Posted on 09/30/2001 2:16:08 PM PDT by Thoeting
Nightmare at Noon
Stephen St.Vincent Benet
There are no trenches dug in the park, not yet.
There are no soldiers falling out of the sky.
It's a fine clear day in the park. It is bright and hot.
The trees are in full, green, summer-heavy leaf.
An airplane drones overhead, but no one's afraid.
There's no reason to be afraid, in a fine big city
That was not built for war. There is time and time.
There was time in Norway and the thing fell.
When they woke, they saw the planes with the black crosses.
When they woke, they heard the guns rolling in the street.
They could not believe it at first. It was hard to believe.
They had been friendly and thriving and inventive.
They had had good arts, decent living, peace for years.
Those were not enough it seems.
There were people there, who wrote books and painted pictures,
Worked, came home tired, like to be left alone.
They made fun of the would-be Caesars who howled and foamed.
That was not enough it seems. It was not enough.
When they woke, they saw the planes with the black crosses.
There is grass in the park. There are children on the long meadow
Watched by some hot, peaceful nuns. Where the ducks are fed
There are black children and white and the anxious teachers
Who keep counting them like chickens. It's quite a job
To take care of so many school kids in the park.
But when they've eaten their picnic, they'll go home.
(And they could have better homes, in a richer city.)
But they won't be sent to Kansas, or Michigan
At twenty-four hours notice.
Dazed, bewildered, clutching their broken toys,
Hundreds on hundreds filling the blacked-out trains,
Just to keep them safe, just so they may live, not die.
Just so there's one chance that they may not die, but live
That does not enter our thoughts. There is plenty of time.
In Holland, one hears, some children were less lucky.
It was hard to send them anywhere in Holland.
It is a small country, you see. The thing happened quickly.
The bombs from the sky are quite indifferent to children.
The machine guns do not distinguish. In Rotterdam
One quarter of the city was blown to bits.
That included naturally, ordinary buildings
With the usual furnishings such as cats and children.
It was an old peaceful city, Rotterdam,
Clean, tidy, full of flowers,
But that was not enough it seems
It was not enough to keep the children safe.
It was ended in a weak, and freedom ended.
There is no air raid siren yet, in the park.
All the glass still stands in the windows around the park.
The man on the bench is reading a Yiddish paper.
He will not be shot because of that, oddly enough.
He will not even be beaten or imprisoned.
Not yet, not yet.
You can be a Finn or a Dane, and an American
You can be a German or French, and an American.
Jew, Bohunk, Nigger, Mick--all the dirty names
We call each other--and yet an American.
We've stuck to that for quite a while.
Go into Joe's Diner and try to tell the truckers
You belong to a master race and you'll get a laugh.
What's that brother? Double-talk?
I'm a stranger here myself, but it's a free country.
It's a free country . . .
Oh yes, I know the faults and the other side.
The lyncher's rope, the bought justice, the wasted land,
The scale on the leaf, the borers in the corn.
The finks with their clubs, the gray sky of relief,
All the long shame of our hearts and the long disunion.
I am merely remarking--as a country, we try.
As a country, I think we try.
They tried in Spain, but the tanks and the planes won out.
They fought very well and long.
They fought to be free but it seems it was not enough.
They did not have the equipment, so they lost.
They tried in Finland, the resistance was shrewd,
Skillful, intelligent, waged by a free folk.
They tired in Greece, and they threw them back for a while.
By the soul and spirit and passion of common man.
Call the roll of the Fourteen Nations. Call the roll
Of the blacked-out lands, the lands that used to be free.
But do not call it loud. There is plenty of time,
There is plenty of time while the bombs London fall
And turn the world to wind and water and fire.
There is time to sleep while the fire-bombs fall on London.
They are stubborn people in London.
We are slow to wake, good-natured as a country,
(It's our fault and our virtue) We like to raise a
Man to the highest power and then throw rocks on him
We don't like war and we like to speak our minds.
We're used to speaking our minds.
There are certain words,
Our own and other's we're used to--words we've used,
Heard, had to recite, forgotten,
Rubbed shiny in the pocket, left home for keepsakes,
Inherited, stuck away in the back drawer,
In the locked trunk at the back of the quiet mind.
Liberty, equality, fraternity.
To none will we sell, refuse or deny, right or justice,
We hold these truths to be self-evident.
I am merely saying, what if these words pass?
What if they pass and are gone and are no more?
Eviscerated, blotted out of the world?
We're used to them, so used that we half-forget,
The way you forget the looks of your own home
And yet you can walk around it in the darkness.
You can't put a price on sunlight or the air
You can't put a price on these, so they must be easy.
They were bought with belief and passion, at great cost.
They were bought with the bitter and anonymous blood
Of farmers, teacher, shoemakers and fools
Who broke the old rule and the pride of kings
And some that never saw the end and many that were weary
Some doubtful, many confused.
