Me, too. I took my son to see a very good production of Godspell a year-plus ago in NoCal - it was updated very nicely. The "Long Live God/Prepare Ye" ending ALWAYS makes me cry.
Can I ask why you find the last scene of Godspell so wonderful? I saw it about ten years ago (unaware of the show's content) and I thought the last scene was horrible. I was sitting there waiting for the next scene! My impression was that the ending conveys the meaning: Jesus was a good teacher and even though he's dead now, his teaching and legacy will live on in our memories. I can't see how anyone who puts their hope in the ressurection of Jesus would be anything but appalled at how that musical ends.