On the other hand, I am not sure anyone wants to live under a benign dictatorship or oligarchy.
Agreed, I don't think they can be said to have been better off under apartheid, without freedom. But it every measureable way they were.
Well, it probably would have helped if they had not embraced totalitarians, communism, and socialism after the colonial governments left. The ANC ideology of socialism/communims has wrecked every single economy it has toyed with. Countries like the United States and India have faired far better because of capitalistic systems after colonialism.