What if Kavanaugh turns out to be another ‘Justice’ Roberts?
Then we live with it
As matters know stand, it wouldnt matter a whit if Justice Roberts had two votes and Kavanaugh none - we hope.At any given time someone (or two) justice(s) dominate the court by being the only persuadables. That was Justice Kennedy, after OConnor retired. While OConnor was on the Court, we had to hope that both OConnor and Kennedy went the right way - and if either one of them didnt, the decision would be wrong.
As matters now stand, Roberts is now the Democrats hope. If Kavanaugh is another Roberts like Kennedy was another OConnor, I agree that will be worse - but at least we can hope that neither Kavanaugh nor Roberts comes to be another OConnor - or Kennedy.
The next big test is Nov. 6; if the Senate improves then well have good hope for a sound Court if one of the Dem-nominated justices leaves SCOTUS. And we could then look with equanimity on the prospective retirement of Thomas. If not, wed have to hope to be able to hold or expand our lead in the 2020 cohort of Senators. Not as easy a task as gaining ground now. Republicans wont have nearly as good a chance again for another 6 years.
“What if Kavanaugh turns out to be another Justice Roberts?”