25 PST by Budge (budge@seark.net)
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: aristeides

    "This outrage needs to keep getting publicity."

    Let as many people know about this as possible.

    6 Posted on 11/15/1999 06:40:45 PST by Budge (budge@seark.net)
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | Top | Last ]


    To: Budge, Askel5, BigM, Wallaby

    Bump and a Drip.

    7 Posted on 11/15/1999 06:44:32 PST by CholeraJoe
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | Top | Last ]


    To: T'wit, Force Ten, Marcus Welby

    Bump.

    8 Posted on 11/15/1999 06:45:27 PST by CholeraJoe
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    We are moving at a more intense pace,

    Meanwhile ... back at the US Justice Department, Reno lets her Mail Room Supervisor vet her mail and rebuff pleas for an investigation.

    Morning Budge ... thanks for the GIF!

    9 Posted on 11/15/1999 06:50:28 PST by Askel5
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: Askel5

    Morning dear one! You're more than welcome. We sure missed you at the recent get-together

    10 Posted on 11/15/1999 07:15:50 PST by Budge (budge@seark.net)
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    Do you have a URL for this story?

    11 Posted on 11/15/1999 07:17:10 PST by MadAsHell
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: MadAsHell

    Here you go. I was in a hurry this morning...

    12 Posted on 11/15/1999 07:20:06 PST by Brian Mosely
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    Thanks! I want to be able to send it along to some friends of mine who work in the blood collection "industry".

    13 Posted on 11/15/1999 07:40:21 PST by MadAsHell
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 12 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    Excellent post!

    A big bump and a drip for the men in red!

    14 Posted on 11/15/1999 07:57:21 PST by BigM
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: Budge

    I was bummed. The only evidence I weighed those two weeks centered on which coffee pot looked the freshest ... =(

    15 Posted on 11/15/1999 08:13:57 PST by Askel5
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | Top | Last ]


    To: truthkeeper

    Hey truthkeeper!

    16 Posted on 11/15/1999 12:34:47 PST by Askel5
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    In his report, Krever fingered the charitable organization - and he named its former deputy national director of blood transfusion services, Dr. Martin Davey - for allowing its response to the blood-borne AIDS crisis to lag behind other nations in the mid-1980s.

    I'd like to know who was responsible for: (1) the 1983 decision by the "Reagan" Administration to waive annual inspections by the FDA of donor center; (2) ignoring the FDA's three suspensions of HMA's license to bleed at Cummins Prison; and (3) ignoring the Canadians' discovery of Angola, Louisiana prison blood in Connaught lab batches; (4) ignoring the 1978 suit and 1980 appeal of the Arizona prisoner who alleged infection with Hep-C from the prison's plasmapheresis program -- one Bruce Babbitt defended the State on appeal and continued the prison bleed operation during his subsequent tenure as governor.

    I think our own Red Cross has much to answer for ... including Bush-appointed Liddie Dole who so graciously served as a volunteer for her first year (four months into which she ASKED to overhaul the entire US blood system).

    Maybe -- despite her Harvard JD, degrees in government and public safety and a career centered on public education and welfare ... she's just a bimbo after all.

    17 Posted on 11/15/1999 12:45:06 PST by Askel5
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    Investigators expecting important developments in the next few weeks? I wish I had a dollar every time I heard that about a Clinton scandal. Let's face it, he's never going to be brought to justice for what he does.

    18 Posted on 11/15/1999 14:36:53 PST by Pining_4_TX
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    BUMP

    Another chapter for the Clinton Legacy.

    19 Posted on 11/15/1999 16:01:31 PST by Grandy
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 12 | Top | Last ]


    To: Theresa

    More "puzzle pieces" ...

    20 Posted on 11/15/1999 17:02:13 PST by Askel5
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | Top | Last ]


    To: Askel5

    A bump and a drip!

    21 Posted on 11/15/1999 19:45:19 PST by BigM
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 20 | Top | Last ]


    To: Great Dane

    Front page of the biggest daily in Canada and our political opposition can't be bothered to ask a question about it in the House of Commons. Very disturbing as one would think this would be a great reminder to the Prime Minister of all the tainted blood people he abandoned because he says that negligence only started in 1986.

    22 Posted on 11/15/1999 19:52:39 PST by BigM
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 20 | Top | Last ]


    To: aristeides

    I would think the fire and break-in would really tie the whole thing together, I sure hope the RCMP didn't ignore it.

    23 Posted on 11/15/1999 20:32:50 PST by Great Dane
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely, CLIVE

    Bump.

