Posted on 12/15/2001 11:48:30 AM PST by Clint Williams
Longing for Christmases with 'real' family
by Judith Conklin-Craddock
My heart travels back to painful Christmases beginning in 1953 when I was taken prisoner in Portland.
My crimes? Having alcoholic parents. I was sentenced to a nine-year term of so-called protection by the foster-care system.
Nine Christmases spent trying to not miss my family turned me into a ghost of a child -- haunted by the specter of Christmas spirit while inwardly aching for those I loved most dearly. I hung ornaments on strangers' trees, while thinking of the decorations I had grown to love at home. I wondered if my mother and father, aunts, uncles and cousins thought of me during their holiday family gathering.
On my second Christmas away from home I was invited to a benefit for needy kids that was held at one of the downtown theaters. I was 10, but don't remember much of the festivities. I do remember that Santa did not bring what I wanted most: a chance to go home.
I can still see the eyes of some of the other children -- there were perhaps 300 of us -- and I still wonder, as I did then, if they missed their families as much as I did.
Some Christmases I received presents from my parents, though I was not allowed to visit with them. So that I wouldn't be sent to my bedroom to be alone, I learned not to cry for my mother. My need to be with people was particularly strong then, of course, even if it meant pretending that my foster family was real.
One Christmas I saved all my money to buy a special gift for my foster mother. It was a beautiful miniature bird bath with tiny pure white birds sitting on its rim. I had hoped it would make her love me. Instead she continued to belittle and physically abuse me.
There were two Christmases when I had to try even harder to pretend that everything was fine. One was the morning when Santa arrived while I was being molested by a foster brother, who at 16 was five years older than me. He said I would be punished if I told. I knew he was right. Like a good girl, I kept quiet so no one could guess my guilty secret. At night I asked God to make it stop.
The next Christmas there was one more secret: a foster grandfather was "loving" me, too. His abuse had started during vacation the previous summer when I had visited his home. He resumed tormenting me during his holiday visit.
We both knew there were no Christmas angels to rescue me, because his daughter, my foster mother, had condemned me as "evil" when she discovered the first molestation. No one would believe me if I told of his violation. Even worse, I would again be called a whore.
There were, certainly, some holidays in caring foster homes. The adults there tried hard to make me a part of their family. I appreciated their kindness, but none could fix my broken heart. Like a litany, I silently repeated, "I want to go home! I want to go home! I want to go home!"
That was my heart's song every breathing moment of my young life. Even when the reality of the problems in my family became clear. When I turned 16, I was allowed to spend a Christmas vacation with my mother.
Sadly, the shadow of separation the day after Christmas lay so heavily on us that my mother needed "one little drink." That little drink led to so many that she couldn't find the bathroom and urinated on the front porch.
I called my foster mother to get me, unwilling to explain why. Though I was sick at heart at my mother's behavior, I still hoped that someone would help us get well so I could go home.
I opened my gifts in the foster home that night, struggling once again to smile, then excused myself to cry in my room for all that was lost. For the millionth time I prayed for a miracle, "God, please let my family be together." Despite seven years of forced protection, I could not reconcile myself to being kept from my heart-source. I still wanted my own safe and secure place with my loved ones.
I never got my wish. I still endure a recurring nightmare about the cold and gray afternoon when I was taken away from my mother., I recall my mother sadly walking to the bus stop alone. I see her as if it were yesterday, through the caseworker's blurred car window, the raindrops crying tears I was afraid to shed.
This story is not mine alone. So many people continue to see foster care as a humane way to protect children in jeopardy. I believe, even in the best of homes, foster care takes away children's rights, puts them into prison and steals from them a piece of their very life.
When will people understanmd that children need, above all, to be with their loved ones? When will we provide options where damaged children and their families can be kept together, taught social and emotional skills and awarded real family value?
Merry Christmas, dear vulnerable children.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright 1993, by Judith Conklin-Craddock
I called my foster mother to get me, unwilling to explain why. Though I was sick at heart at my mother's behavior, I still hoped that someone would help us get well so I could go home.
Sadly, her mother chose alcohol rather than her child, and had made this choice all of this child's life.
There was nothing inevitable about it. And her
biological parents were unfit for the job. Don't
allow the perfect to drive out the good.
A record of abuses in Wenatchee
The town of Wenatchee, Wash., made world headlines in 1994 and 1995 when police and state social workers undertook what was then called the nation's most extensive child sex-abuse investigation.
By the time it was done, at least 60 adults were arrested on 29,726 charges of child-sex abuse involving 43 children. Many of the accused were poor or developmentally disabled. Many cases were settled on the strength of confessions taken down by Wenatchee police Detective Bob Perez.
In February 1998, the Post-Intelligencer published a series of articles that documented overzealous -- and even abusive -- actions by Perez and social service caseworkers, civil rights violations by judges and prosecutors as well as sloppy work by public defenders.
Since then, many of the convicted have been freed by higher courts, largely through the work of The Innocence Project, a group of volunteer lawyers.
More HERE.
But, that officialdom abused their power still does not mean that children should not be protected from evil people.
Agreed. But never believe for an instant that those appointed (anointed) by the government do not count in their ranks evil people. The rate of abuse (sexual, physical, psychological) in foster homes is substantially higher than in the average home. The child is not somehow suddenly "safe" for being in foster care -- those who are really abused MAY be safer in the foster home, but the victims of false accusations (and the children are the _real_ victims of such) are much LESS safe there.
So true. My wifes little sister was put in foster homes when she was 9 because the do gooders said my wife and I were too young to care for her. This was in 1958 and she still struggles today dispite a good marriage and children.
This poor child had a fantasy of Christmas at home. the truth is she was probably far safer in that awful abusive home than she would have been with her natural mom.
I worked in that field for years....moms drunk friends take turns with the kids..some times mom joins in..there is no tree and no gifts .One young man I know tried to hang himself Christmas eve.
I do not like the system eithor..but sometimes as bad as it is it beats the "natural" family
I was a case manager for welfare recipients in public housing. We were tasked with really getting to know our participants and providing comprehensive case management to help get their lives together so that they could become self-sufficient outside of subsidized housing.
Observations - sortof a laundry list:
These folks don't have any idea what normal is. Welfare, CPS, jail, foster, these are all things that "everyone" has to deal with.
Many welfare recipients are foster parents. The couple hundred bucks they get per child per month is a lot of money to them. And though most have good intentions of helping a kid or two, their own lives are screwed up. (see above)
Many welfare recipients who go to college become social workers. They looked at me and decided that was the profession they wanted to be in. Partially because they had opinions about the way the "system" worked because they had been screwed once or twice. But mostly because I was the only profession they had aver been exposed to, and it is hard to visualize being something one has never seen. They have had exposure to convenience store work and social workers and that is it. True there are exceptions to that rule. I was one. But I looked around me, and all of my coworkers and my boss grew up on welfare.
The side-effect of the above phenomenon is that much of the social work is done by people who grew up in pretty abnormal (I loathe dysfunctional, but it fits here) circumstances, and lacked the skills to live independent of the social service network themselves. So worse than the blind leading the blind, critical decisions about how to "fix" other people's lives are being made by former "broken people" who were themselves up to their eyeballs in their own problems until someone helped them go to college and get a job.
Fodder for thought anyway, for now.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.