Wouldn't closing an alternate route, regardless of how it's being used in normal daily traffic, create more issues during such a high traffic event?
There is a tendency for people to forget that much of South Jersey, especially the Cape May peninsula, is literally built on a foundation of sand. Sinkholes are to be taken seriously. Imagine the stink if the sinkhole collapsed while being pounded by an unusual volume of traffic This is a prudent safety precaution on the part of NJDOT.