Posted on 04/15/2002 10:32:10 AM PDT by SlickWillard
April 15, 2002
ALM SPRINGS, Calif., April 12 — When Boston church officials granted the Rev. Paul R. Shanley a medical leave 12 years ago and allowed him to move here, they saw it as a chance for him to heal various physical ailments, primarily allergies, in the desert air, and to do a little pastoral work if and when he was well enough.
At his insistence, Father Shanley's Boston superiors arranged for regular checks to be sent to him for living expenses and medical bills, and sent laudatory letters of recommendation to their counterparts at the Diocese of San Bernardino, carefully avoiding mention of a swirl of accusations that he had molested more than two dozen young boys in Massachusetts going back to 1967.
What his superiors appeared not to know, however, was that the address to which they were sending Father Shanley's checks for most of his time here was the Cabana Club Resort, one of the many hotels that cater to the town's gays. Father Shanley became an owner of the hotel, along with the Rev. John J. White, another Boston priest who was also on sick leave and receiving money from the Boston Archdiocese. Father White was the sole owner of a second hotel, the nearby Whispering Palms.
Neither remains in business, although the scene they were part of is thriving, with 40 such hotels and bed-and-breakfasts, mostly in the Warm Sands enclave. These clothing-optional places, protected from prying eyes by walls and towering bougainvillea, do year-round business for gay men from around the world.
Interviews with some of his acquaintances in Palm Springs paint a picture of a man who immersed himself in the local gay scene soon after his arrival in 1990, although most people who remember him said he was quieter and less outgoing than Father White. On occasion, he helped out at St. Anne Church in San Bernardino, celebrating a weekend Mass or leading youth retreats.
"My biggest surprise was that Paul was a priest at all," said John Kendrick, 47, co-owner of Inn Exile, a hotel that he expanded after buying the Whispering Palms, next door, from Father White in 1994. "I didn't know you could be a part-time priest."
The disclosures about Father Shanley, 70, who vanished from his San Diego apartment building almost three weeks ago, have added heat to the controversy surrounding Cardinal Bernard F. Law of Boston, depicted in documents released on Monday as being consistently supportive of priests like Father Shanley and John J. Geoghan.
Both were shuttled from parish to parish, even as evidence of abuses gathered against them, without regard to whether they had further contacts with children. Father Geoghan was later defrocked and convicted of indecent assault. Father Shanley has not been charged with a crime, although the Boston Archdiocese has settled at least three lawsuits against him.
Officials at the San Bernardino Diocese who were supposedly watching over Father Shanley during his sojourn in Palm Springs said last week they had known nothing of his activities in Warm Sands.
Kevin Rice, 46, who has lived in Palm Springs for 14 years, got to know Fathers White and Shanley after he sold them space in Frontier News magazine for advertisements promoting the two hotels.
"I knew Jack was a priest and thought he wasn't practicing," Mr. Rice said. "Jack introduced Shanley as someone he knew from his days in the seminary."
Mr. Rice said that Father White "seemed to be a little off the wall" but that Father Shanley was a "very nice guy, personable." Father Shanley was "more of the business person," Mr. Rice said. "He had his head on straighter. There's no question about it, he's a very charismatic man."
Having once stayed at the Whispering Palms, Mr. Rice described the resort as "one of the friskier places." Nude sunbathing was encouraged, and sex by the pool was permitted, he said.
The two priests sold the Cabana Club Resort for $185,000 in 1997, three years after Father White had disposed of the Whispering Palms for $389,000. It is not clear how much they profited from the sales of the hotels, or at which point they stopped receiving money from the Boston Archdiocese.
Father Shanley seemed unable to understand that he had hurt anyone in his years as an active Roman Catholic priest, and painted himself as a victim.
"I have done nothing wrong," he wrote in a letter dated March 14, 1991, to Father John B. MacCormack, then a senior aide to Cardinal Law and now bishop in Manchester, N.H. In the letter, he also wrote: "Do the decent thing. Allow me, quietly, to retire, or put me on permanent disability. Remove the unpredictability and my health will return. This is cruel and unusual punishment."
Yet diocesan officials went out of their way to help him. In 1995, they transferred Father Shanley to New York, where he became acting director of Leo House, a guest house for students and clergy members. Two years later, he was denied a permanent post there when one of his accusers came forward. Then, with a longtime companion, Dale E. Lagace — who had been with him for part of his time in both Palm Springs and New York and is 21 years his junior — Father Shanley moved to Hillcrest, a district of San Diego favored by gays.
Reached at her home in Maine, Mr. Lagace's mother, Mona Stefanik Lambert, said tearfully that she had not spoken with her son in two weeks and did not know where he was. "This is a complete surprise, all of this," Ms. Lambert said. "I'm very hurt inside about the whole matter."
Melinda Lee, manager of the mustard-hued three-story Santa Fe Villas building on Albatross Street, where Father Shanley and Mr. Lagace pay $900 a month for a two-bedroom apartment, said the older man had described the younger as his caregiver.
Santa Fe Villas is almost directly across the street from the Florence Child Development Center, where dozens of children frolicked today. "I've been here the longest and I haven't seen him at all," said a teacher, Wanda Singleton, when told that Father Shanley lived close by.
Until last week, Father Shanley was a volunteer with the Retired Senior Volunteer Patrol, a San Diego Police Department program that puts about 500 elderly people to work. "He had no contact with kids," said a police officer who works with the volunteers. The department dropped Father Shanley after the accusations against him became public.
One of the priest's elderly neighbors, Milton D. Turner, said Father Shanley had introduced him to the voice of the British soprano Sarah Brightman. "I know him as a perfect gentleman and a great neighbor," Mr. Turner said.
Down in the manager's officer, Mrs. Lee said she had no idea that Father Shanley was a priest, let alone that he had been accused of molesting children.
"It just goes to show you — you need to check up on people," Mrs. Lee said. "I told him once he had an ethereal quality. He thought that was a nice compliment."
1) How does someone who has sworn a vow of poverty use his monthly stipend check to purchase a $185,000 hotel, much less one that goes for $389,000? There may be more truth to the blackmail rumors than people care to admit. Another possibility is that they were running a prostitution ring to supplement their income.2) Since when does Ye Ol' Gray Lady run hit pieces on gay men? She must be feeling some heat from this scandal...
I thought that all priests took vows of poverty, chastity and obedience, but such is not the case. Although it should be, IMHO.
Since when does Ye Ol' Gray Lady run hit pieces on gay men?
If some gays get hit in the Times unending assault on Christianity, they’re just well-dressed collateral damage.
Someone needs to find this guy and cut his penis off.
Don't you guys think you're being just a little too long-winded?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.