Skip to comments.
Best of both worlds? (New hybrid home/private school education model)
World Magazine ^
| 09/08/2001 (Issue date)
| Leah Driggers and Lynn Vincent
Posted on 09/06/2001 9:10:48 AM PDT by Constitutionalist Conservative
Add to the three dueling educational modelspublic, private, home schoolsa fourth: the campus/home school hybrid.
At one such school, Grace Preparatory Academy in Arlington, Texas, students spend two to three days at schooldepending on their grade leveland the other days learning at home. The model combines rigorous academics with heavy parental participation in a K-12 setting. Ideally, parents tutor heavily in the early grades, but back off in high-school years in an effort to produce self-governed seniors.
Administrators say the model is right for parents who don't want to homeschool full-time, parents who don't feel comfortable teaching advanced subjects, and parents who can't afford full-time private tuition: "It's the best of both worlds," said Bob Van Wieren of Christian Schools International.
Michael Sneed, 18, is a tall, dark-haired chess tournament champ who was home-schooled through the 10th grade, along with most of his eight siblings. Then, he spent his junior and senior high-school years at Grace Preparatory Academy, which was founded in 1993 with 186 students (it now boasts 600 students, with 700 more families waiting for an open class in the two-story brick building set off I-20). Michael entered the University of Houston this fall to study architecture on a full, five-year academic scholarship. Out of his graduating class of 45, he was one of three National Merit Scholarship finalists.
Grace's outreach director Barbara Van Wart just finished the 5th annual national workshop for those interested in starting new institutions on the Grace model; between workshops, she fields about 40 calls each month from people seeking information about the model, which Grace calls the "University Model School."
Ten UMS campuses will offer classes during the 2001-02 school year; all are Christian and three are brand new. Parents will pay about half of what a full-time private school would costaverage tuition for a high-school student, for example, is about $3,000 a year.
Private-school parents nervous about homeschooling, but who want more involvement in their kids' education, are among those willing to try hybrids. "They like the structure, accountability, lesson plans, progress reports, and report cards," said Margi McCombs, principal of The Community School in Winter Park, Fla., the CSI member school that is working toward CSI accreditation. The Community School mirrors the UMS model, but requires even more parental involvement: Parents must attend monthly meetings, and assist in their children's classroom for two weeks every semester.
The arrangement suits Patti Reynolds, who pulled her blue-eyed son Jerrod, 9, from a Christian school two years ago. Jerrod would come home from his 22-child private-school classroom exhausted and crying. "Kids would hit each other and yell at the teacher," remembers Mrs. Reynolds. "Jerrod would say, 'I don't wanna go back there.'" Mrs. Reynolds hunted for a new school, but was disillusioned with long hours and high student-teacher ratios. And she found home school intimidating: "I was scared to death to do it all by myself."
The Community School turned out to be her perfect solution: Two days each week, Jerrod learns in the school's formal classroom setting where the teacher-student ratio is 16 to one. The other three days, Mrs. Reynolds teaches Jerrod at home. He plays on the school's basketball team and "is excited about learning," smiled Mrs. Reynolds. "He's a totally different boy."
Most UMS students are junior high-age or older. About half have been homeschooled since kindergarten, but their parents have become overwhelmed or feel uncomfortable teaching advanced subjects like algebra or a foreign language. Many homeschoolers come to UMS institutions for college preparation. The schools offer class rankings, grade point averages, and extracurricular activities such as drama, band, student council, yearbook staff, Fellowship of Christian Athletes, and debate. Instead of a prefab six- or seven-hour school day, classes in university-model schools are scheduled like those in a college environment. Students must learn to balance class time, study, and outside activities.
So far, many seem to be doing a good job of it. For the past eight years, Grace graduates have boasted a 3.38 GPA after their first college semester. Hybrids are "not for everyone," said Barbara Van Wart. "But at least now we're offering a fourth option that is proving successful."
TOPICS: Culture/Society; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS:
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-39 next last
To: summer
bump
To: Ben Ficklin
Facinating read, Ben Ficklin. Thanks so very much for the flag on this article. Best, summer :)
3
posted on
09/06/2001 10:12:18 AM PDT
by
summer
To: Constitutionalist Conservative
God bless 'em.