    24 Posted on 11/15/1999 20:33:55 PST by Great Dane
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | Top | Last ]


    To: BigM

    BigM, do you remember when we said, the best government, is a terrific opposition, I don't recall the last good opposition we had, it's been such a long time.

    25 Posted on 11/15/1999 20:39:13 PST by Great Dane
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | Top | Last ]


    To: CholeraJoe, Brian Mosely, T'wit

    Thanks for staying with this story, Brian.

    Thanks for the bump, CJ. Where's T'wit?

    26 Posted on 11/15/1999 21:01:16 PST by Wallaby (wallaby@altavista.net)
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | Top | Last ]


    To: Great Dane

    We've made the trough to big to have politicians helping ordinary citizens.

    27 Posted on 11/15/1999 21:27:31 PST by BigM
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 25 | Top | Last ]


    To: Great Dane

    "BigM, do you remember when we said, the best government, is a terrific opposition, I don't recall the last good opposition we had, it's been such a long time."

    You are right.

    We had the potential of having an effective, vigourous, populist conservative opposition.

    Reform, in the face of conventional wisdom and derision and slander by the mainstream media, went from a party with one member in the House to Her Majesty's Official Opposition in just two general elections.

    It also helped to organize the defeat of a referendum on a proposed constitutional amendment that would have put Canada into a straightjacket in perpetuity.

    It did so in the face of the support of the referendum by every other political party, all the elites and special interest groups and the entire mainstream medis.

    What killed Reform's effectiveness was sudden success.

    I made an impromptue speach at London shortly after the first election when 52 Reformers were sent to Ottawa.

    I was watching the beginnings of the jockeying for power and control, the elbowing for positions on executives and the campaigning for policies that were supposed to attract liberal votes.

    I commandeered a microphone. I said that the biggest threat that faces a new party, especially a populist party, is sudden success. I reminded them of the abandonment of principles that took place and the resultant loss of credibility when the NDP party unexpectedly sent 40 members to Ottawa. My remarks were somewhat blunt in defence of staying the course and sticking to principles.

    I was congratulated on my speech by people who seemet to be important in the party at the time, but the party continued to, in effect, turn its policy making over to the hired sherpas and the poll takers, because it thought that such was the way to power, with the result that the party that had such promise will fade away like all the prior promising populist mpvements that came out of Western Canada, to lie dormant until the need for reform again becomes sufficiently compelling.

    I watched the same thing happen to Newt Gingrich's conservative populist movement in the US. I knew it would happen and said so, I just did not know the particulars of how it would happen.

    Please understand that I am not saying this to pat myself on the back. After all, I lost.

    I am beginning to see something similar happening in the Harris "Comon Sense Revolution" in Ontario.

    I feel like Cassandra.

    28 Posted on 11/15/1999 21:36:12 PST by Clive (chdove@home.com)
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 25 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    Quote Of The Day by thinktwice

    29 Posted on 11/15/1999 21:44:18 PST by RJayneJ
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: Brian Mosely

    Thank you for the article.

    It is reassuring that the Horsemen seem to be getting some results.

    30 Posted on 11/15/1999 21:54:33 PST by Clive (chdove@home.com)
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | Top | Last ]


    To: Wallaby

    > Where's T'wit?

    Nag, nag, nag.

    Bump.

    31 Posted on 11/15/1999 22:25:21 PST by T'wit
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 26 | Top | Last ]


    To: Clive

    Right on all points, I voted reform twice, in the last election, we didn't have a reform candidate, anyway by then they had already become just another party, looking like everyone else, it seems both in the states, and Canada, the parties meld together as one........ some choice, huh.

    32 Posted on 11/15/1999 23:05:26 PST by Great Dane
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 28 | Top | Last ]


    To: T'wit

    Well....... be glad you're missed, but be here when we need you.

    Were you by any chance shopping for another baritone disc, in that case, I understand you being a little late, after all, one does have priorities....... bet you never thought I would throw that one in your face. :-}

    33 Posted on 11/15/1999 23:10:27 PST by Great Dane
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | Top | Last ]


    To: T'wit

    Well....... be glad you're missed, but be here when we need you.

    Were you by any chance shopping for another baritone disc, in that case, I understand you being a little late, after all, one does have priorities....... bet you never thought I would throw that one in your face. :-}

    34 Posted on 11/15/1999 23:11:09 PST by Great Dane
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | Top | Last ]


    To: T'wit

    Pardon the double print......... s..t happens.

    35 Posted on 11/15/1999 23:28:15 PST by Great Dane
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | Top | Last ]


    To: ATTENTION! Steven Spielberg and AIDs activists everywhere

     
    Tainted-blood sleuth firebombed
     
    Intimidation campaign suspected as Arkansas clinic razed,
    Montreal office ransacked
     

    Hmmm. Now which Arkansan could it be who would be so unrestrained by law and scruples (and so restrained by psychopathy) as to intimidate adverse witnesses and destroy evidence?

