AR,
Will Smith wasn't the worst answer she could have given. So far as I know all you say about him is true.
But I'd argue....well if you could PICK a man to be...and I think the question was to be this chosen MAN for a short period of time....how about the pope? How about Tony Blair?
Will Smith?
Still, it wasn't the worst answer she could have given. If she'd have said Bill Clinton I'd have passed out cold.
Giving an answer that comes across as too religious or political answer is risky in a contest like this. You have to remember, the judges were people like Jerry Springer. Most of the judges would have rejected her if she gave a response like a pro-war person like Blair or a religious answer like the Pope. It is a contest.