Posted on 09/12/2001 4:05:30 AM PDT by Israel
As Americans struggle to absorb the horror resulting from this morning’s unprecedented attacks upon our nation, it is vitally important that we keep in mind several key principles. One of the most important is contained in Alexander Hamilton’s warning that war or the threat of war
“will compel nations the most attached to liberty to resort for repose and security to institutions which have a tendency to destroy their civil and political rights. To be more safe, they at length are willing to run the risk of being less free.”Hamilton’s words have an eerie resonance now that fighter planes are orbiting New York City and Washington, D.C., and armed guards are patrolling the evacuated White House. The carefully orchestrated terrorist attack, in which civilian jetliners were converted into weapons of mass destruction and aimed at the symbols of our nation’s financial and military power, was perfectly calibrated to rupture America’s sense of security. In the immediate aftermath of the attacks, prominent voices in the Establishment’s opinion-molding class took up the refrain that new impositions upon liberty will be necessary in order to win the war against international terrorism.
Senator John McCain (R-Az.), who correctly described the attack as “an act of war,” told Judy Woodruff of CNN, “our lifestyles won’t be the same for a long time.” NBC News Anchor Tom Brokaw’s assessment was even more pointed: “We will have to revisit many of our freedoms as a result of this attack.” Former Defense Secretary William Cohen has stated that because of the attacks Americans will be forced to make “choices between security and civil liberties.” British Prime Minister Tony Blair has urged that the world’s democracies “join together” in a global war upon terrorism. Other figures, including former federal government officials, have insisted that we are living in a “new day” and that dramatic changes may have to be made in our society’s governing institutions and principles.
Obviously, those responsible for the atrocious crimes committed on September 11, 2001 must be found and punished, and this should be done through our existing constitutional system.
If this crime has been carried out by a foreign power, or coalition of foreign powers, a declaration of war would be an appropriate (if tragic) response. If the attack was perpetrated by a quasi-state terrorist network, such as that operated by Osama bin Laden, the Constitution provides the means to respond: Congress has the authority to “define and punish” such crimes as piracy and terrorism, and to grant “letters of marque and reprisal” against the likes of bin Laden – should he or his associates bear the responsibility for these attacks.
Why review such arcane matters at a time like this? It is important to recognize right away that the attack upon our nation provides neither the need nor the justification for the use of extra-constitutional measures.
While heightened vigilance would be wise, we cannot allow our country to become a garrison state. Although it may be necessary to cooperate with friendly governments, there is no reason to believe that new entangling alliances are necessary. In fact, this morning’s terrorist attack illustrates, to tragic effect, some of the deadly consequences of our government’s insistence upon becoming entangled in the wars and conflicts of other nations.
All Americans worthy of the name will support timely, constitutionally sound actions to protect our nation and punish this despicable act of mass murder. But Americans also have a duty to demand answers from our leaders about some very important questions:
“Fears about the military’s role in domestic affairs are unfounded,” Cohen soothingly wrote. “There need be no fear or foreboding by the American people of the preparations of their government. On the contrary, the greater threat to our civil liberties stems from the chaos and carnage that might result from an attack for which we had failed to prepare and the demands for action that would follow.”The approach recommended by Cohen, ironically, complements very well the classic strategy pursued by terrorists. Marxist militant Carlos Marighella, whose tactical blueprint has been followed by terrorists worldwide, explained that terrorists attack innocent people in order to provoke governments
"to intensify repression. The police roundups, house searches, arrests of innocent people, make life unbearable.... Rejecting the 'so-called political solution,' the urban guerrilla must become more aggressive and violent, resorting without letup to sabotage, terrorism, expropriations, assaults, kidnappings, and executions, heightening the disastrous situation in which the government must act."Marighella went on to explain how this cycle continues until the existing political order is completely subverted, and a revolutionary regime takes power.
The gravest danger presented by today’s terrorist attacks is that the effort to find and punish perpetrators will become a war upon the liberties of the American people. Yes, those responsible for the attacks must be found and punished with pitiless severity. But at the same time Americans must demand an immediate end to our interventionist foreign policy, which exacted such a tragic price in American blood on this terrible day.
Here is the word of the Lord from Jerusalem for today. Pay attention.
States will have to constantly enlarge their police force, yet terrorism will continue to hit rich and poor alike. Every third citizen will have to become a policeman in order to protect the people and their homes.At every intersection there will have to be security guards checking bags and clothes to make sure
that no one is carrying a bomb or various poisons.The democratic states will be unable to continue living lives of freedom and prosperity, as people will, out of necessity, give their support to various dictators who will promise security for their lives and property.
By then it will be too late – they will lose their freedom, but they will not gain security.
Then, instead of “Torah will go forth from Zion, the word of God from Jerusalem,” terror, murder and mourning will go forth from Palestine.
All of this will come to pass because the Western leaders failed to distinguish between the righteous and the evil in the Israeli struggle against the Palestinian Authority.
Because we have virtually zero human intelligence inside the various PLO splinter groups. Neither do the Isrealis, and they've been fighting them longer.
Actually, victim compliance "worked" pretty well up to yesterday. This was the first airplane suicide bombing attack ever. It is unrealistic to expect anyone to have implemented strategies to defent against an attack that had never happened.
It's a lot like Columbine. Previous to the attack on the school, doctrine (which had always worked reasonably well with attackers who wanted to get attention or negotiate) was to pull back, stabilize the situation and work from there as a way of minimizing fatalities. Such an approach was obviously totally counter-productive with attackers whose goal was to kill as many as possible. Doctrine on dealing with public building invasions has changed as a result.
Victim compliance on airliners died yesterday. The terrorists killed it.
(Actually, the term "victim compliance" is redundant. Those who die fighting back may be just as dead, but they are not victims.)
William Norman Grigg hits the nail squarely on the head once again.
This is very nearly treasonous. To implement it is treason. Never must Americans live under Martial Law. It contradicts our very existence as free people.
There are three very critical elements needed for Martial Law, and utter, complete totalitarianism.
1. Citizens are banned from owning weapons.
2. Military is used as domestic law enforcement.
3. The civil authority becomes subservient to the military authority.
Once #1 and #2 are in place, #3 become possible, maybe even inevitable. If we aren't VERY careful #1 and #2 are very likely to occur. This must be fought!!! This must NEVER happen!!! .
Even if you make a case that we saved a couple of hundred lives, the 10,000 we lost on the 11th make a complete mockery of it. By the way, I think we are pretty much in agreement.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.