Replies

How about this scenario--a baby is being born, breech. Her father is in the service overseas for the past 3 months. She is just beginning to emerge from the womb. The "still-legally-pregnant" woman doesn't realize, until that moment, that the female fetus is "racially mixed." The woman was sure she had taken adequate precautions, during a one night stand, nine months before. Her husband will know the child is not his.

Should the doctor follow the woman's directive and perform a partial birth abortion so the husband will not ealize his wife had an affair?

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I was under the impression that skin color did not become apparant for some time after birth. I don't think that the doctor would be able to tell by the baby's feet what color his daddy is. In addition, what doctor would say to a woman in the middle of a breach birth, "Doesn't look like Daddy is who we thought."

What's wrong with the woman giving the child up for adoption and telling the husband the child died in birth? Considering the woman is already lying to her husband - he doesn't know she's had an affair. . . I would hope she would rather her conscience carry a second lie than the knowledge she killed her child.

Some women view their child's birth by looking in a mirror, so the woman might be the one to notice the baby looked different than she expected.

I don't have answers to all your other points, but since this is a hypothetical situation I can try to change things a bit to make the example more suitable for this discussion.

For example, let's say the baby's real father's feet have extra digits or some other distinguishing characteristic-- so it is the woman (not the doctor) who realizes who is really the baby's father. If only males can inherit the characteristic, we'll make the baby a male.