combat_boots,
do you think total independence for Puerto Rico is a bad thing?
Why do you ask?
IMO, if Puerto Rico can self sustain, economically, no. However, strategically, the US would have to retain some territory militarily, e.g., Ft Buchanan & the high ground.
This would mean, however, that Puerto Ricans would have to survive without US aid/money. I don’t know what that economy would look like there, or, the working situation. Barrios after dark are their own experience.
I will say that I don’t like most of the hotels. They’re a garish and boring contrast to the way the people live. Also, the cruise ships in town remind me of the Navy being in port.