[ksen]

I think the Haldir of the film is universally not liked, but were we supposed to like him at first?

Call me kooky but I liked the book version of Haldir. That spilled over to the movie version, although he was definitely snootier in the movie. If that is really him during that scene at the top of the wall at Helm's Deep I won't be disappointed. I think he would be a good man, er, elf, to have at your side in a battle.

-Kevin

[HairOfTheDog]

RE: Haldir... I won't call you kooky... I thought Haldir fit. I pictured the Lothlorien elves - especially the guards, to be fairly cold to outsiders. - Snooty, if you will. I don't mind him either.