    Worse than 10,000 Nixons
     
    As Gregor Samsa awoke one morning from uneasy dreams
    he found himself transformed in his bed into a gigantic insect
    ------------------------------------Franz Kafka, The Metamorphosis
     
     

    In retrospect it will be clear (notwithstanding the historians) that clinton was infinitely worse than 10,000 Nixons.

    In fact, when all the dust settles. . .

    it will be clear that clinton was infinitely worse than 10,000 Hitlers.

    36 Posted on 11/16/1999 05:19:49 PST by Mia T
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | Top | Last ]


    To: Steven Spielberg and AIDs Activists everywhere

    CLINTON & THE KILLER BLOOD
     
    In the mid-1980s, as contaminated blood flowed from
    Arkansas inmates to other countries, then-Governor
    W.J. Clinton sat on his hands despite evidence of
    severe mismanagement in his prison system and its
    medical operations. The prison medical program was
    being run by Health Management Associates, which was
    headed by Leonard Dunn, a man who would brag to state
    police of his close ties to Clinton.
     
    Some of the killer blood ended up in Canada where it
    contributed to the deaths of an unknown number of
    blood and plasma recipients. An estimated 2,000
    Canadian recipients of blood and related products got
    the AIDS virus between 1980 and 1985. At least 60,000
    Canadians were infected with the hepatitis C virus
    between 1980 and 1990. Arkansas was one of the few
    sources of bad blood during this period.
     
    The Royal Canadian Mounted Police has a staff of 24
    working on the case. So far, investigators have
    interviewed about 600 people including in the U.S.,
    Germany and the Netherlands. According to the Ottawa
    Citizen, the team has amassed more than 30,000
    documents.
     
    Other Arkansas plasma was sent to Switzerland, Spain,
    Japan, and Italy. In a case with strong echoes of the
    Arkansas scandal, a former premier of France and two
    of his cabinet colleagues are currently on trial
    stemming from the wrongful handling of blood
    supplies. Some of the blood in the French controversy
    may have come from Arkansas.
     
    A 1992 Newsday report on the French scandal noted
    that three persons had been convicted for their role
    in distributing blood they knew was contaminated:
    "Throughout the 1980s and later, blood was taken from
    prison donors for use in blood banks despite a series
    of directives warning against such a practice.
    According to the report, donations from prisoners
    accounted for 25 percent of all the contaminated
    blood products in France. Blood from prisons was 69
    times more contaminated that that of the general
    population of donors."
     
    The Arkansas blood program was also grossly
    mishandled by the Food and Drug Administration. And
    the scandal provides yet another insight into how the
    American media misled the public about Clinton during
    the 1992 campaign. The media ignored a major Clinton
    scandal despite, for example, 80 articles about it in
    the Arkansas Democrat in just one four-month period
    of the mid-80s.
     
    Here's how Canada's Krever Commissioner report
    describes the beginnings of the problem:
     
    "During 19812, the number of AIDS cases in the
    United States reported to the Centers for Disease
    Control in Atlanta grew at an alarming rate. The vast
    majority of the reported cases were of homosexual men
    and intravenous drug abusers. During 1982, cases of
    AIDS transmitted through the use of blood and blood
    products began to be reported.
    The U.S. blood and plasma centers regularly collected
    from two groups of persons who were at high risk of
    contracting AIDS: homosexual men and prison inmates.
    Plasma was collected at centers, licensed by the Food
    and Drug Administration, in prisons in Arkansas,
    Florida, Louisiana, and Mississippi. By way of
    contrast, because of the high prevalence of hepatitis
    B in prisons, the Canadian Red Cross Society had
    stopped collecting donations from prison inmates in
    1971."
     
    Suzi Parker, writing in the Arkansas Times, described
    the scene: "At the Cummins Unit of the Arkansas penal
    system during the 1980s, while President Clinton was
    still governor, inmates would regularly cross the
    prison hospital's threshold to give blood, lured by
    the prospect of receiving $7 a pint. The ritual was
    creepy to behold: Platoons of prisoners lying supine
    on rows of cots, waiting for the needle-wielding
    prisoner orderly to puncture a vein and watch the
    clear bags fill with blood. Administrators than sold
    the blood to brokers, who in turned shipped it to
    other sates and to Japan, Italy, Spain and Canada.
    Despite repeated warnings from the Food and Drug
    Administration, Arkansas kept its prison plasma
    program running until 1994 when it became the very
    last state to cease selling its prisoners' plasma.
     
    Mike Galster, a medical practitioner whose
    fictionalized account dramatically raised interest in
    the blood scandal, recalls that at the Pine Bluff
    unit's hospital they also took blood from prisoners.
    When he raised questions about the wisdom of bleeding
    sick people, he was told that even the ill had the
    right to sell their blood.
     
    Here is a time-line of this as yet too known Arkansas
    horror story:
     
    1981
     
    The Arkansas Board of Corrections puts A.L. "Art"
    Lockhart in charge of the state's troubled prisons.
    An Arkansas Gazette front page feature on Lockhart
    begins by noting that he is "dogged by a public
    reputation as a man who runs roughshod over the
    constitutionally guaranteed rights and welfare of
    inmates. 'I don't why,' he said in an interview with
    the Gazette. 'I don't deserve it.'"
     
    The state's prisons are already a mess. Ten years
    earlier Lockhart had taken over the notorious Cummins
    facility which, according to a member of the
    corrections board, was "still controlled by inmate
    trusties with guns. The inmates called the shots. A
    lot of experts said there was no way to take the guns
    away from them without a riot. But Art did it without
    spilling any blood."
     
    But the Gazette also notes: "The prison system, and
    Cummins, in particular, still is in the transition
    from an institution controlled by the inmates to one
    controlled by guards. On many nights at Cummins,
    there are as few as half a dozen guards to watch
    about 1,650 inmates."
     
    Two years earlier, a prison monitor hired under a
    federal court order, released a report saying there
    was "clear and convincing evidence" that Lockhart and
    other employees beat and kicked inmates needlessly
    after an attempted escape from Cummins. Another
    prison mediator charged that the abuse of inmates had
    increased under Lockhart and that he had obstructed
    efforts at prison reform.
     
    Health Management Associates wins a contract to
    provide health services to state inmates, including
    running a blood plasma donor program.
     
    The Centers for Disease Control and World Health
    Organization establish that AIDS is a blood-borne
    disease. CDC recommends testing and sterilization of
    donor blood. The warning is widely ignored and, as a
    result, according to WHO, some one million people
    become infected. Twenty-two countries will eventually
    have to pay compensation as a result.
     
    FDA asks US companies not to buy prison plasma since,
    due to unsafe sexual and drug practices by many
    inmates, the blood has a high risk of carrying the
    AIDS virus.
     
    JUNE 1983
     
    HMA tells FDA that 38 units of plasma from four
    inmates of the Grady prison should not have been
    collected because the prisoners had once tested
    positive for hepatitis B despite a test at the time
    of collection being negative. HMA sees the hazard as
    slight and thinks there is no need to recall the
    plasma. The Canadian Krever Commission will later
    report that "by 1983, however, an association had
    been identified between hepatitis B and AIDS; most
    persons with AIDS had also been infected with
    hepatitis B. There was a greater than average risk
    that the 38 units of plasma from the four inmates
    could transmit AIDS. Four of the units ended up in
    Canada, the others were sold to corporations in
    Switzerland, Spain, Japan, and Italy."
     
    AUGUST 1983
     
    HMA decides to withdraw the 38 units from circulation
    and FDA concurs. This is the first time that
    Connaught, the Canadian blood firm, has heard of any
    problems. The shipping papers had only shown that the
    blood came from "ADC Plasma Center, Grady, Arkansas."
     
    By this time, however, the blood is already in
    circulation and only 417 of 2409 vials are retrieved.
     
    The same month HMA tells the FDA of a fifth inmate
    with similar problems. He had given 34 units in less
    than a year.
     
    SEPTEMBER 1983
     
    Connaught reviews its approvals for receipt of plasma
    from US centers and finds that twelve have never been
    properly approved. One is the prison center in Grady,
    Arkansas. Other questionable blood has come from four
    prisons in Louisiana. Canadian Red Cross nullifies
    its contract for the blood the same day it finds this
    out.
     
    FEBRUARY 1984
     
    FDA suspends plasma production at the Grady facility
    where an average of 550-600 inmates have been giving
    blood since 1967. UPI regional wire reports that FDA
    finds overbleeding of inmate donors, disqualified
    donors, lack of documentation of testing, and
    inadequate storage. It also notes inaccurate and
    incomplete storage, instances of intentional and
    willful disregard for proposed standards, alteration
    of records and files to conceal violations, as well
    as inadequate training and ineffective supervision of
    the plasma center staff. Within months, however, HMA
    successfully applies for a new license after blaming
    the problems on a corrupt clerk.
     
    1985
     
    A UPI story recounts how the largest inmate donor
    program in the country -- in the Louisiana state
    prison -- is coming under increased federal scrutiny
    because of what is dubbed the "AIDS scare." Says the
    state's secretary of corrections: "We have no
    intention of shutting it down. It would have the same
    impact as a major industry shutting down in a small
    town: economic chaos." The president of a plasma
    company is quoted as saying, "There is no scientific
    evidence that prisoner plasma is worse than street
    plasma." The programs had, in fact, been shut down
    for six months but were reinstated after the prison
    discovered foreign markets to replace a dwindling US
    demand. Says the plasma company president, "I'd say
    70 to 80 percent is going overseas. There's a good
    market for it over there, and they don't ask where it
    came from."
     
    FDA finally requires testing of donor blood. Tainted
    blood distribution will continue inside the US until
    1986. Thereafter, contaminated blood stocks will
    still be shipped from US companies to other
    countries.
     
    Prosecuting attorney Wayne Matthews, after a two
    month state police probe, finds no evidence of drug
    trafficking in the Arkansas prison system. The
    allegation is that HMA employees are diverting drugs
    from the department's pharmacy and selling them to
    inmates, and that prisoners who 'knew too much' about
    drug trafficking were killed or allowed to die.
    "There's just absolutely no evidence whatsoever,"
    says Matthews.
     
    JANUARY 1986
     
    The Corrections board agrees to have HMA's contract
    reviewed by outside parties. A media account notes
    that "HMA has been frequently in the news lately
    because of allegations by inmates of improper medical
    treatment." Among the charges: HMA hired a
    Mississippi doctor who was refused a permanent
    license in Arkansas. The doctor had lost his
    Mississippi license for "habitual personal use of
    narcotic drugs."
     
    The Arkansas Democrat Gazette reports: "Governor Bill
    Clinton recently asked the Department to review
    health care services provided by HMA after
    allegations were raised that several inmates died
    because of a lack of medical care and that the leg of
    at least one inmate was amputated as a result of
    improper care. Department Director A. L. (Art)
    Lockhart, who earlier said HMA was doing a
    'satisfactory' job, said Thursday a review of HMA
    could reveal some problems. ~~~ During the discussion
    of HMA and the allegations that have been made
    against it, [Corrections] Board member Don Smith of
    Pine Bluff excused himself because his law firm
    represents HMA."
     
    MARCH 1986
     
    Clinton tells a radio audience that there is no
    solution to problems with running a prison, only the
    process of dealing with the problems as they arise.
    He also says that "there is no evidence of systematic
    abuse for which the administration is responsible
    that I can see. If I did, I'd try to do something
    about it."
     
    State Representative Bobby Glover charges that
    inmates are forced to participate in homosexual
    activities, that there have been gang rapes, that
    marijuana is openly smoked and that "home brew" is
    being sold for $7 to $10 a gallon. He disputes a
    recent prison department report that claimed only 6
    per cent of the inmate population was participating
    in illicit drug use. Glover says he also is looking
    into reports of gambling, the theft and personal use
    of department property by employees, bid rigging,
    three questionable deaths, the lack of medical
    services, the physical abuse of inmates by guards and
    other prison officials, and bribes to obtain work
    release assignments or favorable classification.
     
    Sandra Kurjiaka, director of the American Civil
    Liberties Union in Arkansas, says that there is a
    "real slavery problem" in the state correction
    department and that changes need to be made. Kurjiaka
    says an attitude exists that allows inmates to be
    raped and brutalized and that it exists with the
    consent of the governor, the correction board and the
    public.
     
    APRIL 86
     
    Clinton tells State Police chief Tommy Goodwin to
    begin a full scale investigation into reports of
    criminal conduct within the prison system. Says he
    finds them "very disturbing." Clinton makes his
    announcement after meeting for an hour with Goodwin
    and Rep. Glover. "Rep. Glover has communicated to me
    and Col. Goodwin some very serious allegations."
    Clinton says the state police "has resources" to
    investigate and Goodwin promises to assign at least
    eight investigators.
     
    MAY 1986
     
    Stories circulate about an alleged $25,000 bribe
    being paid to a prison board official to obtain a new
    contract for HMA. One witness tells the state police
    that the HMA board was angry about the extortion.
    This is all denied in a series of state police
    interviews with HMA and prison officials. It is
    claimed that the story arose from the attorney
    Richard Mays being hired for that same amount to
    serve for two years as an ombudsman for HMA. No
    contract or other written evidence of this agreement
    is ever produced.
     
    What did Mays do in this job? According to HMA
    medical director Francis Henderson in a state police
    interview, "Mr Mays has thus far performed his duties
    in a very capable manner. He has met with us on three
    or four occasions and has mediated in some problem
    areas we have had. He has met with inmates and worked
    out some difficulties they had in the form of
    grievances with medical treatment services."
     
    Henderson also describes his efforts to obtain a
    buyer for the plasma: "Historically this [was] the
    worst possible time to do it. I called all over the
    world and finally got one group in Canada that would
    take the contract."
     
    Corrections board chair Woodson Walker is also
    interviewed by state police. According to the
    interview notes, he states that "he had had direct
    contacts with Governor Clinton throughout the
    selection process and that the Governor was deeply
    concerned with HMA's past performance and the
    deficiencies found by both the State Health
    Department and the Arkansas State Police Investigator
    of [sic] late 1984." Asked by Clinton for his
    recommendation, Walker states that after "taking
    everything into prospective [sic] he advised the
    Governor that he had decided to go with HMA ~~~ but
    only if a safeguard in the form of an ombudsman was
    included. The ombudsman was completely my idea and
    Governor Clinton advised me that he definitely
    approved. I was asked to make several suggestions as
    to who this ombudsman might be and among others
    recommended Judge Richard Mays and Judge David Hale,
    both of Little Rock. Hale was white and Mays was
    black but races was not a major consideration in
    these recommendations. As it turned out, Judge Hale
    declined. . . "
     
    Hale would later become famous in the Whitewater
    scandal. Mays would also crop up again several times
    in the Clinton saga. A long-time Clinton supporter,
    he would gain posts both on the state supreme court
    and on the prison board. More curiously, he would
    show up as David Hale's attorney when the FBI got a
    subpoena to raid Hale's files for Whitewater
    documents -- issued on July 20, 1993, the day Vincent
    Foster died. [For yet another Mays link to Clinton,
    jump to 1994]
     
    From state police notes of an interview with former
    Cummins guard Jackie Cummings: "Jackie Cummings
    further stated that he had been dismissed from his
    job at the Cummins Unit because he had not been a
    'team player.' When asked to provide additional
    information that would help investigators look into a
    situation such as his, Cummings stated that he would
    say no further, but that he only wants to 'get my job
    back.' Cummings advised both investigators that he
    had gone to the Office of Governor Bill Clinton and
    had met with him personally and was told by Clinton
    that he could do nothing about the situation at the
    Cummins Unit because it would cause him political
    harm."
     
    Leonard Dunn, president of HMA, is interviewed by
    state police. Investigator S. R. Probasco notes that
    Dunn explained that he "was the financial portion of
    the corporation as well as the political arm. Dunn
    advised that he had been a former member of the State
    Claims commission under Governor Pryor and that he
    was close to Governor Clinton as well as the majority
    of state politicians presently in office. Mr. Dunn
    explained that he was very fond of politics and that
    he was very active.
     
    "Dunn stated to these investigators that the entire
    matter of trying to obtain a contact for HMA was
    considered to him to be part of negotiation and not
    in any form of pressure by the State Corrections
    Board or the Governor's Office. When asked
    specifically about contacts from the Governor's
    Office, Mr. Dunn stated that he did have
    conversations with both Governor Clinton and Mrs.
    Betsey Wright to assure them that HMA wanted to what
    was right. ~~~ Dunn stated that he was advised that
    the Governor's office was very concerned about
    problems HMA was having but was told to compete like
    anyone else if they wanted the penitentiary
    contract."
     
    Incidentally, Dunn is chair of a holding company that
    will later purchase two branches of Jim McDougal's
    failed Madison Guaranty Savings and Loan Association.
    He will also be named to the Arkansas Industrial
    Development Commission.
     
    JUNE 27, 1986
     
    The Institute for Law and Policy Planning, asked by
    the corrections board in March to study allegations
    of malfeasance in the prison system, presents its
    report to Governor Clinton and the board. The report
    states that that HMA has "consistently failed to
    provide the management system and medical services
    specifically called for in the contract." It also
    states that HMA and ADC "have only recently developed
    protocol and procedures for handling AIDS cases, and
    are currently developing a refined approach to AIDS
    screening and testing." Among numerous deficiencies,
    ILLP finds HMA has failed to provide the required
    number of doctor hours, the head of HMA is too
    overcommitted to give proper medical supervision, the
    enforcement of the medical contract has been
    inadequate, the program "fails to meet many
    significant professional standards," HMA has not
    followed state requirements, it has used inmates in
    prohibited medical jobs, and its record-keeping has
    been lacking."
     
    JULY 30 1986
     
    HMA is cleared of wrong-dong by the State Police.
    Prison officials are charged with just two
    misdemeanors and one felony.
     
    JULY 31, 1986
     
    The corrections board finds HMA in violation of its
    two year contract and placed on 90-day probation. The
    contract will eventually be taken over by Pine Bluffs
    Biologicals.
     
    AUGUST 1986
     
    Clinton decides not to ask AL "Art" Lockhart --
    director of the state prison system -- to resign. He
    also denies being directly involved in the renewal of
    the contract for HMA. He says he didn't talk with
    Dunn until after the decision was made to give HMA
    the contract again. All he told Dunn, Clinton claims,
    is that HMA should be willing to accept an outside
    monitor and should work to improve patient care.
     
    Rep. Glover, who has asked for Lockhart's
    resignation, says he has shown "a complete lack of
    administrative abilities." Clinton refuses to respond
    to Glover saying he should have taken the matter up
    with the Board of Corrections. He said he had "bent
    over backwards to try accommodate" Glover and accuses
    him of refusing to accept the state police
    investigation because "he had decided how it was
    suppose to come out before it was done."
     
    1987
     
    The last year improperly treated blood and plasma is
    distributed in Canada. The government provides
    compensation for harmed patients.
     
    1989
     
    The Committee of Ten Thousand -- named for the
    estimated 10,000 Americans infected with HIV by the
    blood industry -- is formed. Writing in POZ seven
    years later, COTT's president Corey Dubin says, "For
    years the manufacturers of blood products and the
    regulators at the FDA persuaded the hemophilia
    community as well as the general public that their
    infections were a 'tragic yet unavoidable mistake.'
    We now know that this is absolutely not the case and
    that doing business as usual from 1982 to 1985
    consigned thousands of people with hemophilia to the
    ravages of AIDS. ~~~ Internal drug company memos
    demonstrate that officials understood the impact that
    blood tainted by this pathogen could have on people
    with hemophilia as early as mid-1982, but they failed
    to warn either our doctors or us. The industry was
    also targeting for plasma collection groups with a
    high incidence of hepatitis B -- gay men and
    prisoners -- that the CDC had by then identified as
    likely to have AIDS."
     
    MAY 1993
     
    Two separate tainted blood probes -- one by a
    California investigator and another by the Canadian
    government -- lead to the door of the Arkansas
    governor's office, now occupied by Jim Guy Tucker.
    Both are informed that all the governor's papers were
    removed when he left office and that they should
    contact the White House legal counsel's office. What
    happens next is not known but presumably they make
    contact with Vince Foster, the man in the legal
    counsel's office who knew Arkansas and who had been
    involved in the prison system and who may, at one
    point, have represented HMA.
     
    JULY 1993
     
    Vince Foster dies under mysterious circumstances.
     
    A day or two after Foster's death, the New York Post
    will report much later, someone calls a little-known
    phone number at the White House counsel's office
    where Mr. Foster worked. "The man said he had some
    information that might be important," writes
    columnist Maggie Gallagher, who did not name her
    source or identify the official who took the call.
    "Something had upset Vince Foster greatly just days
    before he died. Something about 'tainted blood' that
    both Vince Foster and President Clinton knew about,
    this man said."
     
    1994
     
    Richard Mays, the "ombudsman" in the 1980s prison
    health scandal, crops up again, as described in a
    report from the House Government Reform and Oversight
    Committee:
     
    "Charlie Trie was first solicited to contribute to
    the DNC in connection with the June 22, 1994,
    Presidential Gala in Washington, D.C. Trie was
    solicited to give $100,000 to the DNC, even though he
    had never made any significant political
    contributions previously. No one at the DNC
    demonstrated any concern about taking $100,000 from
    an obscure Arkansas restaurateur with little apparent
    wealth. Trie was rewarded with an immediate entree
    into the world of Washington insiders and
    presidential intimates, and the DNC was rewarded with
    badly-needed campaign cash.
     
    "Trie was solicited to make his first contributions
    to the DNC by Richard Mays, a close friend of the
    President from Arkansas. Mays had been appointed to
    the Arkansas bench by Governor Clinton, and was also
    a longtime major DNC donor and fundraiser. Mays
    claims that he knew Trie from patronizing his
    restaurant in Little Rock. Mays claimed not to recall
    the exact circumstances of his solicitation of Trie,
    but did state that he 'had the distinct impression
    that [Trie] was in a position to contribute, and
    wanted to make a contribution.' Mays says he based
    his conclusion that Trie was in a 'position to
    contribute' to the DNC on the fact that Trie was
    traveling between Little Rock and Washington, D.C.:
     
    "Question: When you say "in a position to
    contribute," do you mean he had sufficient money to
    contribute?
     
    "Mays: I felt he did.
     
    "Question: And how did you get that impression?
     
    "Mays: I donít know how I got that impression, but
    frequently, he seemed like he was traveling
    extensively, you know, I knew he owned that Chinese
    restaurant down there, and he apparently had engaged
    in some business, other business interests. I really
    didnít have a specific judgment that, in fact, he
    could, but I certainly thought it was worth talking
    to him about it.
     
    ***
     
    "Question: Would you ever see him anywhere other than
    D.C. or Little Rock?
    "Mays: I donít recall that I have. I mean, I am not
    saying I havenít, but I donít recall."
     
    "Mays asked Trie what he could contribute, and Trie
    told him $100,000. Mays claims that he was not
    surprised by Trieís offer of $100,000, even though
    this was the largest contribution he had ever
    solicited. Trieís $100,000 contribution was used for
    the DNCís Health Care Campaign, which was a public
    campaign to promote the Presidentís health care
    legislative proposal.
     
    "At this point, Mays claimed he still had no concern
    that a political novice with little apparent wealth
    had pledged $100,000 to the DNC. Rather than
    conducting any background research of Trie, or
    looking into the source of Trieís funds, he
    introduced Trie to Terry McAuliffe, then the Finance
    Chairman of the DNC. Mays set up a breakfast meeting
    between McAuliffe and Trie. At this meeting, Trie
    confirmed that he would make a $100,000 contribution
    to the DNC, and asked only that he be prominently
    seated at the June 22 gala. When asked if he ever had
    a concern about the source of Trieís contributions,
    Mays responded, 'Why would I have some concern?'"
     
    1994
     
    Arkansas finally stops selling prisoner's plasma.
     
    1995
     
    Four blood company officials are convicted in Germany
    of distributing HIV tainted blood and derivatives.
    The government admits a cover-up. The former owner of
    a plasma testing lab goes on trial for murder in the
    deaths of three people treated with AIDS-tainted
    blood products.
     
    1996
     
    Japan, which has never discarded its contaminated
    blood and plasma, criminally charges a pharmaceutical
    company and a government adviser for the distribution
    of tainted blood matter.
     
    1999
     
    "This I know. Without the governor's support and
    protection, this disease-ridden system would have
    been shut down by 1922" -- Mike Galster to Suzi
    Parker
     
    ====================================================
     
    To unsubscribe, send message
    with the word 'unsubscribe.'
     
    Copyright 1999, The Progressive Review. Matter not
    independently copyrighted may be reprinted provided
    you pay TPR your normal reprint fees, if any, and
    give proper credit.
     
    SEARCH TOOL: Our new search tool permits you to find
    quickly what you've looking for in our 600,000 word
    news archives: http://prorev.com
     
    TO POST MESSAGES & NEWS ON OUR FORUM:
    http://dejanews.com/~prorev
     
    CHAT ROOM:
    http://www.dejanews.com/~prorev/[ST_rn=md]/chat.xp?j=prorev
     
     
     
    THE PROGRESSIVE REVIEW
    1739 Connecticut Ave NW
    Washington DC 20009
    202-232-5544
    202-234-6222 Fax
    ssmith@igc.org
    Editor: Sam Smith
    WEBSITE: http://prorev.com
    READERS' FORUM: http://dejanews.com/~prorev
    CHAT ROOM: http://www.dejanews.com/~prorev/[ST_rn=md]/chat.xp?j=prorev
     
    For a free trial subscription to both our bi-monthly hard copy edition
    and our regular e-mail updates send e-mail and terrestial address
    to ssmith@igc.org
     
    To order "Sam Smith's Great American Political Repair Manual"
    (WW Norton) direct from Amazon.com:
    http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ISBN=0393316270/progressiverevieA/
     
    UNDERNEWS
    By Sam Smith
    February 18, 1999
     
    The Progressive Review
    1739 Conn. Ave. NW Washington DC 20009
    202-232-5544 Fax: 202- 234-6222
    editor@prorev.com
    http://prorev.com
     
    For a free trial subscription to our hard
    copy edition and e-mail updates send your
    postal address with zip code
    ====================================================

    37 Posted on 11/16/1999 05:40:06 PST by Mia T
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 36 | Top | Last ]


    To: Mia T

    Thanks Mia! Bump and a DRIP!

    38 Posted on 11/16/1999 08:51:25 PST by Askel5
    [ Reply | Private Reply | To 37 | Top | Last ]

    Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

    [ Top | Latest Posts | Latest Articles | Self Search | Add Bookmark | Post | Abuse | Help! ]

    FreeRepublic , LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
    Forum Version 2.0a Copyright © 1999 Free Republic, LLC