In any case, you did not answer the question. WHy don't they have the same rights that Arabs do to the holy sites? Only Arab rights are to be defended but Jews not? SOunds like bigotry to me. Zinni should demand equal access, isn't that what we are all about in the US? Are you denying it is a holy site? BTW- there are religious opinions that do allow them to act, most of us happen to disagree, but that is not for you to decide as a secular commentator.
I have not answered your question of an assertion that I HAVE NOT MADE.
As far as I'm concerned "rights" are not at issue here. Just as I did not question Sharon's "right" to go to The Wall in December,(October?) 2000. I question the prudence.