Skip to comments.Racially diverse emojis are missing the entire point
Posted on 02/24/2015 6:20:33 AM PST by rickmichaels
Theyre here, some say, at last: Emojis, those universally coded images that punctuate your text messages and social media comments or serve as symbolic stand-ins for feelings best expressed, say, by Ghost With Tongue Sticking Out or Women With Bunny Ears, will finally reflect racial realities. According to many reports, Apple has rolled out five new shades of old emoji for the developers testing its upcoming version of iOS and OS X; while theres no announcement yet of plans for Android devices, one expects that will come with time.
Its a big deal if only for the massively widening scope of emoji use in our daily lives. According to New York Magazine, a 2013 survey found that 74 per cent of Americans and 82 per cent of those in China said they used emoji or Facebook stickers in message appsnumbers that have certainly only increased since then. For those of a certain set, emojis are grammatical second nature, a way to convey emotions, to sexually tempt, to show support, to communicate across generations; theyve exploded in popularity since they first developed in 1999, and were universally coded for mass devices in October 2010.
And there is a lot to say about the normalization of our media, about the belief that whiteness is our baseline, even as Caucasians become a racial minority in countries around the world. It is, no doubt, a problem; look no further than the marginalization of African-Americans from the Academy Awards, or the quiet neutering of Asian actors and actresses. A New York Times feature just this weekend helped expose the insidious bias against black people in photography: In our time, as in previous generations, cameras and the mechanical tools of photography have rarely made it easy to photograph black skin, wrote Teju Cole. Beginning in the mid-1940s, the smaller film-developing units manufactured by Kodak came with Shirley cards, so-named after the white model who was featured on them and whose whiteness was marked on the cards as normal. Across a wide swath of pop culture, the idea that white is the standard has become ingrained.
The problem is, the idea and execution of racially representative emojis completely misses the point.
For starters, emojis never really had a race problem. The invention of Shigetaka Kurita, emoji have an Asian root that has in many ways been whitewashed over, with many of the original ones depicting Japanese-centric images like a bowing businessman; it is why many of the food items in Unicodes emojis are Japanese, from ramen to tempura shrimp. According to the Wall Street Journal, initially supposed to depict characters with inhuman, cartoon-like complexions for example, a yellow or orange colour.
So the standard baseline in emojis was never really whitethats a later interpretation that society has applied. If anything, the race problem is with Unicode, the consortium that codes symbols and images so that they can be displayed across the worlds many platforms and devices, which took Kuritas initial offering, sidelined many of the Japan-centric ones, and produced a selection of 722. (Personal research finds that Apple devices currently feature 845 emojis.)
And the reality of racial representation is that it will, invariably, leave someone out and leave someone unhappy. It has already begun; social media has noted that there is no one with freckles and red hair among the six new colour options for each emoji. The backlash has started, too, as some have been furious over the bright yellow of what they are seeing as the East Asian skin colourironic, since theyre actually referring to the aforementioned cartoon-like emoji complexion as Asians are not technically depicted at all, given the fact that the new emojis reportedly hew to the Fitzpatrick scale, a dermatological standard for judging race. (The Fitzpatrick scale did not adequately measure non-white skin colour for years after its 1975 creation, dumping all non-white skin into one category.) Theres perhaps nothing more problematic than Chinese people seeing themselves as the cartoonish bright yellow initially designed to mean literally nothing. But anyway.
That doesnt even cover the fact that racial representation in emojis squelches the very thing that makes emojis tick, which is their loose, ambiguous interpretative quality. New York Times tech reporter Jenna Wortham expounded on her favourite emoji, the tempura shrimp, in womanzines emoji issue: It reminds me of the way I feel when Im salty, in a prickly ball of funk that requires a couch, a fetal position, a bottle of wine and Netflixin that exact orderand thats how I use it to communicate a foul mood to one friend. With another, however, it only comes up in conversation about Mariah Carey. Something about her complexion and the way shes always stuffed into a tube-ish dress works as a proxy for a tiny cartoon image of a fried shrimp. And a friend of mine recently revealed that she occasionally sexts with emojisthe otherwise unassuming seashell and eggplant stand in for human anatomy, apparentlyand while it was a strange crash course to receive, it was a reminder that the fun of emojis are that they mean nothing, and therefore, can mean anything.
Indeed, of course, no one believes a penis is really an eggplant. And yet we are not crowing about the accurate representation of human genitals in emoji. So why do we really care about racial representation?
Unlike most languages, less precision serves emoji better. Emojis generality is exactly why its taken off as a universal language, not necessarily the efforts of some secretive coding consortium. Emoji are our modern-day shibbolethstheyre defined not by colour, but by context.
And while its hardly wrong to get our hackles up over race, it seems odd that the hill we are choosing to defend is the one where the baseline was an intentionally preposterous complexion for a fun thing whose use is derived by its ambiguity. So lets not let racial politics needlessly creep into our Woman Doing The Salsa: may your Fist emoji mean fist-bump or solidarity or Im-punching-you, no matter what shade it is.
what... no Mooselim Emojis??
” look no further than the marginalization of African-Americans from the Academy Awards”
Read far enough. Marginalization, or perhaps there was not an Oscar worthy performance from a black this tie around. What’s next? Affirmative action Academy awards, of should it just be everyone gets a trophy like kids soccer?
These miss the point entirely. There are 666 genders that are not represented!!!
Thank heavens. My life can be complete now. I have been worried sick about emoticons which are only white or yellow. Progressivism marches on!
Why can’t the thumbs up/down simply be BLUE (as on facebook) or green (up) and red (down) as on some news sites?
well, someone might think you’re “making an image of Muhamed” and come cut your head off.
By the way, I made an image of Muhamed this morning, and I felt much relieved afterwards.
ahh - they originally were yellow, after the “smiley face” of the 70’s, which was the sun.
“I left obama in the Outhouse”
And in a few hours, someone will complain about the lack of “trans” emojis.
Yeah, that first cup of coffee is the sculptor's muse. ;-)
Why do the dark skinned women have blue eyes and where are the red skinned people?
Virtual Marilyn - VM2 - animated stickers will soon be available in both places and other sites. I am involved in this project. One of the preliminary sites under construction is VM2.tv.
If anyone here has the expertise to build apps, I would like to talk to you about becoming a part of this and other projects.
I see no Asians among the “women with bunny ears”
It reminds me of the way I feel when Im salty, in a prickly ball of funk that requires a couch, a fetal position, a bottle of wine and Netflixin that exact orderand thats how I use it to communicate a foul mood to one friend. With another, however, it only comes up in conversation about Mariah Carey."
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.