Replies

Look: Possibly there would be some abstract justice in closing down the settlements, I don't know. I don't see it myself, I must admit. Why should Jews not live among Arabs? Lots of Arabs live in Israel, and do very well there. There are rich Israeli Arabs; there are Israeli-Arab pop stars and comedians; there are Israeli-Arab intellectuals, teachers, writers, businessmen, athletes. Why, when the whole thing gets sorted out, should there not be Jews living in Arab territory — as there were for centuries past? What, exactly, is wrong with the settlements? I don't see it.

The Israeli settlements are, according to the Fourth Geneva Convention, illegal colonies of an occupying power. Israel has used security for the settlements as an excuse to set up an oppressive apartheid-like system of controls over the Arab population of the West Bank and Gaza. The Israeli settlers are part-and-parcel of the barbaric Israeli occupation. Jews who want to live peacefully among Arabs in the West Bank or Gaza should apply to live there as ordinary residents, subject to local laws.

Do you honestly believe that if Israel gave back the occupied territories, that the rest of the region would leave them alone?

We have had problems with this region since the beginning, hell, even Thomas Jefferson sent the military to the area to clean things up... this whole obsession with Israel is but a headache compared the the brain tumor that really exists.

The Israeli settlements are, according to the Fourth Geneva Convention, illegal colonies of an occupying power. Israel has used security for the settlements as an excuse to set up an oppressive apartheid-like system of controls over the Arab population of the West Bank and Gaza. The Israeli settlers are part-and-parcel of the barbaric Israeli occupation. Jews who want to live peacefully among Arabs in the West Bank or Gaza should apply to live there as ordinary residents, subject to local laws.

Where were those settlements pre-67 and why is it that your Arab Islamic nazis still sent suicide missions, armed insurgents, and Arab armies into Israel to attack the Jewish populace? I guess the same arguments apply to Israel proper, i.e., no Jew except dhimmi or dead Jew for you and your Arab Islamic nazi friends.

Jews who want to live peacefully among Arabs in the West Bank or Gaza should apply to live there as ordinary residents, subject to local laws.

The are no "local laws" in the PA-controlled areas, there is only anarchy.

The Israeli settlements are, according to the Fourth Geneva Convention, illegal colonies of an occupying power.

You have a fundamental misunderstanding of the Geneva Convention which allows you to make these incorrect statements. The territories are not illegal colonies and Israel is not an occupying power. Whose land are they occupying except their own, won in a defensive war? Remember, there has NEVER been a Palestinian state. Thus, you are wrong. But I don't expect reality to change your mind.

Israel has used security for the settlements as an excuse to set up an oppressive apartheid-like system of controls over the Arab population of the West Bank and Gaza.

Specify exactly what these controls are and tell us how they could be considered aparthied.

The Israeli settlers are part-and-parcel of the barbaric Israeli occupation.

Arab propaganda is your stock in trade. There is no occupation and Israeli treatment of the Arabs is benign compared to what they deserve and need, i.e., denazification. And, lest we forget, in 1967 when Israel won the lands in a defensive war, the Israeli government offered to provide humanitarian assistance to the Arabs who lived there. This offer was refused by the UN and the other Arab countries. Why?

Jews who want to live peacefully among Arabs in the West Bank or Gaza should apply to live there as ordinary residents, subject to local laws.

It is a crime, punishable by death, to sell land to a Jew under the dictates of the Palestinian Authority. This is what you support.

Oh, and, by the way, the subject of this thread is Kill a Jew for Allah. I assume, based on your response, that it is perfectly fine with you to murder Jews because of all your allegations. If not, please explain why you are attempting to hijack this thread with your falsehoods.

the hell with those anti-semitic conventions

No one buys your Muslim lies that if only Israel would unilaterally withdraw from the West Bank or Gaza there would be peace. This is number one Muslim lie. The attempt to fool liberal Europeans and Americans. Anyone with some common sense can see the aggressive nuclear Pakistan that is the Muslim homeland next to India. And has never given India peace. And was created by the British over the objections of the majority Hindus.

Islam is all about war and lies for their neighbors. Any gains or treaties the Islamics sign are all just stepping stones to conquering and subjugation of their neighbors. Your fat slob Mullahs preach as much from time to time depending on how hopped up they are.

Jews are only occupying those territories because they won them fair and square in a war the Arabs started.