Skip to comments.Obamacare, ACA, healthcare, medicaid
Posted on 02/22/2018 8:54:06 AM PST by spintreebob
Norma Diaz and her husband, Joseph Garcia, have dedicated their careers to running a nonprofit health insurer that covers some of Californias neediest residents. For three decades, they have worked for a Medicaid managed-care plan, Community Health Group, serving nearly 300,000 poor and disabled patients in San Diego County under a state contract funded entirely by taxpayers. Theyve earned above-average ratings for patient care.
And in the process, theyve made millions of dollars.
Together, Diaz and Garcia made $1.1 million in 2016 and received more than $5 million since 2012. Diazs compensation as CEO exceeded the pay of several peers at bigger plans in 2016.
Garcia, married to Diaz since 1997, is an outside consultant who serves as chief operating officer. Their health plan, with $1.2 billion in annual revenue, had a profit margin of 19 percent in 2016, the highest of any Medicaid insurer in California and more than six times the industry average.
This is not only a conflict of interest but egregious overpayments, Frank Glassner, chief executive of Veritas Executive Compensation Consultants in San Francisco, said. Its the family-and-friends plan.
The arrangement at this midsize California health plan raises broader questions about government oversight as states award billions of dollars in public money to private plans to cover patients on Medicaid, the federal-state insurance program for the poor.
Evidence is mounting that Medicaids rapid expansion under the Affordable Care Act has far outstripped the governments ability to monitor the taxpayer money it turns over to insurers. In California the state is now trying to claw back billions in overpayments, a recent Kaiser Health News investigation found.
Medicaid enrollment has soared to 74 million Americans, from 58 million before the ACA rollout. (The 16 million without insurance who got insurance under Obamacare) About 75 percent of them are assigned to plans like Community Health Group, which receive a flat monthly fee per person to handle their medical care.
Increasingly, states have embraced managed care in hopes of controlling Medicaid costs. Insurers could see further growth as the Trump administration and Congress seek to cut federal spending on Medicaid and shift more of the fiscal burden onto states.
These managed-care contracts can be highly lucrative for the companies involved and their executives, like Diaz and Garcia. Any money left over after spending on medical care and administration is profit or surplus, depending on whether the plan is nonprofit.
Federal auditors have warned for years about lax oversight of Medicaid money, a task that primarily falls to states. A 2017 report found that even as managed care has grown in importance, states have fallen behind in collecting essential data from plans.
In the past year alone, government auditors and consultants criticized Illinois, Kansas and Mississippi for poor supervision of Medicaid insurers. Illinois auditors said the state didnt properly monitor $7.1 billion paid to Medicaid plans in fiscal year 2016, leaving the program unable to determine what percentage of money went to medical care as opposed to administrative costs or profit.
An examination of Community Health Group in California points to systemic flaws in oversight.
For instance, California officials said they do not examine the companies public tax filings. As a social welfare nonprofit, Community Health does not pay taxes, but it is required to file returns with the federal government, known as 990s, which provide basic information about operations and finances.
KHN discovered that the company falsely denied on the 2015 and 2016 forms that it was doing business with a family member.
In response, the insurer immediately said that was an error and it was amending the returns to reflect its relationship with Garcia. The company had disclosed the relationship in earlier years.
Californias Medicaid agency, in a statement, said insurers are allowed to set their own conflict-of-interest policies. Asked specifically about Community Health Group, it referred further questions back to the health plan.
Likewise, the states chief insurance regulators at the Department of Managed Health Care said in a statement that insurers are not required to submit information on executive compensation and the state does not set standards for that. They do review the pay of outside contractors.
Diaz, 56, said her husband reports not to her but to a fellow executive, the associate CEO, and his consultants role was approved by the health plans board. I dont feel for me its a conflict of interest because he was here for many years long before we ever got married, so we got used to a working relationship, she said.
Garcia, 66, served as the companys on-staff chief operating officer for about 15 years and then switched in 2011 to the role of consultant (acting as COO), which ultimately raised his pay. He said the couple has never tried to hide their personal relationship from the state or anyone else.
I understand from the outside someone might say Oh my God. Thats a conflict. But its not. Its irrelevant that Im her husband, he said. I dont see how its a misuse of public funds. The expense for a chief operating officer would be made no matter what, and my compensation is fair.
His total compensation reached $487,386 in 2016, according to the insurer. From 2012 to 2016, the health plan paid him a total $2.3 million.
Under his consulting agreement, Garcia is paid $275 an hour and can make as much as $572,000 annually, according to documents obtained by KHN through a public records request. The health plan had requested the information be kept confidential, but the state released it.
In September, regulators at the managed-care department asked Community Health Group how Garcias pay was determined.
Community Health said it picked the maximum figure in the range, $442,863, to reflect Garcias many years of experience in health plan operations. It then increased his pay range by 30 percent because it said Garcia doesnt receive benefits. The plan called his current salary which in 2016 fell below the maximum allowed both fair and competitive.
An agency spokesman said the states review of the matter is closed.
Joseph. He has a tremendous amount of knowledge, said Albert Vitela, a retired San Diego police detective who is the plans co-founder and chairman.
As for Diaz, she has received $2.8 million in salary, benefits and other compensation over the five years ending in 2016. Her 2016 pay of $604,502 exceeded that of the CEO of the Inland Empire Health Plan in Southern California, which has four times the enrollment.
Last year, federal auditors examined compensation for the 133 top paid executives at managed-care organizations in seven states, focused on health plans that get more than half of their revenue from Medicaid.
For 2015, the top executives earned $314,278, on average more than double what state Medicaid directors earned, according to the report. Auditors didnt find major differences in pay between for-profit and nonprofit Medicaid plans.
Executive compensation has risen as Community Health Group recorded hefty profits.
State officials had raised the rates paid to Medicaid plans in anticipation of the Affordable Care Act rollout in 2014, but the costs for newly insured patients werent as high as predicted. After the KHN investigation into insurer profits published in November, Californias Medicaid director, Jennifer Kent, vowed to recoup billions of dollars in excessive payments from insurers in coming months.
Robert Stern, a government ethics expert and former general counsel of Californias Fair Political Practices Commission, welcomed the scrutiny of Medicaid profits. But he said the business practices at Community Health Group suggest there is much more to be done.
Taxpayer money should be spent as wisely as possible, Stern said. Its not their money. Its our money.
Do you have a Medicaid story? Contact Senior Correspondent Chad Terhune at firstname.lastname@example.org or via Signal at 657-226-0625
Now with tens of millions of people added to SSI/SSDI and Medicaid, we are discovering that Corporatism is (almost) as flawed as is Socialism.
As bad as VA and Tricare which is a lot of trouble with the roll out of its new system. Bad enough the DoD MANDATE on Tricare Life that all daily scripts are gotten from Military base or Express Scripts. With the USPS just shoving meds in unsecure mail boxes NO ID required. These are NOT inexpensive meds. Whelcol for Cholesterol for 90 days retails at $1,000. If you send it back, then some one is not going to get their meds for over 2 months. Just easier to take it over to their house as most are somewhere with in a few houses in a large Ret. Military area.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.