To: Constitutionalist Conservative
no matter which of the three parents choose, (home school, private school, or hybrid) it is obviously 3000 times better than any public (govmint) scrool....
To: Ben Ficklin
Ben, such a fascinating article that I bookmarked it for other people to see as well. Best, summer :)
6
posted on
09/06/2001 10:27:04 AM PDT
by
summer
To: Ben Ficklin
PS Ben, I just want to make my position clear, in case someone does wander over to my bookmarks and find this article.
As you know, Ben, I am an independent voter now -- I had been a Dem voter all my life; and, I am a FL certified teacher. I taught in an inner city public school here in FL and I've taught elsewhere as well.
My view about public school is this: I know some people on this forum are against all public schools, but I am VERY much FOR public schools, and, other people on this forum are ALSO FOR PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
However, in ADDITION to public schools, I believe there is a PLACE for ANY KIND OF EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT if such environment does this: HELPS THE STUDENT TO LEARN.
Consequently, I believe the GREENS have it RIGHT because they BELIEVE IN A VARIETY OF EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENTS.
And, I believe that our most intelligent GOP leaders, like Gov. Jeb Bush here in FL, and his EDUCATOR Lt. Gov. Frank Brogan ALSO have it right: WHATEVER WORKS; DO IT -- AND, YES, LET'S ALWAYS SUPPORT OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS AS WELL.
But, the Dems have it ALL WRONG. The not so bright DIM DEM LEADERSHIP SAY: NO HOMESCHOOLING; NEVER. NONE OF THIS "HYBRID" STUFF. NIX THE PRIVATE COMPANIES LIKE EDISON.
And, I say to those Dim Dem Leaders: GET OUT OF YOUR CAVE AND INTO THE 21ST CENTURY -- OR ELSE THE REST OF YOUR BASE WILL BE LEAVING YOU TOO.
Ben, Thanks for allowing me to rant!
Best, summer :)
7
posted on
09/06/2001 10:33:06 AM PDT
by
summer
To: Constitutionalist Conservative
Wonder how the unions will try to wreck this model.
8
posted on
09/06/2001 10:33:31 AM PDT
by
LarryLied
To: summer
and find this article. = and should find this article.
9
posted on
09/06/2001 10:34:46 AM PDT
by
summer
To: summer
and find this article. = and should find this article.
10
posted on
09/06/2001 10:35:12 AM PDT
by
summer
To: Constitutionalist Conservative
Anyone who believes the Green Party is anything but totalitarianism with a happy face should check out their party platfrom:
http://www.gp.org/platform/gpp2000.html
These people should never be allowed near a child much less have any say in how parents educate their children.
To: all
BTW, I may have appeared to characterize the current FL leadership as being FOR everything else in education and public schools having "2nd place" in the below quote.
BUT -- ACTUALLY -- in FL: these GOP leaders-- Gov. Jeb Bush and Lt. Gov. Frank Brogan -- care about PUBLIC SCHOOLS IN A BIG WAY. A VERY BIG WAY.
In addition, I ALSO believe: they WILL ALWAYS support the RIGHT OF A PARENT TO HOMESCHOOLING and SUPPORT ANY OTHER TYPE OF EDUCATIONAL ENVIROMENT THAT WORKS FOR THAT CHILD.
IMO -- They may as well be GREEN on education in this respect.
Consequently, the "ordering" of my examples of educational environments below -- "WHATEVER" and "PUBLIC SCHOOLS" -- may be changed by the reader, with the full support of FL GOP leaders, to suit whatever environment A PARENT DECIDES IS BEST FOR THAT CHILD:
"And, I believe that our most intelligent GOP leaders, like Gov. Jeb Bush here in FL, and his EDUCATOR Lt. Gov. Frank Brogan ALSO have it right: WHATEVER WORKS; DO IT -- AND, YES, LET'S ALWAYS SUPPORT OUR PUBLIC SCHOOLS AS WELL."