They were bought by the ragged boys at Valmy Hill,
The yokels at Lexington with the long light guns.
And the dry, New England faces,
The iron barons, writing a charter out
For their own iron advantage, not the people
And yet the people got it into their hands
And marked it with their sweat.
It took a long time to buy these words
It took a long time to buy them, and much pain.
Thence fore and forever free
Thence fore and forever free.
No man may be bound or fined or slain till he has been judged by his peers.
To form a more perfect union.
The others have their words too, and strong words,
Strong as the tanks, explosive as the bombs.
The State is all, worship the State!
The Leader is all, worship the Leader!
Strength is all, worship Strength!
Worship, bow down, or die!
I shall go back through the park to my safe house,
This is not London or Paris,
This is the high, bright city, the lucky place,
The place that always had time.
The boys in their shirtsleeves, the high flowering girls.
The bicycle rider, the kids with the model planes,
The tough kids, squirting water at the fountains,
Whistled at by the cop.
The dopes that write, "Jimmy's a dope" on the tunnel walls.
These are all quite safe and nothing will happen to them,
Nothing will happen to them...of course.
Go tell the brokers story about the President.
Whatever it is, that's going to help a lot.
There is plenty of time--plenty of time.
Go tell the fire, it only burns in another country.
Go tell the bombers, this is the wrong address,
The hurricane to pass on the other side.
Go tell the earthquake, it must not shake our ground.
The bell has rung in the night, and the air quakes with it.
I shall not sleep when I hear the planes tonight.
I hope you enjoy it and find something worthwhile to think about.
It does seem rather like 1939, doesn't it? And the attitudes are much the same.
In other words, they gave peace a chance.
All they did was save Hitler some time huh?
I memorized this poem in college for a performance over 20 years ago. I still can't read it without crying
The poem seems to me to be both a praise of America and a criticism of its willful ignorance. We are in the Phoney War period right now. Next comes the Blitz.
We will all see what we are made of.
I fear the message will be lost on the "Give Peace a Chance" crowd because they know nothing of Norway, WWII or history in general. Sad.
America has been through this before - we did not fail then. We will not fail now.
2. The poem was actually written in June 1940, at the time of the fall of France. Several lines were added (about London and Greece), probably in 1941.
3. The posts about Norway are unfair. Read Churchill's "The Second World War" on the Norwegian resistence, aided by the British, around the Northern fijords, ports and mountain areas. That lasted several months, under very adverse odds.
4. Benet wrote all sorts of wonderful patriotic stuff -- "We Stand United" and other radio plays; A "propoganda" book called "America" a 100-page history to be printed in madd quantities and given away in mass quantities in Europe in 1943-45. And, of course, the epic poem "John Brown's Body,"
If the folks who from time to time re-fight the Civil War on FR would read and digest the poem, they would have a lot better understanding of the slavery v. defense of home; hate v.heritage; Lincoln as satan and other ideas thrown about way too casually.
Let's especially not forget the single bravest and most important resistance action of the whole war: the Norwegian destruction of the heavy-water plant at Vermork.
-ccm
The poem was indeed written in June 1940, but published a little later. I was referring to the published date
And yes the Norwegian's posted a quite vigorous defense, but, it should be noted, the GOVERNMENT did not. They gave up to Germany without a whimper, thinking that they could appease Hitler.
However, being a poem, rather than a historical essay, it is still quite moving--and relevant to today, that is why I spent almost an hour transcribing it from old college notes and posting it.
Glad it was enjoyed
I wonder sometimes if I'm prone to paranoia or am simply paying attention. I remember many situations where I may have been close to 'in the know' on a press worthy event. Those where I could corroborate whether the press reports were hype, to what order of magnitude they were hype, how to place them in appropriate level of urgency with respect to other events, fed me criteria to recognize that If one wanted to know what was really happening, then don't ever listen to the news.
In other situations the news seemed more reportive. A clearinghouse for the most up to date and pertinent information about influential events about us worthy our attention.
Today I observe the most rigorously competitive news organizations, which hold an oligopoly in a vainglorious industry play news reruns on cable TV. This occurring where no shortage for fameseeking players exists and a cast of thousands stand in the wings for even a hint of an opportunity to announce a news report in any forum. Where even Senators and Representatives are treated as mere errand boys touting a personal belief on dedicated topics, yet still these magnates of news industry are unable to solicit the machinery to produce more news than a repetitive rerun.
I now wonder. Is how perception of the magnitude of terror been ever established beyond the obvious WTC and periodic news story reports?
Is this an isolated event, which could have occurred anytime in the last 40 years, or is this merely the tip of an iceburg which we still have not even considered donning a life preserver?
My confidence in our institutions fades moreso when I consider these institutions lack the ability to produce news 24 hrs/day or even consider ever showing a rerun. What's wrong with this picture? Is it simply a reasonable display or are these indicative of the actual picture?
I wonder.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.