12
posted on
09/06/2001 10:43:05 AM PDT
by
summer
To: summer
My view about public school is this: I know some people on this forum are against all public schools, but I am VERY much FOR public schools, and, other people on this forum are ALSO FOR PUBLIC SCHOOLS. Whatever kind of schools you favor, if you are in favor of forcing people to pay for a school even if they don't use it, you are for THEFT. And theft is ALWAYS a crime.
To: Arthur McGowan
Whatever kind of schools you favor, if you are in favor of forcing people to pay for a school even if they don't use it, you are for THEFT. And theft is ALWAYS a crime. I really don't follow your argument. Government has always provided services which it deems necessary for the common good. And I can't think of anything more important at present than education in providing for the common good. I wonder how a Catholic justifies divorcing the concept of the common good from public policy.
FWIW, I do not support public education as it exists today; but I see nothing wrong (or unconstitutional) about using non-federal taxpayer dollars to fund education vouchers.
To: Constitutionalist Conservative
I've heard these schools are also called co-op schools or cottage schools. The government education monopoly is starting to crumble. There is an article in today's NY Times about a new public high school in NYC that starts kids off in college in the 11th grade. Apparently, a lot of kids feel that their time in high school is a waste, especially the last two years. More power to people who homeschool or have the initiative to implement new ways for kids to get an education.
15
posted on
09/06/2001 11:32:45 AM PDT
by
bettina0
To: independentmind
Dear independentmind,
RE: your post # 14
A HUGE BTTT for what you said in reply to:
"Arthur" Mcwhatever his name is.
(I will not attempt to give his actual screen name, because though I would prefer to do that I also know:
If unintentionally misspell it, there are people on this forum who will NOT hesitate to publicly and privately JUMP DOWN MY THROAT for a mistake in my typing.)
On a much happier note, as there ARE many wonderful people on this forum:
It is so good to meet you, independentmind. I see you have been on this forum for a few months now.
If you should ever have the time, please, do not hesitate to privately freepmail me for a friendly chat -- with me, another independent mind.
Also, note: Even though several people here have been rudely and persistently making public slanderous comments in recent days against me on this board, wrongly and falsely claiming I am a "GOP Operative," in fact:
I do NOT work for the GOP, nor any political party, nor Jeb Bush; nor do I wish to solicit you for a campaign contribution; nor do I have any rally to invite you to attend.
I only seek to say "hello" to another independent mind. And, maybe, who knows -- maybe I have a funny joke for you. But, it's been a rough week for me here. I'll try to find a good joke we can share!
Take care, until we meet again,
With love and peace,
summer :)
16
posted on
09/06/2001 1:10:47 PM PDT
by
summer
To: all, mafree, independentmind
Another BTTT for post #14 from "independentmind".
--------
Hi mafree,
I wanted to introduce you to the wonderful poster named "independentmind" just so this poster KNOWS there ARE in fact other INDEPENDENT voters here on FR. Who knows, maybe independentmind will click on your screen name and check out your cool profile page and read all about you, because I believe you are one of the MOST interesting posters on this, or any forum, in my own personal and humble opinion -- which, BTW, I am entitled to have to all you posters who think I am not allowed to have my OWN opinion.
------------
Hi independentmind -- meet my friend, mafree, another independent person....
17
posted on
09/06/2001 1:18:08 PM PDT
by
summer
To: Constitutionalist Conservative
Great post. Hadn't heard of this effort. Sounds very intriguing. Or should I say 'risky'?
18
posted on
09/06/2001 2:00:28 PM PDT
by
BigTime
To: Constitutionalist Conservative
How about the one-room schoolhouse idea? One trusted teacher working with a few students of all ages. Kids get homeschool-like attention and quality, and get exposed to a range of ages and see what others are learning - as opposed to public school students locked into single-age single-topic boxes, rarely interacting with other ages or seeing what's next.
To: summer, independentmind
Hi summer- you're always so nice. Thanks for the compliments and yes, I've seen some of independentmind's posts before. There are so many independent voters on FR- maybe it'd be nice to start a thread where they all can stand up and be counted.
20
posted on
09/06/2001 2:35:13 PM PDT
by
mafree
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-39 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson